Adaptive brightness too dramatic? - Nexus 5X Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting

I've seen a couple posts about delays with adaptive brightness, but this is a different item. I'm seeing that the adaptive brightness alters the brightness a little too dramatically. In a somewhat dark room (not pitch black) the brightness will be at absolute minimum even when the brightness is about 1/3 up on the slider. In a moderately bright room that same brightness setting will be near maximum.
Does anyone else notice this as an issue? I'm just wondering if it's normal (ie, software calibration issue) or if the brightness sensor might not be seated correctly.

It's normal. Or at least it sounds like it is working the same way mine is. And yes, IMO it is a little too sensitive. The Lux app works beautifully if you want an alternative. Also, the goog is known for tweaking this feature over time with updates.

I've noticed this too. The biggest thing for me is walking down the street at dusk (so not dark out yet) I can't read the screen as it turns it all the way down, then, when I walk under a street light, it turns it all the way up to full! It's one extreme or the other, there seems to be no middle ground.

In other words "adaptive brightness has mind of its own!"

This is why I have always kept this setting off. The brightness just changing on its own always annoyed me.

When it works properly (and it should) for ones uses, it's great, it's automatic, what's not to like? It's a pita to always have to change brightness manually just to see a phone display depending on ambient lighting which varies immensely for many users.

jbdan said:
When it works properly (and it should) for ones uses, it's great, it's automatic, what's not to like? It's a pita to always have to change brightness manually just to see a phone display depending on ambient lighting which varies immensely for many users.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree. I have it set to maybe around 15-20% (centered over the WiFi symbol below it) and I never need to touch it. Gets dark enough for night driving and bright enough to read outside. Never found it stuck on one or the other when it shouldn't be.
Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk

If you buy the app Lux you can customize how it adapts your brightness. The free version is good to but you have to use mostly default settings. By default it only adapts brightness when the screen turns on.

