So my MNML case got shipped today, but I just seen a post on reddit about the case not covering the camera bump on the Pixel 2 XL.
Post:
https://www.reddit.com/r/GooglePixe..._2_xl_mnml_case_doesnt_cover_the_camera_bump/
Pics:
https://imgur.com/a/uYVuG
I can't guarantee that the pics are of the final product, but I thought I'd give a heads up to anyone else that has ordered the case.
The product discription says:
PERFECT CUTOUTS - The case fits your Pixel 2 XL like a glove, exposed buttons and ports are perfectly cut giving you full easy access. The camera cutout has a raised bump to protect your camera on surfaces. The front of the case has a raised rim to protect your phone’s screen from scratching.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've emailed MNML for confirmation.
Will be disappointed if it doesn't have a raised bump on the case. I will be returning it myself.
Nightmare79 said:
So my MNML case got shipped today, but I just seen a post on reddit about the case not covering the camera bump on the Pixel 2 XL.
Post:
https://www.reddit.com/r/GooglePixe..._2_xl_mnml_case_doesnt_cover_the_camera_bump/
Pics:
https://imgur.com/a/uYVuG
I can't guarantee that the pics are of the final product, but I thought I'd give a heads up to anyone else that has ordered the case.
The product discription says:
I've emailed MNML for confirmation.
Will be disappointed if it doesn't have a raised bump on the case. I will be returning it myself.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Keep us updated when you hear from them.. Indeed that will be a disappointment..
This is the only reason why i did not order mnml this time. Loved it on my pixel xl. if i want to set my phone done on a metal surface or stone then i am worried that the camera could crack or that the housing around it would scratch.... Still searching for a thin black case that isnt flimsy like TPU. One like this or one that is maybe made similar to the original Nexus case for the 6P. That wasnt very thin , but it was made from a more sturdy and rigid rubber. Also FYI, the peel case and the mnml case are the exact same case. I went through this last year on the Pixel XL 1.
thanks for this.... Had it in my Amazon cart waiting for reviews of it. Gonna hold off and wait to see what Diztronic brings
The person made an update to the post
"EDIT: Ok, so apparently the bump around the fingerprint sensor is large enough that the camera bump doesn't touch the surface. It's not ideal but at least it won't touch on flat surfaces."
Nope no raised bumped around the camera lens. Lens and case are almost flush. Just got mine. Pics attached. Buttons are a lil hard to get to. Case side panel is too flushed to the buttons, if that makes any sense. Also its pretty slippery compared to the actual back of the 2 XL.
https://imgur.com/a/psSRB
It will do for now, for me until Peel ships there's and I can compare.
Well crap. I ordered 2 a long time ago and they just shipped as well. I'm not liking the pictures and what I'm seeing. Guess I'll just keep the case I have on it now
So MNML got back to me.
"When you place the case backside down the raised fingerprint sensor will protect the camera."
Pretty disappointed.
How does the case grip feel in hand? Less, equal, or more grippy than bare phone?
Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
Nightmare79 said:
So MNML got back to me.
"When you place the case backside down the raised fingerprint sensor will protect the camera."
Pretty disappointed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pretty ****ty on their part to advertise one thing and then backtrack and say another.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
Nightmare79 said:
So MNML got back to me.
"When you place the case backside down the raised fingerprint sensor will protect the camera."
Pretty disappointed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
By looking at the back, that's what I thought might be going on. Seems a little questionable though.
Except nobody holds the phone in a way that the bottom lands first!
People hold the phone by the middle or the bottom and often than not the top camera part lands on the surface first. But that's not the issue here, the issue is that you shouldn't have to be concerned with how your phone lands after putting on a case!
A truly bold move by them when the market is flooded with $2 cases from AliExpress without this issue. Most people will opt for a little thicker case from Spigen or whoever to protect the best aspect of pixel phones - the camera.
Fix your ****.
My biggest issue was that the mnml case caused significant scratching on the base of my pixel XL first gen. It made little specks through the black and was showing silver. I think it is because the case want tight like a traditional tpu case that stretches. I'm currently using one of the China cases. I needed something to hold me over until I can find a thin case that works.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
I've had the MNML case on my xl for 6 months with no issues of scratching at all. As far as the xl2's MNML case and lack of hump around camera; I'm ok with the hump being around the fp sensor. Interesting as to why they didn't choose to"hump" the camera tho.. possibly aesthetics and feel?
