Will xda-developer open new forum for Xda Atom? - Upgrading, Modifying and Unlocking

I like the model very much!! But I heard it is not the HTC model, anyone knows there are any forum for the Atom?

I believe xda-developers.com should start working on phones made by other companies, not just HTC...
we have very nice PPCs coming into the market everyday, M600, XDA ATOM, Gigabyte g-smart Pocket PC phone, and the list is growing...
so, IMHO, I think people here should think of opening new sub-forums for these new devices, as of many folks here are changing their devices due to better performance and nicer models ( this is not true for all HTC models )

As the name implies this site is devoted to xda's and their development , ie HTC handsets so there is no reqquirement to create a forum for non HTC devices!
Dont mean to rain on your parade.
rgs
Jim

Perhaps I am mistaken but isn't XDA a brand name of O2 meaning
(x)DA as opposed to PDA ??
Which would really mean this site is for O2 developers which clearly
isn't the case.
And yes this is explained on the front page where they say the domain
name is very misleading and this site is really for discussing HTC hardware.
And yet here we are talking about Quanta hardware and there is no thunder and lightning. why can't we all just get along!

sim1 said:
I like the model very much!! But I heard it is not the HTC model, anyone knows there are any forum for the Atom?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What about us new HTC Charmer owners? We want somewhere too ;-)

brykins said:
sim1 said:
I like the model very much!! But I heard it is not the HTC model, anyone knows there are any forum for the Atom?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What about us new HTC Charmer owners? We want somewhere too ;-)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
IMHO (no flame pls! :twisted: )
I do second the creation of more sub-forums. Like it or not, this forum has become a convergent point of like-minded Mobile PPC PDA-phone users from all over the world.
BUT (yes, there is always the buts)
it will be pretty hard on the moderators to keep a tab on all these sub-forums and make sure that things don't get too haywired around here.
SO, 4 suggestions:
(a) For all the moderators of other similar forums in their home countries to owe up, provide a description for their forum and the URL link. There might be a great ETEN M600 forum going on in a English forum in Taiwan, and we might be missing out on the discussions.
(b) For volunteers to be sub-moderators of the sub-forums in this place. More content means more hard disk space, something which will run out eventually if old stuff are not deleted. For the sake of democracy, we can put this to a vote, and see if we should start deleting stuff which has been here for 6 months or more.
(c) Perhaps one generic sub-forum (wiki?) for newbies "Request for Help", and we put in place some messaging protocol like putting in a tag @ the subject line as <RFH:<model>:<help message> e.g. "RFH:Qtek9100:Camera not working!!!! HELP!".
(d) Perhaps create one more generic sub-forum (wiki?) for evaluating software, patch releases by the helpful community here???
Just putting some thoughts here to make this a better and more useful forum for all.
oh, and Happy Holidays!!!

(a) For all the moderators of other similar forums in their home countries to owe up, provide a description for their forum and the URL link. There might be a great ETEN M600 forum going on in a English forum in Taiwan, and we might be missing out on the discussions.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, there is!
http://www.eten-users.net

Related

(New) hTC p3600i is out!