Related

Need more control over the backlight

Is there a way to tweak the behaviour of the auto-brightness backlight? At the moment it correctly goes up to full brightness in sunlight, but it doesn't go as dim as I would like under artificial light. At home, after dark, under electric light, I can manually turn the screen brightness down to the minimum level, and it's still bright enough - the auto setting is much brighter than that(although clearly much dimmer than it is in sunlight, so it is doing something).
Can this be tweaked? Failing that, is there an easier way to control the brightness manually - something I can keep running all the time, and which doesn't require the stylus to change the setting?
Try GLight
http://www.ageye.de/index.php?s=glight/about
JustBored said:
Try GLight
http://www.ageye.de/index.php?s=glight/about
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I'll give that a try.
I find Lumos to be more stable and reliable
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=450318
Ok I havn't tried either of them before but I just installed G-Light.
After a bit of config. it's ok. You need to give each backlight number a wider setting.
Otherwise it'll just flip back and forward in brightness.
So far G-Light is proving rather dissapointing. The phone's built-in "Auto" setting works well, apart from the fact that the brightness doesn't go low enough in dim light - in particular, it manages to choose a good level and then stick to it. G-Light, by contrast, keeps changing the brightness up and down all the time.
I think the notion of having absolute brightness bands may be the wrong way to go. You really want a set-up where the threshold values are in different places depending on whether the light is getting brighter or dimmer. So, as the light fades, you cross a threshold and dim the screen - but when the light goes slightly back up over that threshold, you don't brighten the screen again until it gets significantly higher than that. That way, regardless of the light level, the screen brightness will be steady unless the ambient light level is changing a lot. If you use single threshold values then whenever the ambient light happens to be very close to a threshold value you will always get the brightness going constantly up and down.
Edit: some of the things Lumos does (like averaging across multiple readings) sound hopeful, though. I'll give that a try.
Shasarak said:
So far G-Light is proving rather dissapointing. The phone's built-in "Auto" setting works well, apart from the fact that the brightness doesn't go low enough in dim light - in particular, it manages to choose a good level and then stick to it. G-Light, by contrast, keeps changing the brightness up and down all the time.
I think the notion of having absolute brightness bands may be the wrong way to go. You really want a set-up where the threshold values are in different places depending on whether the light is getting brighter or dimmer. So, as the light fades, you cross a threshold and dim the screen - but when the light goes slightly back up over that threshold, you don't brighten the screen again until it gets significantly higher than that. That way, regardless of the light level, the screen brightness will be steady unless the ambient light level is changing a lot. If you use single threshold values then whenever the ambient light happens to be very close to a threshold value you will always get the brightness going constantly up and down.
Edit: some of the things Lumos does (like averaging across multiple readings) sound hopeful, though. I'll give that a try.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Let me know how Lumos is.
Yes as I said earlier you need to widen those settings.
For now I have 5 set to 0-81
6 set to 82-200
8 set to 201-600
10 set to 601-1000
All the rest are disabled by setting the values to -1 to -1
HeavyComponent said:
Let me know how Lumos is.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lumos is also proving dissapointing. It's partly the fault of the hardware - the sensor seems to read 0 even in surprisingly bright light, so the app has no way of telling whether you're at a light level where backlight 1 is appropriate or a light level where backlight 3 is appropriate - both read 0 on the sensor. (This is probably why the default auto option doesn't go below 3 in the first place).
As for Lumos, the author needs to realise that perception of brightness is actually based on an exponential curve. That means that all of the values between level 1 and level 5 are somewhere between 0 and 80 sensor reading. The graph interface is useless for editing custom values with that level of precision - it's trying to squeeze over 2000 values into less than 800 pixels of screen space, and the pixels are tiny! I think you can edit the values directly in the settings.txt file, but that's fiddly - there should be spinboxes, really (as with G-Light).
In any case, you don't want to be editing the values directly! What you want to be doing is taking the phone out of your pocket, looking at it, and thinking "hmm, the screen is too bright at the moment" then adjusting the brightness to whatever level is comfortable for the current ambient light level. The programme should then interpolate the curve that you want, and progressively refine it each time you decide it isn't quite right and tweak the brightness.
I haven't tried to Lumos program yet, but I've been using Glight for a few days. At first I had some issues with it but then I realized that you have to turn the auto light adjustment off in settings first. If not, they'll both be fighting against one another.
Also, you have to set your thresholds pretty carefully as has been already stated. Mine is set to go bright only in bright outside and lowest in a dark room with no light at all.
1 0 to 5
3 10 to 799
8 800 to 2500
I've got mine set low for better battery life and the screen is always readable to me no matter what anyway.
Also, if you're using a the snap on rubber protector (I got a T-Mobile one) it will interfere with the light sensor. I just got one and the lighting is all over the place now. Time to order a full body screen protector.
GLight doesn't seem to work for me. keeps crashing, and the settings don't seem to save at all.
I don't want a sliding scale that Lumos has since i don't think the light sensor is all that accurate (sometimes thinks it's too bright and sometimes thinks its too dark). would rather just have a few settings (pitch black setting, super bright setting, and in the middle) as shawndh suggested.
i have the verizon tp2 - not sure if this might be causing some of the glight probs.

Minimum brightness

You don't want to give your significant other yet another reason to yell at you while you're reading XDA in bed. Rate this thread to express what you think of the OnePlus 3T's display minimum dimness. A higher rating indicates that the display can get extremely dim, ideal for reading in very dark environments.
Then, drop a comment if you have anything to add!
i feel that they need to dim it more, it's still annoying
One thing I noticed is that the phone offers EXTREME fine tune-ing of the lower brightness end.....when I adjust the adaptive brightness, if I click and drag the setting towards the bottom end, there is tons of adjustability available to the user to find exactly how much brightness you want. Having said that, the lowest settings appears quite dim to me (but not 'dangerously' dim)
The lowest setting for me seems to be extremely bright still, for night usage at least. Every other phone I've used has been able to get far more dim.
Anyone know of any way to lower it further actually?
Chipaton said:
The lowest setting for me seems to be extremely bright still, for night usage at least. Every other phone I've used has been able to get far more dim.
Anyone know of any way to lower it further actually?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
root it and with the help of xposed (or without) you can edit the parameters to make it even dimmer.
vikingsail said:
root it and with the help of xposed (or without) you can edit the parameters to make it even dimmer.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do I edit? I'm rooted with Xposed.
Chipaton said:
What do I edit? I'm rooted with Xposed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
check this out.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2367412
This phone is love
OnePlus 3T is just an amazing phone, I loved it
Got the device for a few weeks and there are already burn ins on the left side
If you don't want the hassle of rooting and running xposed you could just install an app from play store, I use lower brightness by Nu-Kob, nothing fancy but it does the job
I'm using rr with magisk (if any of that even matters when it comes to brightness). When the lights are off and I have the brightness all the way up I can barely look at it. But when I turn the brightness all the way down with the lights off it is perfect and I can see everything very clearly and my girlfriend or has an s6 and she is always jealous that when she turns her brightness down it's still blinding. So I think it's great.
Try Velis Auto Brightness https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.velis.auto.brightness&hl=en
no ads and it works great, tons of parameter to adjust as well.
At night, the brightness is way too much. Observing the display, f.e. playing PoGo in a park at night, you almost get night blind. If you switch automatic brightness off, there is one more step down, but this one is way too dark and without any contrast. Compared to my previous device, it's really bad. I hope, it gets fixed, if possible by the hardware at all.
I also think that the minimum brightness is not dim enough.
I rectify this using an app called Twilight - no root required - which allows to dim + apply red filter
It's usually okay for me, however I use Dimly if I need to go even lower.