Got mine in yesterday. I'll be returning them. While they are thin and sleek it doesn't protect anything and as prior mention. It doesn't have a protection around the camera.
I love the thinness of this case, hate that there isn't a completely clear option. Has anyone found something like this? Ultra thin case (not raised on the front bezel) that's completely clear?
I've been using this case since Saturday and, while I love the minimal feel, I don't think I'll be using it long term. The button cutouts are precise, which would normally be a good thing. However, in this case the case is slightly thicker than the buttons protrude from the phone so they actually become recessed. The precise cutout makes it even harder then to discern which buttons you're feeling and pressing, at least for me, requires using my fingernail. Totally kills it for me.
I reached out to Peel and they said there case will have protection for the camera.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
While I did just get it tonight, I'm in the other camp.... I actually love it. It's exactly what I want, a skin with no edges to deal with.
I know all of the complaints when I ordered it, so I guess I knew I would like it.
I pre-ordered 2 of these cases weeks ago, just got them last night. They actually sent me 4 total for some reason, so I have 2 clear and 2 really blue. I'll post some pics in a bit. The fps bump does keep the camera from touching what the phone is sitting on though. This case offers no protection other than scratches, I already knew this though. This will be my weeknight weekend case. The buttons are totally flush with this case so it's hard to tell what your pushing, just FYI.
Related
Writing this review for those who will order their Cases online. I got 2 spigens the other day. But i didnt have my V20 yet. Just got that today. I just went with it since ive always used Spigen cases and have always had faith
Spigen Rugged Armor, i have no complaints. Its what i have on now. I plan to use this as my daily case
Spigen Liquid Crystal, this sadly was a disappointment. Everything is almost okay. Got a good lip on the front. Fits well. Buttons were no problem. The only problem i have is the camera hole. It seems that the case is the same level as the camera lense. If ever its recessed i cant see it. At most maybe 1mm recessed but that might not be enough for an uneven table. With all the "scare" of the camera lense cracking easy, i dont think ill be risking it. Sucks because i wanted to use that case for night outs when i want to show off the phone design.
But the rugged armor has a good enough recess
I also have the liquid crystal and it's a great case however the camera is a bit too close to the surface. My problem with the rugged armor is that it's a glorified jelly/silicone case which offers no bend protection. To be honest the glass cracking on the camera isn't a widespread issue. I honestly think the people who damaged it abused it to begin with. I usually take care of my gadgets diligently.
mtsingson said:
Spigen Liquid Crystal, this sadly was a disappointment.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I bought the liquid crystal case through Amazon and I'm glad I did because I returned it a couple days later at no cost to me. The case discolored to a light yellow/brownish tint after a day or two and my biggest gripe was the 2mm gap between the phone and case around the power button & camera cutout. So I had to press the case down a bit to reach the power button which was a pain when trying to fingerprint unlock. I got my refund I'm just surprised by the poor quality. Definitely a rush job by Spigen.
Sent from my T-Mobile LG V20
mtsingson said:
Writing this review for those who will order their Cases online. I got 2 spigens the other day. But i didnt have my V20 yet. Just got that today. I just went with it since ive always used Spigen cases and have always had faith
Spigen Rugged Armor, i have no complaints. Its what i have on now. I plan to use this as my daily case
Spigen Liquid Crystal, this sadly was a disappointment. Everything is almost okay. Got a good lip on the front. Fits well. Buttons were no problem. The only problem i have is the camera hole. It seems that the case is the same level as the camera lense. If ever its recessed i cant see it. At most maybe 1mm recessed but that might not be enough for an uneven table. With all the "scare" of the camera lense cracking easy, i dont think ill be risking it. Sucks because i wanted to use that case for night outs when i want to show off the phone design.
But the rugged armor has a good enough recess
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm wondering if the camera cutout had to do with the wide angle lens. Maybe if it was deeper it would interfere with the pictures. Just throwing that our there. I've never had a problem with Spigen before, but as someone said it could be a rush job. I think LG rushed the device and the sheer volume is more than anticipated because of the note 7 debacle.
Sent from my SM-N910T using Tapatalk
DLovo313 said:
I bought the liquid crystal case through Amazon and I'm glad I did because I returned it a couple days later at no cost to me. The case discolored to a light yellow/brownish tint after a day or two and my biggest gripe was the 2mm gap between the phone and case around the power button & camera cutout. So I had to press the case down a bit to reach the power button which was a pain when trying to fingerprint unlock. I got my refund I'm just surprised by the poor quality. Definitely a rush job by Spigen.