After HTC announced Trinity not included between WM6 devices, H3G Australia sell the WM6 Professional based version HTC P3600i, obviously HSDPA-enabled, including handwriting recognition!
Specifics:
- Samsung 500 MHz processor;
- 256 MB.
For further informations click here: http://www.three.com.au/cs/ContentS...1618&cid=1155886580937&MobileId=1185943301498
Who's the 1st's goin' to extract the ROM
cool!!!
very nice device!!!
i`d like to have one
there are already two threads that speak about p3600i
Are you a moderator, Guybrush ?
This is my thread, so please don't be boring little boy
vysus said:
Are you a moderator, Guybrush ?
This is my thread, so please don't be boring little boy
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't be a spoilt little boy yourself vysus. If everyone creates a thread because they " feel like it" the forum will be unuseable. Guybrush was politely and simply stating a fact. He should have said " mods close this bloody thread down it's completely useless".
This information should have been posted in one of the other 3600i thread instead of polluting the forum with yet another useless thread.
nealed said:
Don't be a spoilt little boy yourself vysus. If everyone creates a thread because they " feel like it" the forum will be unuseable. Guybrush was politely and simply stating a fact. He should have said " mods close this bloody thread down it's completely useless" .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why don't you just do your own business, spoilt, little, cryin' child ?
Did you know that H3G Australia is selling the HTC P3600 ?
Well, other people no, we're in a forum about Trinity and it's my right to write according to the topic
vysus said:
Why don't you just do your own business, spoilt, little, cryin' child ?
Did you know that H3G Australia is selling the HTC P3600 ?
Well, other people no, we're in a forum about Trinity and it's my right to write according to the topic
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, we knew this already from other - way more informative - threats.
Like the ones mentioned below by Guybrush...
So what is your message, other than lower yourself with your wordings?
I think this thread needs closing now, it's changed from a repeat topic to a bit of a flame.
the rom in mobile in H3G used to be older than you think.
the os may be one of the first wm6 releases.it is very possible,i am not kidding.
This thread should have been a point of start on doin' something good, I think, but due to your unwanted comments, became useless, as somebody said.
I'm not used to be impolite, somebody was before me, I've only replied.
I suppose from now I'll only read what I'm interested in, holy rollers
vysus said:
This thread should have been a point of start on doin' something good, I think, but due to your unwanted comments, became useless, as somebody said.
I'm not used to be impolite, somebody was before me, I've only replied.
I suppose from now I'll only read what I'm interested in, holy rollers
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What a spoiled little boy!!!
Why can't you be just a little more humble and admit that everyone that made you the warnings are just trying to improve this forum.
I'm sure that you with ~90 posts already been in some threads without any interest.
If there's already 2 threads about this, why don't you make your post's inside them!!!
vysus said:
I'm not used to be impolite, somebody was before me, I've only replied.
I suppose from now I'll only read what I'm interested in, holy rollers
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nobody was impolite before you. It was you who started being bad mannered on this thread.
What you did was bring an argument you had with Guybrush on another thread onto this one. An argument which YOU started in the first place on his thread.
Look if you're looking for someone to insult and have an argument with, don't do it here, find somewhere else.
I repeat, you're such a sect of supposed supermen, the problem is yours, I feel sadness for everyone of you, will not reply even if you keep on being so disgusting people
vysus said:
I repeat, you're such a sect of supposed supermen, the problem is yours, I feel sadness for everyone of you, will not reply even if you keep on being so disgusting people
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok! so all of us are wrong and you are wright?
For my side I think we should all say SORRY for this guy!!!
This is a open forum and sometimes we have to face guys like this
we apologise for being right?
I can do that
I doubt he'll apologise for being wrong though
After his reply to me earlier I was sorely tempted to reply and thought that he didn't even warrant it. I was right. However, I wanted to thank everyone for confirming what I already thought. Mods - does this thread have any use to any one? One other thing - (sound hypocritical, I know but) if you're reading this, please don't post to this thread any more - it's just giving it credance it should not have - and keeping it on page 1 of Trinity Mobile 6.
vysus said:
Why don't you just do your own business, spoilt, little, cryin' child ?
Did you know that H3G Australia is selling the HTC P3600 ?
Well, other people no, we're in a forum about Trinity and it's my right to write according to the topic
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why don't you stop posting in a rude and assaultive manner. You can be replaced ...

Why Juno forum is not under Smartphones?

Why Juno forum is not under Smartphones, this would help forum consistency?
oh yeah i just realized that.
we should totally relegate that smartphone to the lower position that it deserves!
just joking, but we should move it to the correct section
omg.... gas prices are over 4.00 /gal average in america and rising over the world ... but oh that doesnt matter lets get the smart phone away from the ppcs
there is no title above the ppcs saying PPC so technically its in the GENERAL section and not in a wrong section at all.
TBH with you. I feel all phones should have a 3 forum setup if there are custom roms for it.
shadowmike said:
TBH with you. I feel all phones should have a 3 forum setup if there are custom roms for it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree with you (compare Excalibur or Vox forums for activity and thread count) but this goes to basic forum redefining, though I believe it would be handy that way. Nevertheless, before it is done, Juno separation stick out like a dump in the punch
I always felt that the Excalibur and the Vox should have their own sections, it would help with the congestion in those forums as well.