Screen too bright at night, and turning down brightness results in too dark blacks?

This is my first AMOLED screen phone and something I think I may be noticing that maybe you guys can help confirm or deny about AMOLEDs vs LCDs, is that at night when turning the brightness down (way down, like -50 in the Lux Dash app as an example) results in getting the screen to a point where not bright enough to hurt your eyes at all but the blacks are too dark. So there's no real ideal brightness setting in a dark room that equals no eye pain but still allows you to able to see everything on the screen. Or are my eyes just too sensitive and most other people don't need to turn it down as much as I do and therefore don't have this problem?
You tried night mode
Lux is garbage. Factory adaptive brightness and still being able to use the brightness slider to allow on-the-fly adjustments is far superior - it works perfectly on this phone. And in a pitch black room, with adaptive brightness, setting the slider from 0-25% results in an extremely dim screen (1-2 nits) will information still perfectly viewable. Blacks may have uniformity issues, but that is the nature of OLED panels since it is extremely hard to control voltage at near-black levels when the brightness is extremely low.
s1dest3pnate said:
This is my first AMOLED screen phone and something I think I may be noticing that maybe you guys can help confirm or deny about AMOLEDs vs LCDs, is that at night when turning the brightness down (way down, like -50 in the Lux Dash app as an example) results in getting the screen to a point where not bright enough to hurt your eyes at all but the blacks are too dark. So there's no real ideal brightness setting in a dark room that equals no eye pain but still allows you to able to see everything on the screen. Or are my eyes just too sensitive and most other people don't need to turn it down as much as I do and therefore don't have this problem?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Amoled displays, when used with automatic brightness adjustment, have a small problem - when you are viewing them in the dark, they appear too dark. Their contrast ratio is infinity, which means that dark colors are basically zero luminosity or close to zero. A lot of internet imagery is calibrated for lcd displays, so when you lower your phone brightness to make the brightest parts viewable on an amoled display, the dark colors become too dark and blend together. This is especially true when you are viewing a screen in a dark environment. There's nothing you can do but increase device brightness by hand when you are using automatic brightness adjustment and viewing in the dark,
---------- Post added at 08:19 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:07 AM ----------
Nitemare3219 said:
Lux is garbage. Factory adaptive brightness and still being able to use the brightness slider to allow on-the-fly adjustments is far superior - it works perfectly on this phone. And in a pitch black room, with adaptive brightness, setting the slider from 0-25% results in an extremely dim screen (1-2 nits) will information still perfectly viewable. Blacks may have uniformity issues, but that is the nature of OLED panels since it is extremely hard to control voltage at near-black levels when the brightness is extremely low.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You do realize that Adaptive Brightness simply changes the brightness of the screen in response to the light sensor reading?
In other words, the phone doesn't care about your preference - it will change the brightness to preset levels.
On Samsung phones, this situation is far more intelligent. The phone still uses the light sensor to adjust the brightness, but the phone also applies a user preset to augment the brightness - when you slide the brightness slider up, the phone will make auto brightness adjustment higher, and vise versa.
nabbed said:
You do realize that Adaptive Brightness simply changes the brightness of the screen in response to the light sensor reading?
In other words, the phone doesn't care about your preference - it will change the brightness to preset levels.
On Samsung phones, this situation is far more intelligent. The phone still uses the light sensor to adjust the brightness, but the phone also applies a user preset to augment the brightness - when you slide the brightness slider up, the phone will make auto brightness adjustment higher, and vise versa.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
WHAT? You have it totally backwards. Stock Android, including the Pixel, uses user input to augment the auto light sensor brightness when adaptive brightness is enabled. If my phone thinks 50% brightness is appropriate, but my slider is set to 100, it will choose something like 75% brightness instead. If I drop the slider to 0% in the same instance, it might choose 25% instead. The user preference will ALWAYS be impacting auto brightness.
Samsung phones, unless it changed with Nougat, rely strictly on what the phone thinks is best for auto brightness. The user can adjust the slider with auto brightness on, but the slider is a direct adjustment 0-100% of the true brightness level, and the slider will change automatically when there is a large shift in ambient light after the display has been turned off at least once. User preference does NOT impact auto brightness unless you set it at that specific moment.
Nitemare3219 said:
WHAT? You have it totally backwards. Stock Android, including the Pixel, uses user input to augment the auto light sensor brightness when adaptive brightness is enabled. If my phone thinks 50% brightness is appropriate, but my slider is set to 100, it will choose something like 75% brightness instead. If I drop the slider to 0% in the same instance, it might choose 25% instead. The user preference will ALWAYS be impacting auto brightness.
Samsung phones, unless it changed with Nougat, rely strictly on what the phone thinks is best for auto brightness. The user can adjust the slider with auto brightness on, but the slider is a direct adjustment 0-100% of the true brightness level, and the slider will change automatically when there is a large shift in ambient light after the display has been turned off at least once. User preference does NOT impact auto brightness unless you set it at that specific moment.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Girl, are you kidding me? I just returned a Note 7 for Pixel XL. What were your phones?
nabbed said:
Amoled displays, when used with automatic brightness adjustment, have a small problem - when you are viewing them in the dark, they appear too dark. Their contrast ratio is infinity, which means that dark colors are basically zero luminosity or close to zero. A lot of internet imagery is calibrated for lcd displays, so when you lower your phone brightness to make the brightest parts viewable on an amoled display, the dark colors become too dark and blend together. This is especially true when you are viewing a screen in a dark environment. There's nothing you can do but increase device brightness by hand when you are using automatic brightness adjustment and viewing in the dark,
---------- Post added at 08:19 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:07 AM ----------
You do realize that Adaptive Brightness simply changes the brightness of the screen in response to the light sensor reading?
In other words, the phone doesn't care about your preference - it will change the brightness to preset levels.
On Samsung phones, this situation is far more intelligent. The phone still uses the light sensor to adjust the brightness, but the phone also applies a user preset to augment the brightness - when you slide the brightness slider up, the phone will make auto brightness adjustment higher, and vise versa.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
nabbed said:
Girl, are you kidding me? I just returned a Note 7 for Pixel XL. What were your phones?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have a Note7, Pixel XL, and LG V20. Google how adaptive brightness works. There won't be a single article that matches how you say it works.
Nitemare3219 said:
I have a Note7, Pixel XL, and LG V20. Google how adaptive brightness works. There won't be a single article that matches how you say it works.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Give me evidence. I don't care what your hypothetical "articles" say, I had the actual phones and played with their brightness settings.
nabbed said:
Give me evidence. I don't care what your hypothetical "articles" say, I had the actual phones and played with their brightness settings.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you seriously can't tell how adaptive brightness works just by using it as compared to Samsung and LG, I don't know what to tell you. It's pretty damn obvious. If I'm the kind of person who prefers a bright screen, I can set adaptive brightness to 100% and it will always be bright, but stay relative to the ambient lighting. If it's a dim room, the screen will be bright, but nowhere near 100% manual brightness. It only hits 100% manual brightness when under bright light like the sun.
Samsung's auto brightness is still very cookie cutter. If you put 2 Samsung phones side by side with auto brightness on, they will always be the same no matter the ambient light. If I take 2 Pixels, both set to adaptive, and put one on 25% and one in 75%, they will always maintain a brightness difference even when ambient light changes. Samsung phones do not maintain user preferences once the ambient light level changes. I almost never have to adjust my Pixel. I always have to adjust my Note7 because I prefer a slightly brighter screen.
Nitemare3219 said:
If you seriously can't tell how adaptive brightness works just by using it as compared to Samsung and LG, I don't know what to tell you. It's pretty damn obvious. If I'm the kind of person who prefers a bright screen, I can set adaptive brightness to 100% and it will always be bright, but stay relative to the ambient lighting. If it's a dim room, the screen will be bright, but nowhere near 100% manual brightness. It only hits 100% manual brightness when under bright light like the sun.
Samsung's auto brightness is still very cookie cutter. If you put 2 Samsung phones side by side with auto brightness on, they will always be the same no matter the ambient light. If I take 2 Pixels, both set to adaptive, and put one on 25% and one in 75%, they will always maintain a brightness difference even when ambient light changes. Samsung phones do not maintain user preferences once the ambient light level changes. I almost never have to adjust my Pixel. I always have to adjust my Note7 because I prefer a slightly brighter screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What you are saying is EXACTLY THE OPPOSITE of my experience with Note 7 and Pixel XL. I NEVER had to adjust my Note 7 brightness once I set it.
I find myself constantly adjusting Pixel XL brightness setting.
Maybe they both have "adaptive brightness", but the Note 7 version was perfect, and the Pixel XL is just sh`1rt.
nabbed said:
What you are saying is EXACTLY THE OPPOSITE of my experience with Note 7 and Pixel XL. I NEVER had to adjust my Note 7 brightness once I set it.
I find myself constantly adjusting Pixel XL brightness setting.
Maybe they both have "adaptive brightness", but the Note 7 version was perfect, and the Pixel XL is just sh`1rt.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Or maybe you two just have differing opinions on what a "perfect" brightness setting is...
Doesn't matter how you adjust your brightness. I'm just saying that when brightness is low, blacks are darker and disproportionate to other colors.
I love Lux especially with it's profiles. Much better control and accuracy than adaptive brightness. I just wish Lux had an auto-profile switcher based on time of day. I have a day profile, night profile, and car profile.
One thing to note is that Lux allows me to bring the darkness down below 0% to negative values, which is where I usually notice my concerns. But that's what I need to not hurt my eyes at night. So I don't blame the phone or anything - just posted this article out of curiosity. The blacks are probably just turning off completely at some point when I bring the value to below 0% which I think makes sense based on the nature of OLED.
You should just turn on night mode to help with eye strain. If 0% brightness is too bright I don't think you will ever get lux to work the way you want, but night mode helps my eyes a lot.
Pixel XL adaptive brightness adapts to what you set the brightness to. If you go from 0 to 100 in a totally dark room, you notice how the screen stays really bright and doesn't go back to 0 on Pix
Many phones use auto brightness to fullly determine brightness based on sensor and ignores user brightness. If you go from 0 to 100 with an auto brightness phone, the phone will go back to 0.
Some prefer one over the other.

