Hi guys, I want to buy a new case and have narrowed it down to these two cases. I just need it for scratch protection and maybe minor drops. My questions are: which of these two cases fits better with the official extended battery, and which of these two cases is slimmer? Thanks
If you plan are running it with an extended battery then the diztronic for sure. The Ultra Hybrid wont fit right.
Just to make sure, I have the i9250M version which I will be running with the 2000mAh extended battery. That will not fit perfectly with the Ultra Hybrid, correct?
Someone posted pics of the case on his LTE galaxy nexus + 2100 mah battery.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=26895098
I know that you have the GSM version with the 2000mah battery. It is a little slimmer, but I suspect similar results. Perhaps not as bad, but still. It will go on the phone, but the sides will not completely cover.
BTW the ultra hybrid is on sale from the official site. I have the GSM + extended also and might buy one anyways and try to bend out that plastic part. The thing that makes the "hump" in the back.
4Pr3mier said:
BTW the ultra hybrid is on sale from the official site. I have the GSM + extended also and might buy one anyways and try to bend out that plastic part. The thing that makes the "hump" in the back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The back piece feels like hard polycarbonate, you might have to heat it up to change the shape. It's going to be difficult to make it look good.
That's what I'm thinking. $13 is somewhat cheap enough to mess around with it. The website is OOS on the black one now, so I guess I won't be doing this anymore.
Diztronic is where's it at. I'm also using the 2100mAh battery, fits perfectly.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
mbh87 said:
If you plan are running it with an extended battery then the diztronic for sure. The Ultra Hybrid wont fit right.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nah it fits, just not as perfectly as the original battery but the case won't fall out or looks weird.
There's just a little gap on the bottom of the camera cutout and the edge near the volume and on/off buttons doesn't go up all the way.
MilkPudding said:
Nah it fits, just not as perfectly as the original battery but the case won't fall out or looks weird.
There's just a little gap on the bottom of the camera cutout and the edge near the volume and on/off buttons doesn't go up all the way.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Like I said, it doesn't fit right. Never said it would never fit at all
Hmm...I did not know that the GSM with EB is slimmer than the LTE with EB. I saw those pictures earlier, and the fact that the phone bulges out on the sides bothers me a lot. Does anyone know how much slimmer the GSM variants is to the LTE (both with EB)?
I have the Dizitronic case (among others) and primarily use it when I am not doing anything 'active'. Its definitely slim and looks good. Fit on it is great (GSM with standard battery). For $10, its a great purchase.
For what its worth, it is slim enough to also be used with a leather belt pouch as well.
Haven't used the SGP but it looks very nice as well.
i really wanted to keep the ultra hybrid but the really high sensitivity of the power button was a dealbreaker. just a light brush over the power button would turn the device on.
ceejay83 said:
i really wanted to keep the ultra hybrid but the really high sensitivity of the power button was a dealbreaker. just a light brush over the power button would turn the device on.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How long did you use it for?
ceejay83 said:
i really wanted to keep the ultra hybrid but the really high sensitivity of the power button was a dealbreaker. just a light brush over the power button would turn the device on.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you're handy with small tools, it's pretty easy to adjust the stub inside the case where the button is, and make it less sensitive. A dremel tool with a tiny sanding wheel, or a dental drill when your dentist isn't looking , will do the trick. Or even some small hand tool to carve away some of it could work.
I was taking a few unintended screenshots the first week until I adjusted both the power button and the volume buttons.
SefEXE said:
How long did you use it for?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
for a few days. in that short time i couldn't deal with it.
sanding/modifying it is too much of a hassle. rather get a refund than messing the case up
Related
After reading a few threads here about the best case, I decided that I will purchase a TPU case (clear smoke argyle). I was looking at ebay and see the same item/design by these 2 sellers. One is $3.87 other is $7.49. Anyone know what the difference between these 2 is?