Where are the moderators

I find it strange that there is a hard-spl that requires a certificate signing and another hard-spl that is supossedly not the work of the author but is stickied or if it is then why is one member allowed to accuse another member of cheating.
Please do not take this the wrong way I fully appreciate the work of everyone involved here but surely the following is not an unreasonable request:
Would like to ask the moderators to give judgement and clarification to the forum members
You must be new here.
Moderators are moderators because they keep the peace and clean up the ****.
they aren't technical experts of any sort (well, some are good of course) but the point is that they're not moderators because they're well-versed in this.
And Tom Codon didn't steal the Hard-SPL, I didn't say he did, I DID say he didn't credit Jockyw for making it.
Olipro said:
You must be new here.
Moderators are moderators because they keep the peace and clean up the ****.
they aren't technical experts of any sort (well, some are good of course) but the point is that they're not moderators because they're well-versed in this.
And Tom Codon didn't steal the Hard-SPL, I didn't say he did, I DID say he didn't credit Jockyw for making it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I fully understand your point of view and really appreciate the hard work that you have put in but this is not the correct way to start off this journey into developing our new Diamonds.
I am new is somewhat condesending and to say that moderators do not have the technical expertise is qually condesending. As a previous TYTN II owner at least 3 of the moderators produced some very fine ROMS that I know off and if it was not for some of those moderators alot of the break throughs achieved on previous models would not have happened.
If all a moderator is, in your opinion, a guy to clean up the **** and keep the peace then this forum needs exactly that at this moment.
pauljohn54 said:
If all a moderator is, in your opinion, a guy to clean up the **** and keep the peace then this forum needs exactly that at this moment.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Re-read what I wrote, and don't skim it, then give a proper answer.
Alright then lets put it another way and you tell me what you think.
Tom has a hard-spl that jockyw developed (in fact I also use the jockyw developed hard-spl on my TYTN II before I sold it). This hard-spl is not working because it was mean't for another device (correct?) and yet its stickied. So for a lay man when an item is stickied it normally means something excellent worth pursuing etc etc. So my point where is the moderators on this one.
You and your collegues have developed a hard-spl that requires certificate signing. That is entirely your choice for your reasons and it is appreciated but you have accussed another member of doing something wrong and again where is the moderators on this.
As a magician owner then TYTN II and now diamond this has to be the first time that I have seen the moderators sit on the fence and be impartial. I might not contribute much but at the same time I read alot and never ask stupid questions. I am happy to test anything as this is half the fun of owning a htc device and I am confident in the knowledge that if something goes wrong someone in this forum has a solution.
I do not mean to offend anyone but this is just my 2 cents worth.
pauljohn54 said:
Alright then lets put it another way and you tell me what you think.
Tom has a hard-spl that jockyw developed (in fact I also use the jockyw developed hard-spl on my TYTN II before I sold it). This hard-spl is not working because it was mean't for another device (correct?) and yet its stickied. So for a lay man when an item is stickied it normally means something excellent worth pursuing etc etc. So my point where is the moderators on this one.
You and your collegues have developed a hard-spl that requires certificate signing. That is entirely your choice for your reasons and it is appreciated but you have accussed another member of doing something wrong and again where is the moderators on this.
As a magician owner then TYTN II and now diamond this has to be the first time that I have seen the moderators sit on the fence and be impartial. I might not contribute much but at the same time I read alot and never ask stupid questions. I am happy to test anything as this is half the fun of owning a htc device and I am confident in the knowledge that if something goes wrong someone in this forum has a solution.
I do not mean to offend anyone but this is just my 2 cents worth.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the jocky/tomcodon hardspl was made for preproduction diamonds.. HTC put in new protection in the final ones - you are right it should be unstickied because it doesn't work., have you tried it on your diamond?
please understand, our hardspl will soon be changed to allow unsigned ROMs too.
pauljohn54 said:
Alright then lets put it another way and you tell me what you think.
Tom has a hard-spl that jockyw developed (in fact I also use the jockyw developed hard-spl on my TYTN II before I sold it). This hard-spl is not working because it was mean't for another device (correct?) and yet its stickied. So for a lay man when an item is stickied it normally means something excellent worth pursuing etc etc. So my point where is the moderators on this one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, it's not for another device, it only works with pre-production devices... which obviously you don't get sold to you at the store.
pauljohn54 said:
You and your collegues have developed a hard-spl that requires certificate signing. That is entirely your choice for your reasons and it is appreciated but you have accussed another member of doing something wrong and again where is the moderators on this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Read the whole diamond Hard-SPL thread and you'll see it, which would save the need for this pointless thread demanding it be spoon-fed.
pauljohn54 said:
As a magician owner then TYTN II and now diamond this has to be the first time that I have seen the moderators sit on the fence and be impartial. I might not contribute much but at the same time I read alot and never ask stupid questions. I am happy to test anything as this is half the fun of owning a htc device and I am confident in the knowledge that if something goes wrong someone in this forum has a solution.
I do not mean to offend anyone but this is just my 2 cents worth.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should also know the signing is also a temporary measure... or at least you would if you genuinely did "read alot" (it's "a lot" btw, I'm sure English isn't your first language though) then you'd know that the signing is only a temporary measure.
Olipro said:
No, it's not for another device, it only works with pre-production devices... which obviously you don't get sold to you at the store.
Read the whole diamond Hard-SPL thread and you'll see it, which would save the need for this pointless thread demanding it be spoon-fed.
You should also know the signing is also a temporary measure... or at least you would if you genuinely did "read alot" (it's "a lot" btw, I'm sure English isn't your first language though) then you'd know that the signing is only a temporary measure.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In one fell swoop you have undone all your good work. What a total asshole. So you think you are better than Asians as English is your first language.
I am very disappointed that you can be allowed to degrade genuine members who simply have a raised a concern as to the path that this forum is going in the diamond section as oppossed to the very professional direction taken by the paths of other great devices such as TYTN II
geeee,
is this forum in need of a cleanup? my answer is no!. This is quite toned down as compared to how things were in the hermes forum last year when wm6 was leaked.
what will happen when i release WM7 for the diamond and touch pro later this year? it will get messy and thats the way I like it, nice and foul with plenty of excitement, *****iness and trout slaps!!!
Well well then, firstly to the OP you will notice the original non-working HardSPL thread....is unstickied.
And this thread is closed.
Any concerns you have about the moderation team should be made DIRECTLY to us and not wasting space in an off topic thread.
Regards.