Sent from my T-Mobile LG V20
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Odd because the one I got is tight and I don't have the same issues you do. Maybe the one you ordered was a fake?
Sent from my LG-H990 using Tapatalk
I ordered the Liquid Crystal case and ended up returning it back to Amazon due to the discoloration of the case.
It appeared to have a slight yellowish tint instead of being "clear" as Spigen claims.
I did not have any issues with fit...all cutouts were exactly correct.
I ended up purchasing the Ringke Fusion, but with smoked black bumpers...a much better choice regarding the protection it provides and still maintaining a minimal design to the LG V20.
I have the Liquid Crystal and don't have complaints other than the single color option. I wanted something with minimal bulk and this is it. It also provides just enough grip that I don't feel uncomfortable using my phone.
Sent from my VS995 using Tapatalk
What glass (front) or protective folie do you use with Spigen liquid crystal .................. i cant find any compatible?
My Spigen thin fit arrived... I'm loving it. Had the Caseology vault to start with. Great case, but much thicker than I wanted. Much prefer this thinner case.
Not super stoked with the completely open top and bottom, but otherwise really love this one.
Have a MNML arriving tomorrow so will see, but think this Spigen is gonna end up winning the battle of the cases for me.
Pics? I'd be interested in top and bottom detailed pics especially.
does it had the little notch inside for a magnet like their s8 thin fit?
It has a slot for metal plate for their magnetic car mounts
this one doesn't cover the front bottom/top edges right?
if so, i'm avoiding it since i've broken a phone due to that before
I have this as well and really like it. I feel like it gives the phone enough protection around the edges even though the top and bottom are open. My only complaint, as stated in another thread, is that I wish the sides were more flush with the phone instead of being so much higher. I think they could have built it to be more flush yet use the corners to give it enough lip to protect the screen when you lay the phone face down. My wife has a neo hybrid on her S8 and this is how it is. Just a better look AND would keep the case from trapping so much lint/dust on the side. Besides that great phone. Love that it has the slot for the metal plate as well as I use a Spigen CD slot mount in my truck.
I've been using the think case for the past 3 days. It's surprisingly light. I'm a bit iffy regarding the amount of protection it offers, so I'm also ordering a rugged case. I do like the indent within the case itself for where you put in the plate for the magnet dock. The other concern is with the amount of lint and dust it will gather around the edges.
I have been using the Spigen Thin case for my Nexus 6 and now on my Pixel 2 XL. I got this case for the good grip that the rubberized material brings. I am very satisfied with this case.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
Does this case feel slippery at all like the Maxboost case does?
I tried that case on my OG XL and hated how slippery it was. https://www.amazon.com/Maxboost-Per...415516&sr=8-1&keywords=maxboost+pixel+xl+case
byproxy said:
My Spigen thin fit arrived... I'm loving it. Had the Caseology vault to start with. Great case, but much thicker than I wanted. Much prefer this thinner case.
Not super stoked with the completely open top and bottom, but otherwise really love this one.
Have a MNML arriving tomorrow so will see, but think this Spigen is gonna end up winning the battle of the cases for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I like super thin cases as well but was annoyed with the open top and bottom. That's why I went with the Maxboost mSnap case. So far I'm loving it. Nice rubber grip and protection on all 4 sides.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
I have heard Spigen makes the best cases; they were my top choice for a case Google Pixel 2 XL Case Rugged Armor. However i accidentally ordered the Pixel 2 case instead of the XL case so now have to wait until Wednesday. But the Pixel 2 case looks amazing, and feels great in the hands. One more day...
I had the spigen thin fit for the 6p and now i have it for the pixel 2 xl and it is almost the same except that it does sit a bit higher on the sides. it is fine cause it makes it easier to handle.
This will be my go to case until i can find something better which will probably be very hard to do.
brockkk said:
does it had the little notch inside for a magnet like their s8 thin fit?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes
2x4 said:
this one doesn't cover the front bottom/top edges right?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
correct.
https://youtu.be/q_vnnBof5BI
Also the video and audio is using the pixel 2 xl with the rode video micro.
Would you mind posting some pictures of the phone in the case? Specifically I am interested in the front view of how much bulk it adds to the edge of the phone when looking at it straight on, and how much it sticks out above the screen(if at all). Would really appreciate it. Thank you.