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=370473226743 - $3.87
http://cgi.ebay.com/Argyle-Smoke-Flexi-Skin-Cover-Samsung-Vibrant-T959-/310291583683 - $7.49
There is another for $6.95 it says that it comes in a retail package, where as the first one it says it's "generic." Looks the same to me in the pictures.
http://cgi.ebay.com/SMOKE-Argyle-So...617919?pt=PDA_Accessories&hash=item255d54a37f
Any help? Oh, and I looked around a lot, but wasn't able to find one without the argyle pattern that is also clear smoke. (didn't like the hybrid one too much). Anyone away of any such case?
Thanks!
I bought a smoke case from accstation and it seems to fit well, but the case is so rigid that the case over the power and volume keys make it very hard to press the keys. After some careful stretching they seem to work well enough, at the aesthetic expense of those small areas of the case. I also bought a similar Purple TPU case from post3rs on Ebay. It seemed to have the same issue over the power and volume buttons. I've dropped the vibrant on concrete from 4 feet 3 times with that case and so far it's saved me, and i'm considering cutting out the power + volume with a razor knife.......... Not sure how some of the more pricey cases compare in this arena but it's worth mentioning my experience.
i think they are all the same cases, but rustychiles is right, its extraordinarily rigid making the buttons hard to press, i would recommend that "best case" over the argyle one since its far easier to press the buttons, on the other hand, it is a nice looking case
also, to rustychiles, don't cut out the buttons, they will become recessed and much harder to press, i tried that with a cheap silicone case cause i didnt like it and i was curious too, it doesnt work
Thanks for the reply guys.
@bdroc, which "best case" are you referring to?
its that thread about "the best case in the world"
http://www.daydeal.com/product.php?productid=45703&cat=5085
bdroc said:
its that thread about "the best case in the world"
http://www.daydeal.com/product.php?productid=45703&cat=5085
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Got it, thanks. I ended up going with the TPU argyle case. Not a big fan of the pattern, but I like the feel of TPU more than the hard plastic in the hybrid version.
be sure to give us your review on it when you get it!
btw, is it a hard cover or soft cover?
Ok, will do. It's a TPU case, so I think the feel of it will lie somewhere between soft silicone and hard plastic. Just the way I like it -semi soft or semi hard, depends on how you look at it.
drcrappants said:
be sure to give us your review on it when you get it!
btw, is it a hard cover or soft cover?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh BTW, if you are interested, someone already posted a mini review and pics for the TPU argyle case here, which is what convinced me to get this case. I think there's also pics in the "best case" thread here on xda.
http://androidforums.com/vibrant-accessories/117168-samsung-vibrant-cases-6.html#post1626153
Get the cheapest one you can get because you are going to have to cut out the buttons anyway. I have 2 of the TPUs and they are the best cases out there. Both of the TPUs were the same materials and the buttons are so hard to press you have to cut them out, which I did. I highly recommend TPUs.
I have 5 other types of cases (non-TPU) like Gel, etc and I can say that TPU offers the best combination of protection and feel. It doesnt catch lint in your pockets like other types do. I dropped it many times and no scratches whatsoever.
rustychiles said:
I bought a smoke case from accstation and it seems to fit well, but the case is so rigid that the case over the power and volume keys make it very hard to press the keys. After some careful stretching they seem to work well enough, at the aesthetic expense of those small areas of the case. I also bought a similar Purple TPU case from post3rs on Ebay. It seemed to have the same issue over the power and volume buttons. I've dropped the vibrant on concrete from 4 feet 3 times with that case and so far it's saved me, and i'm considering cutting out the power + volume with a razor knife.......... Not sure how some of the more pricey cases compare in this arena but it's worth mentioning my experience.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Update: Instead of cutting out the case over the power and volume buttons I heated up a flat head screwdriver with a flame and gently thinned out the TPU case over the power and volume buttons by gently melting and stretching the case and couldn't be happier with the results. The cases don't melt the way you want them to, and aesthetically I could probably do better next time by using a hot surface the same size as the area I am stretching but it doesn't look that bad and it's as functional as I'd like it to be now.