a big request,so big that it can't be in requsts thread

request to mods/admins
please,please,please
I GET SICK WHEN I SEE THE GENERAL DISCUSSION THREAD
the general discussion is full of LG,Samsung,Sony-Ericsson threads and posts about roms,apps,whole bunch of stuff which we don't support because they aren't htc
some guys/girls asked for separated threads for those listed above,but they didn't get them because they aren't htc products
and now they are clearly allowed to post about those devices in general discussion
(because you don't stop them)
so when we look it in technical way...it is spamming,as talking about cars,pc's, estates is
in general or any other thread (except for off topic thread)
PLEASE STOP THIS by removing those threads or by giving them a section,either ways let's keep the forum clean and cool....and easy to use and navigate
the third option is to give us shovels to dig our way out of omnias,i780-s,x-perias and whole bunch of crap
please think about this and let's do something
thanks
faruk
Off-Topic is the Apropos Place for this.
Ultimately though, General is a good place for non-HTC products. Most people stay within their own section.
JimmyMcGee said:
Off-Topic is the Apropos Place for this.
Ultimately though, General is a good place for non-HTC products. Most people stay within their own section.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
well we aren't windows mobile developers,at least it's not our name...we aren't support for wm devices,but for htc,as it's said in the welcome screen nad short "site about"
Welcome to xda-developers.com
This site is about certain PDA-phones, made by a firm called HTC in Taiwan. Their makers named them 'Wallaby', 'Himalaya', 'Blue Angel', 'Wizard' and 'TyTN', but almost nobody knows them by those names. The mobile provider O2 sells them under the brand-name 'XDA', and that's what we had in our hands first. They're also known as Qtek, MDA, SX-56, Hermes and many, many other names.
Since we develop software for it, we need information, and nobody seemed eager or ready to give us what we needed. So we 'reverse-engineered' the devices, found a lot of information, and shared it with the world. But as our site grew we realised that lots of ordinary users were also suffering from a lack of support. They started using the xda-developers forum to communicate and before long the forum was as much a user forum as it was a developer forum.
We hope that you will enjoy this site and find it as useful as we do. We encourage you to donate or otherwise support this site. Of course absolutely all proceeds from donations will benefit this community.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
and samsung is not htc so the place for them is off topic
farukb said:
well we aren't windows mobile developers,at least it's not our name...
and samsung is not htc
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh I know. If you look back at all the non-Htc Subforum request threads you will see me telling people no. But They still seem to think General is ok. I don't know what Admin's stand on this is.
JimmyMcGee said:
Oh I know. If you look back at all the non-Htc Subforum request threads you will see me telling people no. But They still seem to think General is ok. I don't know what Admin's stand on this is.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
that is my point,i also say no, but they keep posting...but one moment i saw general full of non-htc crap and i got really pissed off
hateful child....
just kidding.
i think it's ignorant and somewhat elitist to completely deny non-HTC devices service here. We do have a forum for the XDA atom, which was NOT made by HTC. It was, however, carried by XDA. The world isn't static, and it's ignorant to say that the internet isn't either. We've opened forums for even the least used HTC devices, so we should definitely consider giving non-htc devices their own forums, especially given the number of people who have them.
fzzyrn said:
hateful child....
just kidding.
i think it's ignorant and somewhat elitist to completely deny non-HTC devices service here. We do have a forum for the XDA atom, which was NOT made by HTC. It was, however, carried by XDA. The world isn't static, and it's ignorant to say that the internet isn't either. We've opened forums for even the least used HTC devices, so we should definitely consider giving non-htc devices their own forums, especially given the number of people who have them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
personally,i'd give them their sections,and i wouldn't mind to have omnia,but the general thread thing bugs me...if you know what i mean
well, you know....
to quote some inexplicably famous guy "the best place to find order is in disorder"
fzzyrn said:
well, you know....
to quote some inexplicably famous guy "the best place to find order is in disorder"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
????self-quoter
caught me!
i guess this means that i'm inexplicably famous.
fzzyrn said:
caught me!
i guess this means that i'm inexplicably famous.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