Adaptive Brightness Issues

With adaptive brightness on my screen frequently (every 20 seconds or so) changes brightness slightly even when the ambient light isn't changing. It's very annoying when reading and most noticeable with light backgrounds.
Is this a common issue or does it sound like I have a defective sensor?
dmacarth said:
With adaptive brightness on my screen frequently (every 20 seconds or so) changes brightness slightly even when the ambient light isn't changing. It's very annoying when reading and most noticeable with light backgrounds.
Is this a common issue or does it sound like I have a defective sensor?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here.
So annoying I had to turn adaptive off.
Seems to be when I move, probably changing sensor and it's too sensitive. My head mush change/reflect light on sensor
Anyway it's so distracting that I can't use adaptive brightness, except when pitch dark I can set to 0% adaptive to have lowest light output
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
Yep, reminds me of a disco strobe light!
No issues here. I actually think the brightness swing is much better than the OG Pixel XL. I can just leave the setting at 50%. On the OG XL I'd have to turn the brightness down in the living room with lighting from 1 lamp and a tv because it'd be burning my retinas.
I installed Lux Dash and disabled "adaptive brightness" and let Lux handle it. You can go into the profile editor for Lux and setup different presets for different levels of light, you can also adjust the min and max allowed brightness and even setup how you want it to adjust brightness (fade, only set on unlock, dynamic, etc)
It has really made this screen amazing and even helps with battery because most the day my screen doesn't go above 15-20%
AndrasLOHF said:
No issues here. I actually think the brightness swing is much better than the OG Pixel XL. I can just leave the setting at 50%. On the OG XL I'd have to turn the brightness down in the living room with lighting from 1 lamp and a tv because it'd be burning my retinas.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've been fine here with the Adaptive Brightness too. Doesn't change too often at all for me.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
I installed Lux also and that did the trick. I assume the sensor is fine since Lux uses it with no problem. It's odd that some of us are having problems and others aren't but it doesn't seem to be a sensor issue.
Having this same issue any solution?
Mzzyhmd said:
Having this same issue any solution?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm curious but how exactly is it reacting for you? Are you just sitting in bed with the lights on and it's still adjusting up and down the brightness? Cause that's what I'm doing right now and it hasn't fluctuated at all. If I put it on the bedside table it'll brighten up and when I pick it up it dims but that's it.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
Yeah that's too much fluctuations don't you think I mean on my iPhone x or any other iPhone that I have have used so far I never could tell that the adaptive brightness was on but this device does it in an obvious way and way too frequently that im not sure anymore if this is what it's supposed to do I chatted with a Google agent and they forced quit ambient service thing from system apps and I think that still didn't resolve the issue. I will pop up in a vz store tomorrow and check out if their display devices are doing the same
Mzzyhmd said:
Yeah that's too much fluctuations don't you think I mean on my iPhone x or any other iPhone that I have have used so far I never could tell that the adaptive brightness was on but this device does it in an obvious way and way too frequently that im not sure anymore if this is what it's supposed to do I chatted with a Google agent and they forced quit ambient service thing from system apps and I think that still didn't resolve the issue. I will pop up in a vz store tomorrow and check out if their display devices are doing the same
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm curious to hear what the tell you. Lux has helped me a lot bit I still notice it. To be fair I think I only notice in a dim or dark room with the TV on but this is the first phone I've used where it's noticeable to me. I'm also wondering if this is how it's supposed to work or if there's something wrong with my phone.
Mzzyhmd said:
Yeah that's too much fluctuations don't you think I mean on my iPhone x or any other iPhone that I have have used so far I never could tell that the adaptive brightness was on but this device does it in an obvious way and way too frequently that im not sure anymore if this is what it's supposed to do I chatted with a Google agent and they forced quit ambient service thing from system apps and I think that still didn't resolve the issue. I will pop up in a vz store tomorrow and check out if their display devices are doing the same