Don't cut the case! As someone else said, it makes the buttons recessed and hard to press. Take a small piece of tape and place it on the insides of the case, under the power and volume buttons. Works a lot better.
quest4fire said:
Get the cheapest one you can get because you are going to have to cut out the buttons anyway. I have 2 of the TPUs and they are the best cases out there. Both of the TPUs were the same materials and the buttons are so hard to press you have to cut them out, which I did. I highly recommend TPUs.
I have 5 other types of cases (non-TPU) like Gel, etc and I can say that TPU offers the best combination of protection and feel. It doesnt catch lint in your pockets like other types do. I dropped it many times and no scratches whatsoever.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i agree, TPU is one of the best cases. i first got a TPU case for my iphone 3g and i loved it so much that when i bought my vibrant i got the exact same case for it
after the first day, i also learned that the buttons couldn't be pressed so i had to take an x acto knife to cut the holes out. now its not so bad
LOL @ cutting / blowtorching the cases... i used the tape method.
Get stronger fingers.
-bZj
XDAapp
down8 said:
Get stronger fingers.
-bZj
XDAapp
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
THIS...quit being a *****.
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA App
What is that--tape method?
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA App
No need to cutout button...after couple of days it gets softer to press.
Hi guys,
Got my hands on the NGP from Incipio, an awesome TPU case that offers good protection while keeping a slim form factor. It is comfortable, lightweight and cutouts on the case are spot-on. Watch the video review for all info.
Anyone know how it compares to SGP's ultra-capsule?
L Eric said:
Anyone know how it compares to SGP's ultra-capsule?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup, I've been sent the Ultra Capsule for review as well, the Ultra Capsule is a lot more flexible but the buttons are WONDERFULLY easy to press. The Ultra Capsule is glossy whereas the NGP has a soft touch backing, I like it better since it provides better grip.
Cutouts are a little better on the Ultra Capsule but overall both cases are great.
Another good video, thank you
Missing the TV antenna port.
evildave_666 said:
Missing the TV antenna port.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Apologies, my version does not have it so I forgot about it - but you are right, this is made specifically for the i9100 version.
SGP Ultra Capsule Silicone Case for Samsung Galaxy S II i9100 [Infinity White]
07/22/2011 Order shipped
Mmm, Ordered it yesterday...
HongKong to The Netherlands 3/4 days..?
Greetings from The Netherlands
saw your post and ordered it even before the video finished...hope i finally will be satisfied with buying cases
Nimroth said:
saw your post and ordered it even before the video finished...hope i finally will be satisfied with buying cases
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm sure you'll be pleased with the case!
Are buttons really hard to press?
I'm looking for such case... it seems to be parfect except this one little issue...
Its harder and lacks feedback but it means u dont accidentally change volume which is what i do when i dont use a case
The micro usb cut out is a little small but the oem cable and charger fit fine
However my blackberry micro usb cable cant fit in fully
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
Thanks for the vid. I bought the magenta one. Can't wait to receive it. Looks like it offers good protection and still manages to maintain a thin profile. A Win-Win case for me.
I like the Neo Hybrid too but wasn't too thrilled about the antenna cutout.
Just picked one up recently after purchasing a Casemate Barely There the day prior. Of the 50+ stores in my million + city NONE had them in stock. That is until I found the 51st retailer. FWIW I like the Barely There as well.
Overall a very good case. Same price point as the SGP Neo Hybrid, similar dimensions, etc... but higher quality. It's replacing a Neo Hybrid which suffered from the sag on the back side of the phone; I ran double side tape for a while, which worked, but then it pissed me off that I had to run double sided tape.
As much as I liked the Neo Hybrid initially, it wasn't worth the price IMO considering its construction, and sag issue. At the end of the day it costed more than the Incipio after factoring in shipping, etc... and it's not nearly as good. $25-30 isn't going to break the bank, but that's not the point.
Both: look good, are "economical", are slender, lightweight, and offer some protection.
The Neo Hybrid: would be a better case if it were priced at $15 and the rubber didn't sag after many heat cycles.
The Incipio: worth the cost, and much higher quality materials and build quality.