...no...
i only saw your signature...doh!
haha i keep trying to get one of the mods to say it so people don't present that reaction to me.
hint hint wink wink
anyone...please....the situation is getting bad really bad
admin opinion:
I have no issues whatsoever with the thread but I agree that off-topic might be a better place. Though this forum is for HTC made devices it doesn't stop us of discussing any other trivial matter as long as it's in the right section (whether that be the best brand of coffee, the speed of our dsl line, the color of my avatar or a different device)
We will not at any moment open forums for non htc made devices on this forum, it would open the floodgates for way too many devices and make this forum too general and unmanageble.
Best regards,
Flar
Flar said:
admin opinion:
I have no issues whatsoever with the thread but I agree that off-topic might be a better place. Though this forum is for HTC made devices it doesn't stop us of discussing any other trivial matter as long as it's in the right section (whether that be the best brand of coffee, the speed of our dsl line, the color of my avatar or a different device)
We will not at any moment open forums for non htc made devices on this forum, it would open the floodgates for way too many devices and make this forum too general and unmanageble.
Best regards,
Flar
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i totally agree with you
i am a htc user so i don't have problems with the forum
but as an admin you could do something to prevent general development or any other thread being full of "off topics"
mods don't clean it up,go now and you will see more non-htc threads than eg. application development threads
and that drives me crazy
quote from my first post
and now they are clearly allowed to post about those devices in general discussion
(because you don't stop them)
so when we look it in technical way...it is spamming,as talking about cars,pc's, estates is
in general or any other thread (except for off topic thread)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
farukb said:
i totally agree with you
i am a htc user so i don't have problems with the forum
but as an admin you could do something to prevent general development or any other thread being full of "off topics"
mods don't clean it up,go now and you will see more non-htc threads than eg. application development threads
and that drives me crazy
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unfortunately the life of a mod can be overwhelming at times, we can't be everywhere all the time. If you have a problem with a thread and want to bring it to our attention, you could send a PM.
We will evaluate the options and take the action we feel is best.
farukb said:
i totally agree with you
i am a htc user so i don't have problems with the forum
but as an admin you could do something to prevent general development or any other thread being full of "off topics"
mods don't clean it up,go now and you will see more non-htc threads than eg. application development threads
and that drives me crazy
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As jimmy says mods do have their own lives and can't be everywhere all the time, it helps if you help point out stuff like this.
Consider the fact that some of our mods spend up to 14 hours per day here, most of that time spent moderating...
Also consider this is vacation season and for a lot of the mods (and users) this time of day is the time you start thinking about going to bed, with mods being on vacation all of us have a hard time coping with all the mod work as it is, a bit of patience will get you a long way.
Best regards,
Flar
Flar said:
As jimmy says mods do have their own lives and can't be everywhere all the time, it helps if you help point out stuff like this.
Consider the fact that some of our mods spend up to 14 hours per day here, most of that time spent moderating...
Also consider this is vacation season and for a lot of the mods (and users) this time of day is the time you start thinking about going to bed, with mods being on vacation all of us have a hard time coping with all the mod work as it is, a bit of patience will get you a long way.
Best regards,
Flar
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes i know that and i fully appreciate it,they are people too
but there is a dozen of mods,not only one
i'm not rushing anyone,just asked everyone to consider it
this thread is almost a month old (7-25-08) so it won't make a difference now or next week or whenever
thanks again for your patience and dealing with some sometimes pissed off guys
i'll help,make your job easier
i'm starting to provide links of all non-htc threads in a new "report non-htc" thread
so someone could just delete them,without searching and reading the whole forum
is it ok with you?
thanks
By delete, you mean move to Off Topic?
Also, if this is the desired plan, should the General forum have a annoucment, and maybe change the description, informing users of this?
Oh and BTW, I have PM'd Meniesys about making a Roll up Sticky for all his guides, he said he is looking into it
Ta
Dave