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What I described was too much? Sounds appropriate to me. If there's extra light on the phone, I want it to get brighter. If that light goes away, I want it to get dimmer. Now if it was happening with no light changing then I would be annoyed. I keep it at 29% with Adaptive Brightness on and it's not too dark in outside light and not too bright in pitch dark.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
I'm having the same issue. I'm on my second Pixel 2 XL so I don't think it's a sensor problem. I only notice it in lower lighting but it's really annoying when it happens. Haven't seen this issue on any other phone. Im trying out Lux now and set it to only adjust when waking up. There were similar issues when Lux was set to Dynamic.
Ever since Google thought they knew better than everyone else and got rid of auto brightness for adaptive brightness, it's been trash for me. I CONSTANTLY have to raise it in dark rooms and lower it in bright rooms. AKA, I might as well turn it off because I'm manually adjusting it every time anyway.
All in all, it's terrible.
Hobox10 said:
Ever since Google thought they knew better than everyone else and got rid of auto brightness for adaptive brightness, it's been trash for me. I CONSTANTLY have to raise it in dark rooms and lower it in bright rooms. AKA, I might as well turn it off because I'm manually adjusting it every time anyway.
All in all, it's terrible.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You know Adaptive Brightness is a mix of manual and auto brightness right? I remember auto brightness actually having the issues you're describing because there was no way to adjust it if it was set. If you have Adaptive Brightness on high enough, it should be bright enough in dark and bright situations. I believe people's issues are that it adjusts too often or the opposite, it's too dark in light rooms and too bright in dark rooms.
EeZeEpEe said:
You know Adaptive Brightness is a mix of manual and auto brightness right? I remember auto brightness actually having the issues you're describing because there was no way to adjust it if it was set. If you have Adaptive Brightness on high enough, it should be bright enough in dark and bright situations. I believe people's issues are that it adjusts too often or the opposite, it's too dark in light rooms and too bright in dark rooms.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah I know it's supposed to be a mix somewhat. It's supposed to match the setting you set to whatever the surrounding brightness is relative to your brightness setting.
That's exactly WHY it's trash in my opinion though. It's a flawed methodology. I don't want it matching my setting relative to anything. I want it low in the dark and bright in bright rooms or the sun to be legible and not more. It tries to do some meet-you-in-the-middle garbage and it just doesn't work well.
Hobox10 said:
Yeah I know it's supposed to be a mix somewhat. It's supposed to match the setting you set to whatever the surrounding brightness is relative to your brightness setting.
That's exactly WHY it's trash in my opinion though. It's a flawed methodology. I don't want it matching my setting relative to anything. I want it low in the dark and bright in bright rooms or the sun. It tries to do some meet-you-in-the-middle garbage and it just doesn't work well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I found the threshold for the lowest brightness in pitch dark with Adaptive Brightness on to be 29%. That should be dark enough in dark rooms and outdoors it's readable to me. What percentages have you been trying?
Mines doing the same thing. Did anyone work out whether it was hardware?
I used a sensor app to see what light was reporting, and it was stable. I can only assume it's a bug.
For those who aren't sure - if the screen is on, and not moving, without any changes to ambient or direct light, every 20 or so seconds the screen will dim to a warmer colour, and then 20 seconds later will brighten to a whiter colour.
superbestfriends said:
Mines doing the same thing. Did anyone work out whether it was hardware?
I used a sensor app to see what light was reporting, and it was stable. I can only assume it's a bug.
For those who aren't sure - if the screen is on, and not moving, without any changes to ambient or direct light, every 20 or so seconds the screen will dim to a warmer colour, and then 20 seconds later will brighten to a whiter colour.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah I had a feeling that's what people might be experiencing.
To add on to this thread, this is also occuring on my gen 1 Pixel.
Ever since I upgraded to 8.1 the adaptive display will brighten/darken while the phone is sitting still in a constantly lit room.
I also appear to have lost much of the granularity in the brightness selecting bar. The first 25% or so is as dim as it goes, and only after that does it begin to alter the brightness. Previously it would begin around 10% on the bar.
Additionally, the logic behind adaptive brightness seems to have gotten worse. I previously left my brightness setting always in the same place, and no matter where I was it was either dim enough (at night) or bright enough (during the day).
Real unhappy with this update.