Caveat: This post will be updated if I experience any issues with the Incipio.
And yes, the power button is hard to press. I hold my phone with my left hand, and it takes much more force to press the power button with my index finger if I'm in one hand mode. Not as much of an issue for you right handers since you can use your thumb.
Curious if anyone has done "surgery" to the power button with a sharp knife? I'm thinking of making a small incision on either side to lighten up the action a bit.
Edit: micro USB port is "tight"; takes a little bit more force to attach the cable to the phone. It doesn't appear to alter the angle the micro USB enters the port however, so I doubt it will lead to charging port damage. Will see if it wears the case to accommodate itself before I break out the knife.
Can the power button be modified? Perhaps stick something inside the case to make the button more responsive?
Another question - has anyone tried the case with the Samsung 2000mah high capacity battery? It looks to me like the case would fit, but given how snug it is it may not.
Product Link: http://amzn.com/B0062V037Q
I'm not really prepared to give a full review of this case yet since I just put it on today and haven't "lived" with it for very long, but I wanted to go ahead and post some pics for anyone who might be interested. These pics are of a Galaxy Nexus LTE with extended battery. I believe it's designed to fit the LTE with standard battery, but it fits just fine with the extended battery.
What I can tell so far -- the glossy/gel part of this case is rubbery and sticks to hard surfaces, but doesn't seem to stick to fabric/clothes so i don't think it'll be a problem getting in and out of pockets. The matte part is like a textured plastic -- very smooth and not sticky at all. The gel fits around the front and sticks up only a fraction above the screen like it's supposed to, so you can lay it face down and the screen won't touch the surface. Anyway, here are the pics.
If I'm missing any angles that anyone wants to see, let me know and I'll take more pics. I'll try to add some more opinions about this case after I've carried it around a little.
how flexible is the case?
Thanks for sharing large photos, it really helps to show the fit of the case. Think I'll go ahead and order one.
For those who have a different case, it would be nice to see those cases posted in a similar fashion.
I have this case too and I believe it was molded to fit the GSM version. I've had both versions of the phone and it fit the GSM version perfectly. The Verizon version (even without the extended batt) does not fit quite right. You can see it clearly in your 4th pic how it bulges out and does not hug the edges of the screen area properly. I also don't care for the button areas, as they are both enclosed and make it difficult to locate the buttons by feel.
Thanks. I just picked up one in green and it seems to fit fine over the extended battery. I am still able to find the power button because it has a different texture than the rest of the side.
It will probably take a few days to see if it is better out worse that the gel I got at Verizon. So far, so good. And it was on sale!
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
You can find this for 2 dollars on Ebay.
http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_fro...TPU+Gel+Case+for+Samsung+Galaxy+Google+Nexus+
ludow said:
You can find this for 2 dollars on Ebay.
http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_fro...TPU+Gel+Case+for+Samsung+Galaxy+Google+Nexus+
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i don't think that is the same case. the one i got is made by Qubits.
@halo0: yes, i can tell this case wasn't made for the extended battery, and i can see what you're talking about in picture 4, but i don't notice any bulge in actual use, and i'm pretty anal about my cases.
also, like @VivianC mentioned, it's easy to find the power and volume buttons by touch because of the difference in texture.
ludow said:
You can find this for 2 dollars on Ebay.
http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_fro...TPU+Gel+Case+for+Samsung+Galaxy+Google+Nexus+
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My case was around £3 and is IDENTICAL to the pictures above and this link.
Don't spend more than $10/£5 on this case.
The reason why I am getting rid of this case is because it makes the screen/sleep button quite weird to press. (However, having this case for nearly a month you get used to it)
Sadly, lint and dirt collects easily around the lip of the case where it touches the screen.
There are NO issues with this case pulling up the screen protector edge. (I've read how someone said cheap TPU cases sometimes do this)
Does provides good protection for small knocks and drops! - Dropped my phone on wood floor twice and was well protected!