Treo Pro Forum?

Will there be one set up? It is an HTC device.
Question has been asked, answer is no for now. If there's enough buzz in the General forum about the Treo Pro the moderators/administrators may change their minds, but they're aware of the desire and they've made a decision. Talk about it in the General forum.
Black93300ZX said:
Question has been asked, answer is no for now. If there's enough buzz in the General forum about the Treo Pro the moderators/administrators may change their minds, but they're aware of the desire and they've made a decision. Talk about it in the General forum.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm all for rules and clear cut policies, so we all know where I stand. The ONLY criteria given consistently, for years, for creating device-specific forums on XDA-dev, was that they had to be made by HTC. Fair enough, everyone understood that. That's one reason xda-dev, and its mods, have always been respected as a sensible forum.
Now we have the Treo Pro, we are told that being made by HTC device doesn't count, and its the number of posts and "buzz" that matters (to a threshold which is conveniently not defined). Yet a single General/Palm Treo 850 thread has almost as many posts as the whole G1 section. The X1 has a forum under "Other HTC manufactured phones". Come to think of it, shouldn't the Treo 750 and G1 be in that section too?
Where's the transparency and clarity gone?
I have re-raised this issue with the mods and admin. It does seem that the Treo Pro is gathering quiet a following now...
Regards
Dave
Ineedtoys said:
I'm all for rules and clear cut policies, so we all know where I stand. The ONLY criteria given consistently, for years, for creating device-specific forums on XDA-dev, was that they had to be made by HTC. Fair enough, everyone understood that. That's one reason xda-dev, and its mods, have always been respected as a sensible forum.
Now we have the Treo Pro, we are told that being made by HTC device doesn't count, and its the number of posts and "buzz" that matters (to a threshold which is conveniently not defined). Yet a single General/Palm Treo 850 thread has almost as many posts as the whole G1 section. The X1 has a forum under "Other HTC manufactured phones". Come to think of it, shouldn't the Treo 750 and G1 be in that section too?
Where's the transparency and clarity gone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay, don't get all bent out of shape. First of all Black 93 300ZX is not an administrator or representative of any steering committee of XDA-Developers.
Here's how I would recommend you follow through on this. Find definitive proof that its is made by HTC, then send the request to the Site's Administrator.
At that point you will probably get a forum.
EDIT: Here have a leg up courtesy of me. http://www.palminfocenter.com/news/7868/treo-pro-manufactured-by-htc/
Thank you Dave and Jimmy, good to know someone is listening. Several people have already provided this evidence and PM'd the mods and the only response seen so far has been "no".
For others who are interested, the main Treo Pro discussion thread is here:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=419354
and the Wiki is here:
http://wiki.xda-developers.com/index.php?pagename=PalmTreoPro
All contributions welcome.
Ineedtoys said:
Thank you Dave and Jimmy, good to know someone is listening. Several people have already provided this evidence and PM'd the mods and the only response seen so far has been "no".
For others who are interested, the main Treo Pro discussion thread is here:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=419354
and the Wiki is here:
http://wiki.xda-developers.com/index.php?pagename=PalmTreoPro
All contributions welcome.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What is the reason given for the not having a Treo Pro thread? Seems to me that alot of people want it. It's made by HTC. It's not hard to open a thread. What gives?
I hope this isn't a case of phone envy
stevebrooks said:
What is the reason given for the not having a Treo Pro thread? Seems to me that alot of people want it. It's made by HTC. It's not hard to open a thread. What gives?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No reason has been given. That's because no representative of xda-devs has said "no".