Looks like the Pikata where the lens bump might touch surface when laying flat.
Please check with phone in.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
If you lay the phone flat on the table the screen is flush with where the case ends. I would not consider this a lay on table design. I have a screen protector though so that adds a tiny bit of thickness.
Do these pictures help? Sorry I have to wait till I get my wife's pixel 2 to take more pictures of my phone in its case. It is very very little bulk on the sides. One of the thinnest cases ive seen. Not quite as thin as the MNML case but its very very close.
https://ibb.co/bwmbcb
https://ibb.co/mA24Vw
https://ibb.co/bSnhHb
https://ibb.co/bMOdqw
jrharvey said:
If you lay the phone flat on the table the screen is flush with where the case ends. I would not consider this a lay on table design. I have a screen protector though so that adds a tiny bit of thickness.
Do these pictures help? Sorry I have to wait till I get my wife's pixel 2 to take more pictures of my phone in its case. It is very very little bulk on the sides. One of the thinnest cases ive seen. Not quite as thin as the MNML case but its very very close.
https://ibb.co/bwmbcb
https://ibb.co/mA24Vw
https://ibb.co/bSnhHb
https://ibb.co/bMOdqw
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OT, but what screen protector is that? How do you like it?
MrBrady said:
OT, but what screen protector is that? How do you like it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's the Skinomi screen protector. I personally hate screen protectors and have never used them on an Android phone and I've never scratched or broken a screen. I don't like any screen protectors including this one just because they can be annoying but this is a necessary annoyance until I get back from my trip overseas. I'd hate to be in another country and either break or scratch my screen. The Skinomi is okay in my opinion but I'm definitely not one to judge screen protectors because I pretty much hate them all.
jrharvey said:
If you lay the phone flat on the table the screen is flush with where the case ends. I would not consider this a lay on table design. I have a screen protector though so that adds a tiny bit of thickness.
Do these pictures help? Sorry I have to wait till I get my wife's pixel 2 to take more pictures of my phone in its case. It is very very little bulk on the sides. One of the thinnest cases ive seen. Not quite as thin as the MNML case but its very very close.
https://ibb.co/bwmbcb
https://ibb.co/mA24Vw
https://ibb.co/bSnhHb
https://ibb.co/bMOdqw
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the pictures, if you lay the case down on the back, is the camera protected yet?
dsmitty166 said:
Thanks for the pictures, if you lay the case down on the back, is the camera protected yet?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The camera is flush so I wouldn't say it adds any actual protection if it falls straight on its back. The case is just a hair thicker than the camera bump so it should not scratch if you rub the phone around on a table or something but if its on concrete or something I bet it would scratch the lens.
Where is it in black for XL 2 not on Amazon
I dont see it anymore. Looks like they took the black off for the 2 XL. maybe they ran out of stock.
I've been using this case for about a week and can say it is one of the better cases I've used on a phone. It is a bit slippery out of the box, but once you "break it in" and has plenty or grip. The buttons are pretty solid and cut-outs are decent. You will not get much screen protection if any but I feel more confident about the protection this will provide then the MNML. Like mentioned earlier, the camera if for the most part flush with the case surface but it will provide a little lift of the surface then going naked without a case.
Just looking to see everyone's a experience with these
I have one and Idk if my hands are small but I find its hard to grip and feels also slippery...
Just me?
I have the light gray one with the mint green power button on my white 3 XL and yeah it's slippery. I love the aesthetics and feel, but it is slippery. When I prop the phone up against something to watch a video in landscape mode, it just slides out.
I had the fabric case for the 2 XL and returned it because it was indeed slippery in the hand it was also more chunky than the current generation. Fast forward to today, I own the spigen rugged case for my new 3XL, and I bought the fabric case to give it a try. It's a lot more slim, and coverage on the front corners is questionable if it took a direct hit when dropped. I can say that it is not so much slipper in the hand. It is moreso grippy than last year's, but still doesnt grip on hard surfaces like when being propped up as one of the other replies suggested. For now, the spigen is staying in a drawer at home. I prefer the look, feel, and prestige of the fabric case.
c_86 said:
Just looking to see everyone's a experience with these
I have one and Idk if my hands are small but I find its hard to grip and feels also slippery...