Got these on amazon for 8 each.green one for my girl black for myself. Barely noticeable and I actually think it fits better with the extend battery than the standard, mine (with extended battery) just feels better than hers without. Good skin, very pleased with it
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA App
I have three different colors (red, clear, and black) of this case and I have to say I am very pleased with them. They were made for the GSM version but they still fit pretty good with the CDMA's. (Small buldge that was previously mention) Paid $5 for the red and the clear one. $8 for the black one. I'd recommend it for those prices.
I've got this and I really don't like the button covers. They're to stiff for my liking. Amazon carries this for $9.99 with two screen protectors and a micro fiber pouch.
Sent from my ICY+ Galaxy Nexus
Here is a review of the Incipio NGP case for the Galaxy Nexus. Sorry for the out of focus at times. I was using the verizon version with extended battery.
Don't have time to watch the video right now, but you're using the GSM with the extended battery and the Verizon case? I've been waiting for a review like this if true
I also have the Incipio NGP case and I must admit I love it. The power button takes a little more pressure to press than I was expecting, but all in all, I still have no issues. Keeps the phone very light and slim.
I do wish they make more colors soon.
Here's some pics that are a little closer than the video.
I picked this case up as well and love it. I have had 2 other cases that I returned to due additional weight and bulkiness. I am using it with the extended battery and it fits fine. Like the guy above said the power button is a little off, but its not a big deal.
sdot770 said:
I also have the Incipio NGP case and I must admit I love it. The power button takes a little more pressure to press than I was expecting, but all in all, I still have no issues. Keeps the phone very light and slim.
I do wish they make more colors soon.
Here's some pics that are a little closer than the video.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah just received mine
gsm stock battery
tight fit
anybody know if spray paint works well with tpu type cases
The Spigen Neo Hybrid for the Nexus 5 is a solid case. I've received it from Amazon yesterday for a mere $20 and this case has been performing really well so far. All the ports are nicely cut and positioned. One drawback I've noticed is that the power and volume rocker buttons do have space to wiggle around a bit. You can slightly hear them rattling if you shake your phone but they aren't too big of a problem.The USB cutout is large and wide, making it possible to use almost any charging cable. The same applies to the headphone jack. The back of the case tends to show a few fingerprints but they can be wiped off easily. The case does provide a lip, so it is possible to lay the phone on the screen without worrying too much about getting it scratched (though it is not a big enough lip to be protective during falls on rough surfaces). I've attached a good amount of pictures since I am able to post them yet. Overall, I would recommend this case to someone because it's sleek and sturdy despite a few small drawbacks.
Nice
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
I've got the same case. Looks good. I'm still waiting for my phone though.
I've had my Neo Hybrid (silver edging) taunting me while sitting on the nightstand since Saturday. Cannot wait for my phone to arrive tomorrow.
Nice review. I've just ordered the Spigen ultra hybrid (with clear back) from Amazon. I'll post some pics and findings as soon as I have it.
is the case itself heavy?
thegtfusion said:
is the case itself heavy?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not really. The case doesn't add much bulk to the phone itself other than changing the size of the phone a tad bit.
Sharvil06 said:
Not really. The case doesn't add much bulk to the phone itself other than changing the size of the phone a tad bit.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did find that it added a lot in dimension in height and width, but not thickness. Makes the phone feel slightly larger than a G2 even.
ethantarheels123 said:
I did find that it added a lot in dimension in height and width, but not thickness. Makes the phone feel slightly larger than a G2 even.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The only phone I have to compare it with is the Samsung S3 and the case does make the Nexus 5 larger than the S3 (You can pretty much fit the S3 on the Nexus and there will still be a small amount of room on the sides).