It is under consideration at the moment, forums don't just spring out the ground you know.
I'll update you when I know more...
Dave
DaveShaw said:
No reason has been given. That's because no representative of xda-devs has said "no".
It is under consideration at the moment, forums don't just spring out the ground you know.
I'll update you when I know more...
Dave
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually I think Flar said "no" but whatever.
Who is Hyins? and why did they move the Palm Treo Wiki to "Skywriter"?!?! Skywriter was the code name for the CDMA version.
lewcamino said:
Actually I think Flar said "no" but whatever.
Who is Hyins? and why did they move the Palm Treo Wiki to "Skywriter"?!?! Skywriter was the code name for the CDMA version.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No idea, Drop Hyins a PM and ask. It is a wiki, so anyone can edit it
I couldn't find any post by Flar with regards to the Treo Pro Forum (unless you go back to the old treos) nor could anyone else It must have been lost somewhere.
As I said before, it is been considered and an update will be given when available.
Ta
Dave
DaveShaw said:
No idea, Drop Hyins a PM and ask. It is a wiki, so anyone can edit it
I couldn't find any post by Flar with regards to the Treo Pro Forum (unless you go back to the old treos) nor could anyone else It must have been lost somewhere.
As I said before, it is been considered and an update will be given when available.
Ta
Dave
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah. It was via PM but no worries. Glad to see it progress.
Treo Pro Forum
I agree the Treo Pro should have it own Forum.
I find myself visiting XDA Dev a lot less because it is hard to follow the postings as everyone is lumping multiple topics in to a single thread.
Anyway, Thanks for the consideration.
-D
I get this device today ... its fantastic ... and i think unique!
DaveShaw said:
No reason has been given. That's because no representative of xda-devs has said "no".
It is under consideration at the moment, forums don't just spring out the ground you know.
I'll update you when I know more...
Dave
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for looking into it.
I have an 800w, but I'd like to see a Treo Pro forum here, too. Might be able to pick up a few tips, etc. for myself.
DaveShaw said:
No idea, Drop Hyins a PM and ask. It is a wiki, so anyone can edit it
I couldn't find any post by Flar with regards to the Treo Pro Forum (unless you go back to the old treos) nor could anyone else It must have been lost somewhere.
As I said before, it is been considered and an update will be given when available.
Ta
Dave
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dave, just to let you know that I got a PM by Flar a while ago too, saying the only way was to raise enough buzz...
Thanks for your efforts...
Here's the definitive proof of the HTC-origins. I've found the bootloader mode for the Treo Pro, and we can deduct the real codename Panther from it (as 750=Cheetah). I've updated the Wiki accordingly.
Enter Treo Pro bootloader mode
oVan said:
Here's the definitive proof of the HTC-origins. I've found the bootloader mode for the Treo Pro, and we can deduct the real codename Panther from it (as 750=Cheetah). I've updated the Wiki accordingly.
Enter Treo Pro bootloader mode
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi,
I have removed the PalmTreoPro wiki page and replaced it with a re-direct to the new HTC_Panther page you created. Now there is only one list of info to update.
Ta
Dave
Buzz Buzz Buzz - another vote for Treo Pro Forum
oVan said:
Dave, just to let you know that I got a PM by Flar a while ago too, saying the only way was to raise enough buzz...
Thanks for your efforts...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Buzz Buzz Buzz
This bee is getting a Treo Pro, and I would definitely like to see a forum for it here.
Since I didn't technically vote for it, I'll do it now.
It's cleary an HTC device and has already benefitted from the developers on this site. If the 750 is on here, no reason the Pro shouldn't be.

Categories

Resources