Just me?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Love the fabric case! Also had one for 2xl and as nice as that one was, the newer one is better. It's slimmer, grippier (not a word), and has better coverage along bottom. It looks great and the fit is perfect, along with the buttons being nice to press too.
The only downside, mentioned by others but not necessarily shared by me, is that the lip is on the smallish side.
I don't have an issue with the lip. If you lay it on a flat surface the glass does not touch so that's good by me.
I also have the Bellroy leather case (super nice) and just ordered the Simply Carbon Fiber case which I'm hoping is as nice as it looks.
im using the indigo on my pixel 3 xl , but i just noticed something i took the phone out of the cover to wipe it ,
i saw a deep scratch on the left side , i did not use my phone without cover . but i think a dust was inside the side and with squeeze feature the phone got scratched.
always check inside the cover
Broke the rear glass
Top-right corner is totally broken and there's a crack thru the whole glass.
At the moment I put some silicon on the corner to avoid pieces of glass from falling, but I need now a case, a very very very slim one.
Bought one from Amazon that was supposed to be slim but... the problem is that the cover on the two longer sides is too high, meaning it is higher than the white aluminium side. Not sure I can explain...
I'm looking for the slimmest and thinnest case that just covers the back and not much on the sides.
Any help?
Thanks
https://www.amazon.com/Spigen-Google-Coated-Surface-Excellent/dp/B07475C1VT/ref=sr_1_1?keywords=pixel+2xl+spigen+thin&qid=1559331787&s=gateway&sr=8-1-spell
I had this one and it was the thinnest I could find. The only real protection is on the back of the phone which proved to be what I needed most. It finally cracked one morning I woke up from my couch and did a full stretch putting my phone into my ceiling fan on high. The case initially took a little get used to due to me being accustomed to the excellent grip from the cloth official Google case. In short, is worth the price, absolutely! Would I buy again, No.
I know this one, too thick and on the sides is too high
Spigen thin fit
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
LoyalJedi said:
Spigen thin fit
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's what I have and it's really thin
This is an extremely thin case but not cheap. I have it and it super nice.
https://www.ipitaka.com/products/magcase-for-google-pixel-2?variant=4542502371356
tylermrsh said:
That's what I have and it's really thin
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It has raised edges
thegios said:
It has raised edges
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They're very small though
https://buypeel.com/products/super-thin-pixel-2-case?variant=52717314771
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B078TPN753/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
Practically identical, and may be exactly what you're looking for. I have both, and love them.
gforceriders said:
This is an extremely thin case but not cheap. I have it and it super nice.
https://www.ipitaka.com/products/magcase-for-google-pixel-2?variant=4542502371356
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 to this. My favorite case, but it scares me to carry it sometimes. Super nice, super thin. Don't imagine it will protect much though.
try this: https://www.ultimateshield.co.uk/co...ucts/ultimate-thin-case-for-google-pixel-2-xl
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B076BJG8YF/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_r6B-CbCXH0X9W
By far the thinnest one I've owned and the way it fits around the edges is pretty flush. Fits like a glove and feels good in the hand. Not really good for protection though if you drop it, but more like a wrap to keep it from getting dinged up.
I can post a photo of mine later if you want one.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
Curiousn00b said:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B076BJG8YF/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_r6B-CbCXH0X9W
By far the thinnest one I've owned and the way it fits around the edges is pretty flush. Fits like a glove and feels good in the hand. Not really good for protection though if you drop it, but more like a wrap to keep it from getting dinged up.
I can post a photo of mine later if you want one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm actually interested in getting this exact case, but in Wine Red. Are there any issues with screen protectors? Would appreciate a photo as well.
Sent from my Google Pixel 2 XL using XDA Labs
Maverick Jester said:
I'm actually interested in getting this exact case, but in Wine Red. Are there any issues with screen protectors? Would appreciate a photo as well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I no longer use glass screen protectors, moved to Skinomi(best screen protector I've found so far).
When I did use them, I used curved ones and the case fit EXACTLY to the edges of it. Everything fit like a glove.
Curiousn00b said:
I no longer use glass screen protectors, moved to Skinomi(best screen protector I've found so far).
When I did use them, I used curved ones and the case fit EXACTLY to the edges of it. Everything fit like a glove.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good to know. I also use film screen protectors (currently using a Sparin one, as the Spigen was sold out at the time) as they don't have the issues that tempered glass ones suffer with curved screens.
Sent from my Google Pixel 2 XL using XDA Labs