brightness issue

Hi everyone. I haven't seen the related kinds of thread so I decided to post it. My device model is G3223.
tl;dr: It's too bright at minimum brightness during nighttime.
So during daytime the screen looks perfectly fine, no problem reading under the sunlight. But when night comes the problem arises because the phone can't go dimer, which means that the phone is still quite bright compare to my other devices when I am trying to read in bed even though the brightness is set at minimum.
Does anyone also facing this issue? Or if it's device model related?
I have the G3221 and I have the same issues. But I found 2 solutions to the problem. (well kind of) if you disable automatic brightness ? setting it will be way too bright. After enabling the auto brightness you can lower it even further. But if it still feels too bright, you can change the white balance settings to 255 which will lower the brightness even further without actually affecting anything. I hope it helps a little. ?
decron04 said:
I have the G3221 and I have the same issues. But I found 2 solutions to the problem. (well kind of) if you disable automatic brightness ? setting it will be way too bright. After enabling the auto brightness you can lower it even further. But if it still feels too bright, you can change the white balance settings to 255 which will lower the brightness even further without actually affecting anything. I hope it helps a little. ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Problem solved. Thanks a lot. I don't know why Sony doesn't allow us to change the brightness to the real minimum point without using automatic brightness.
For white balance I set my phone to a warm colour. For (255,255,255) [r,g,b] the screen looks too cold though, and it can also lower the brightness. I am currently using (255,147,0) so it's at least better than the original setting (0,0,0)
Speaking of warm tones, sony also hides the blue light filter in the actions section which is almost invisible and many people don't even go there. You cannot enable it otherwise. They need work on their stuff.
You can use the Twilight app to use the phone at night without stressing your eyes. It works for me when I'm reading things. ?
And of course you can use this to lower the intensity of the screen's light if not the overall brightness.
Hope this helps.
xperia.sp.lbl.rr said:
You can use the Twilight app to use the phone at night without stressing your eyes. It works for me when I'm reading things.
And of course you can use this to lower the intensity of the screen's light if not the overall brightness.
Hope this helps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for your advice. As far as I know, apps such as twilight only draw an overlay on the screen, which means it actually doesn't affect the brightness in any ways. It just seems to be darker.
In contrast, decron04's solution can actually decrease the brightness. Don't know why Sony doesn't allow users to minimize brightness without using auto brightness.

Categories

Resources