Received my Galaxy S9 Exynos - AMA - Samsung Galaxy S9 Questions & Answers

Basically title, picked it up today, using it as my daily driver now.

Gratz!
1. Can you record more then 5 mins in 4K60?
2. Does changing to HEVC degrade IQ, or make the video not stop at 5 min if it does?
3. How hot does the phone get on both settings after 5 mins or more?
4. Does zooming ~5x or more, affect quality less then on the other phones ( i have noticed this on some videos) or the quality is the same?
6. Can you turn off video stabilization - eis, and test out 4K30 vs 4K60, and see which one is better quality? what are their bitrates?
7. Did you have S8/N8 before, is it noticable faster then the S8/N8 (with Oreo?)
Thanks

dazed1 said:
Gratz!
1. Can you record more then 5 mins in 4K60?
2. Does changing to HEVC degrade IQ, or make the video not stop at 5 min if it does?
3. How hot does the phone get on both settings after 5 mins or more?
4. Does zooming ~5x or more, affect quality less then on the other phones ( i have noticed this on some videos) or the quality is the same?
6. Can you turn off video stabilization - eis, and test out 4K30 vs 4K60, and see which one is better quality? what are their bitrates?
7. Did you have S8/N8 before, is it noticable faster then the S8/N8 (with Oreo?)
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1 - Nope :/
2 - Did not see any difference in quality from the phone - but it does not remove the 5 minutes limit
3 - It is fine - however it runs hot after a while
4 - I never zoomed in other phones, but it seems normal ?
5 - No noticeable difference in quality between 30 & 60 fps in 4k, beside the lack of calibration - so it is not like in the iPhone
6 - I had S8, and it seems a tad faster ? But I might still be provisioning as of now, so let's wait a couple of days for that

I had S8, and it seems a tad faster ? But I might still be provisioning as of now, so let's wait a couple of days for that
- any improvements on the screen/display quality over the S8 - or was that display mate just a paid-hype PR piece
-let us know about battery
-what changes to S8 did you noticed (besides the ones they've added in like camera. emoji )
thx

tim2london said:
I had S8, and it seems a tad faster ? But I might still be provisioning as of now, so let's wait a couple of days for that
- any improvements on the screen/display quality over the S8 - or was that display mate just a paid-hype PR piece
-let us know about battery
-what changes to S8 did you noticed (besides the ones they've added in like camera. emoji )
thx
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The screen is awesome. Never seen anything like this before.
In a few days yes.
I have the midnight black version - the aluminium is painted in matte black instead of the glossy one now
The fingerprint sensor is super quick, but registration process is weird, it asks you to swipe your finger instead of lift and touch again - just worth noting.
Speakers are super good and super loud.

Paradoxxx said:
The screen is awesome. Never seen anything like this before.
In a few days yes.
I have the midnight black version - the aluminium is painted in matte black instead of the glossy one now
The fingerprint sensor is super quick, but registration process is weird, it asks you to swipe your finger instead of lift and touch again - just worth noting.
Speakers are super good and super loud.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you said: The screen is awesome. Never seen anything like this before.
you also said you had the S8
i know the S8 screen was/is really good (bar the issues they had with the red/blue taint)
in what ways is the s9 display better than the s8 - sorry for being so anal - but i was always interested :fingers-crossed:

the most important question does it have unlocked bootloader and aosp support ?

tim2london said:
you said: The screen is awesome. Never seen anything like this before.
you also said you had the S8
i know the S8 screen was/is really good (bar the issues they had with the red/blue taint)
in what ways is the s9 display better than the s8 - sorry for being so anal - but i was always interested :fingers-crossed:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The screen seems to be more under your fingers. Also it gets incredibly bright, and calibration out of the box is awesome.
Also the area where it curves is no longer of a different tint.
The color seems a tad more punchy, but that might be just the wallpaper that I use.
x111 said:
the most important question does it have unlocked bootloader and aosp support ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The attachment should answer your first question.

that's is a great start, I'm looking very close to find out if this phone supports easy aosp.

x111 said:
that's is a great start, I'm looking very close to find out if this phone supports easy aosp.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm hoping that since the S9 has Treble support, it'll be getting some AOSP love. If so, I'm definitely getting it.

tomiga said:
I'm hoping that since the S9 has Treble support, it'll be getting some AOSP love. If so, I'm definitely getting it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
how do you know it has Treble support ?
any links maybe?

x111 said:
how do you know it has Treble support ?
any links maybe?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
All phones that come with Oreo are required to support Treble. Since the S9 comes with Oreo, it supports Treble.
OP could confirm by running the following command in an adb shell: getprop ro.treble.enabled

Paradoxxx said:
1 - Nope :/
2 - Did not see any difference in quality from the phone - but it does not remove the 5 minutes limit
3 - It is fine - however it runs hot after a while
4 - I never zoomed in other phones, but it seems normal ?
5 - No noticeable difference in quality between 30 & 60 fps in 4k, beside the lack of calibration - so it is not like in the iPhone
6 - I had S8, and it seems a tad faster ? But I might still be provisioning as of now, so let's wait a couple of days for that
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you test the taken videos 4K30 vs 4K60 on pc to get better idea, on mobile display everything looks amazing - or upload some short ones uncompressed during normal movement?
Do you have any phone to compare the digital zoom with? example 3x on both phones during recording?
You mean lack of stabilization?
Also, if you change settings in pro mode, and use it last, does the same mode/setting launch if you use the double click on power button? (will the camera launch in pro or auto mode?)
Thanks alot