Sharvil06 said:
The Spigen Neo Hybrid for the Nexus 5 is a solid case. I've received it from Amazon yesterday for a mere $20 and this case has been performing really well so far. All the ports are nicely cut and positioned. One drawback I've noticed is that the power and volume rocker buttons do have space to wiggle around a bit. You can slightly hear them rattling if you shake your phone but they aren't too big of a problem.The USB cutout is large and wide, making it possible to use almost any charging cable. The same applies to the headphone jack. The back of the case tends to show a few fingerprints but they can be wiped off easily. The case does provide a lip, so it is possible to lay the phone on the screen without worrying too much about getting it scratched (though it is not a big enough lip to be protective during falls on rough surfaces). I've attached a good amount of pictures since I am able to post them yet. Overall, I would recommend this case to someone because it's sleek and sturdy despite a few small drawbacks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tried it the phone and the case on a wireless Qi charger yet? If so, did it work?
beckmaneric said:
Have you tried it the phone and the case on a wireless Qi charger yet? If so, did it work?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it works.
Also have this case, although not as impressed with it.
The biggest complaint is the buttons. The buttons don't have a great feel to them. They wiggle (as mentioned by OP) all the time, the phone is actually annoyingly loud to move around (it's not loud, but it's certainly noticeable).
Other complaint is the USB port. While the OP thinks it's big enough, I can't fit in my Monster MicroUSB cable (I know all the hate about Monster, but the cable is 3" and was under $1 at Frys at one point). Wouldn't typically be a problem, but I use this cable a lot.
The headphone jack does allow my headphones to fit, but it's very close. Not sure if other headphones will have issues, but I'd be slightly worried about it.
Besides those complaints, it's a solid case. It looks great, appears that it'd protect the phone well. All in all, I am not planning on replacing it any time soon... unless my "ideal" case happens to come out... We shall see! The Qi charger still works through the case, along with NFC tags that I've tried thus far.
Petrovski80 said:
Nice review. I've just ordered the Spigen ultra hybrid (with clear back) from Amazon. I'll post some pics and findings as soon as I have it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I ordered one of these which came today. Not real happy with it, as the "clear" back really ISN'T "clear", kinda milkyish and that's after scrubbing at it with a microfiber cleaning cloth for many minutes. The slim armor is easily better, even if it lacks a transparent back.
cutterjohn said:
I ordered one of these which came today. Not real happy with it, as the "clear" back really ISN'T "clear", kinda milkyish and that's after scrubbing at it with a microfiber cleaning cloth for many minutes. The slim armor is easily better, even if it lacks a transparent back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you remove the protective films off both sides of the clear plastic parts? Majority of the people who bought this didn't realize there's something protecting the plastic...
cutterjohn said:
I ordered one of these which came today. Not real happy with it, as the "clear" back really ISN'T "clear", kinda milkyish and that's after scrubbing at it with a microfiber cleaning cloth for many minutes. The slim armor is easily better, even if it lacks a transparent back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
have you checked out the supcase? I just ordered one. It has black borders and frosted clear back, which should help hide scratches and dust.
Have this case and pretty happy with it as well. I just wish the power button was flush with the case. Don't know if anyone else has this problem, but I accidentally hit power all the damn time...
I just received my neo hybrid case... I am not a big fan at all. It makes the phone super bulky. I think this case is awesome for those wanting protection with style but I think I'm going to risk it and go with a skin or just naked.
bleuiko said:
I just received my neo hybrid case... I am not a big fan at all. It makes the phone super bulky. I think this case is awesome for those wanting protection with style but I think I'm going to risk it and go with a skin or just naked.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yea I feel the same way. Am waiting on my diztronic, as well as the supcase unicorn beetle. The thing with the neo hybrid is that it made it boxy as well as wider and taller, which made it very hard to hold and feel bulky. Not to mention taking it off was a chore.
I just got this case today and it is nice. But honestly the phone has a nice rubberized back and sides where I don't feel a case is always necessary. The case adds major width. But it is high quality.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
bleuiko said:
I just received my neo hybrid case... I am not a big fan at all. It makes the phone super bulky. I think this case is awesome for those wanting protection with style but I think I'm going to risk it and go with a skin or just naked.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I felt the same way, this phone is just so damn sexy naked. (Did I just type that...) Anyway, I want my phone to remain that way so I left it on, and it's definitely grown on me. I'm happy with it enough that I'm just going to leave it on.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app