1. What are the settings for the ordinary slow mo mode? Is it 1080p @ 240fps?
2. Can you change the aperture in pro mode WHILE recording video?

dazed1 said:
You mean lack of stabilization?
Also, if you change settings in pro mode, and use it last, does the same mode/setting launch if you use the double click on power button? (will the camera launch in pro or auto mode?)
Thanks alot
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wont have time to check the bitrates and the quality on PC, so I will just reply to what I can from there
Yes I mean no stab in 4k60, and yes the same mode opens if you double tap the power button, but only sometimes, or on some specific mode (?)
Killuminati91 said:
1. What are the settings for the ordinary slow mo mode? Is it 1080p @ 240fps?
2. Can you change the aperture in pro mode WHILE recording video?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1080p240
Nope you cant.

Paradoxxx said:
I wont have time to check the bitrates and the quality on PC, so I will just reply to what I can from there
Yes I mean no stab in 4k60, and yes the same mode opens if you double tap the power button, but only sometimes, or on some specific mode (?)
1080p240
Nope you cant.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What I meant was, if i open pro mode, and make some tweaks, and I close the camera.
Will the camera launch in pro mode when I double press the power button, or the auto mode is launched? If the auto mode is launched, does changing the mode in it, stick or when you double press power it's all on stock? Thanks!

tomiga said:
All phones that come with Oreo are required to support Treble. Since the S9 comes with Oreo, it supports Treble.
OP could confirm by running the following command in an adb shell: getprop ro.treble.enabled
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tested this at MWC and they support Treble!

dazed1 said:
What I meant was, if i open pro mode, and make some tweaks, and I close the camera.
Will the camera launch in pro mode when I double press the power button, or the auto mode is launched? If the auto mode is launched, does changing the mode in it, stick or when you double press power it's all on stock? Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It re opens the Pro mode.

Paradoxxx said:
It re opens the Pro mode.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm sorry dude, but I must be sure you understand me, this is very important to me.
I open pro mode, and set shutter speed to 3 seconds, or I adjust white balance and then I close it the camera app from memory.
Then i double click on power button, does the camera then opens in pro mode with the settings adjusted or its pro mode but on stock- with nothing changed?

dazed1 said:
I'm sorry dude, but I must be sure you understand me, this is very important to me.
I open pro mode, and set shutter speed to 3 seconds, or I adjust white balance and then I close it the camera app from memory.
Then i double click on power button, does the camera then opens in pro mode with the settings adjusted or its pro mode but on stock- with nothing changed?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It re opens on stock after force closing.

Related

Camera: Manual mode lagging

Good day, users. I apologize in advance for my bad English. I'm not a native speaker. I was faced with some features of the device. if you turn on the camera, select the manual mode and manually select ISO, then selecting the manual shutter speed, the camera starts to lag hopelessly. The greater the exposure, the greater the lag. At the same time if you select auto ISO, the stop lags. Only I have a problem?
P. S OxygenOS 3.2.1
Noticed that to but I think the display is showing you what you have selected e.g if you select a 4 second shutter it will display 4 second lag on the display. I know its sounds odd and my g4 does not do this but I think one plus are doing this on purpose maybe ? I could be totally wrong and I don't like it also but am sure it's showing a preview of what is going to really happen ?
ipmanwck said:
Noticed that to but I think the display is showing you what you have selected e.g if you select a 4 second shutter it will display 4 second lag on the display. I know its sounds odd and my g4 does not do this but I think one plus are doing this on purpose maybe ? I could be totally wrong and I don't like it also but am sure it's showing a preview of what is going to really happen ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I searched this question and found the same answer. It's really not cool. I think it can be fixed(Maybe in CM or custom camera driver). I have Meizu Pro 5 and it's have more comfortable behavior like your G4.

Google Camera is finally here people ??

Yes you read it correct our long wait is over now. Now we too can enjoy the amazing processing of gcam. Everything works like a charm and there is a significant improvement in the quality. I'm sure this will get better as this is obiously an early build.
And it's not the pixel 2 camera but it's the pixel 3 one!..
Here's what works:
*Portrait mode on both front and back cams(only on humans)
*HDR+, HDR+ enhanced
*Panorama (super glitchy for now)
*And pretty much everything else
*Night mode ( slight improvements only)
*Photo Sphere
Here's what doesn't work:
*Live Google lens
At first the images will look dead.So after you install it you need to increase the saturation. Go to settings , bsg mod settings , saturation and change saturation of front and back cam.
Literally all the credit goes to @xdaakhil for digging this up. If you want to thank someone thank him.
Well my thanks button is down there too ?
Working on :
Honor 9 Lite
Honor 7X
Honor P Smart
Mate 10 Lite
P20 Lite
Honor 6x
keep testing
Edit: video and photos sphere works after changing the default storage to internal. Don't know why it doesn't work with the SD card?
Photo sphere is also very buggy
Photos cannot be clicked without enabling HDR+ or HDR+ enhanced.
There is a pinkish tint on highlights. This can be overcome if you guys focus on the lit(highlights) part by tapping on the viewfinder.
This port can work without root or any modifications.
Stock https://imgur.com/gallery/qvzPuAo
Gcam https://imgur.com/gallery/1bGXR6h
Here's the original thread where you can find the link to the camera:https://forum.xda-developers.com/9-lite/themes/google-pixel-3-camera-port-honor-9-lite-t3858075
Stock cam:
Honor 9 lite stock cam https://imgur.com/gallery/qvzPuAo
Gcam:
Honor 9 lite gcam https://imgur.com/gallery/1bGXR6h
All photos were taken indoors in relatively low lights. So considering that it's pretty cool. Just wish the video gets fixed soon.
It showing " app not installed" what to do?
abhi2912 said:
It showing " app not installed" what to do?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
? Don't know why that happened. Try downloading it again.
To those of you who who don't know why portrait only work on humans:
Gcam doesn't utilise the secondary camera that comes with the device as pixel phones have a single lens setup. The portrait is completely software based. You can check this, cover the secondary lens and click a portrait pic, it'll work!
This is also very useful as we will get good quality blur and edge detection like flagships in our budget phones as the software processing is the same in both apps.
So the camera cannot detect Dept between the subject and background as it only uses one lens.
Hello,
please, tell me, did you find optimal settings of gcam for our phone? Saturation and HDR+? I am testing it but I am not finding the perfect combination yet.
binpe13 said:
Hello,
please, tell me, did you find optimal settings of gcam for our phone? Saturation and HDR+? I am testing it but I am not finding the perfect combination yet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well im also a bit confused about the perfect match.
But this is what I use:
Pixel 3 as the input method in both front and rear cams(for the super res zoom to work)
Saturation, rear cam highlights 2.7 shadow 2.9
Front cam highlights 2.2 shadow 2.6
Tweak around yourself but I couldn't get the cam to take a picture like it is shown in the viewfinder and the skin tones are better in the viewfinder than the final photo ( the details are far better though)
Thank you Fredin. I will test it.
Been lurking for a while, just registered to say thanks, works nicely the difference is pretty big! Panoramic mode is slow and buggy for me but photosphere does the same thing anyway and works well, lastly, is the RAW picture supposed to look really low resolution like it does for me?
It's working on P Smart as well, will be testing more tomorrow.
Isopropil said:
It's working on P Smart as well, will be testing more tomorrow.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good to know it works on more devices.
It's good to know that you guys find it useful but it's been digged up by @xdaakhil I don't want to steal his work, I just
posted this with more details about the bugs and a small comparison.
Anyways thanks guys. Keep testing
anontb said:
Been lurking for a while, just registered to say thanks, works nicely the difference is pretty big! Panoramic mode is slow and buggy for me but photosphere does the same thing anyway and works well, lastly, is the RAW picture supposed to look really low resolution like it does for me?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah the raw shots do look like it's of low quality(don't know why). But since this build wasn't built for us this is really good.
Only if someone ports the camera for Kirin devices.
Anyways good to hear from you.
Is there a way to get slow mo working?
Btw thanks for the awesome work
Kushagra4902 said:
Is there a way to get slow mo working?
Btw thanks for the awesome work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm not sure as slow motion recording requires hardware support which our phones dosent have.
Normally phones (including ours) records in 30 or 60 fps which is good for taking normal videos but not for slow-mo recording. All the apps you see in playstore just slows down the fps and processes them to slow the video down, but this causes quality loss and an artificial feel to it.
So I don't think we will be about to get slow motion working.
Kushagra4902 said:
Is there a way to get slow mo working?
Btw thanks for the awesome work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
its not working on any phone right now.. including op6, poco f1 etc.. its not been fixed yet
Yup, its working on my honor 9 lite like boom but 1 thing I would like to ask is that it supports any image stabilisation or not.

Main camera distortion

Using Global version 11.0.6.0.
I notice that the main camera, even at 1x setting, produces quite a bit of pincushion distortion at the edges. Furthermore, in 0.6x wide angle, the distortion is severe and not at all helped by turning on the correction setting.
None of the camera reviews for the RN8P mention this, so I am wondering if there is a defect in my device.
Any thoughts?
use gcam it will fix it
Nihat2003lol said:
use gcam it will fix it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I guess I have to pick my poison. I briefly tried Gcam but didn't really evaluate it because it seemed so laggy and buggy
jshames said:
I guess I have to pick my poison. I briefly tried Gcam but didn't really evaluate it because it seemed so laggy and buggy
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes it seems laggy but it is good. To not to experience bugs download [this]
Nihat2003lol said:
yes it seems laggy but it is good. To not to experience bugs download [this]
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried it and I don't see any clear improvement over the built in app, either with distortion or with the photo quality itself. In fact the native app 64 mp mode is much clearer
I admit that I haven't bothered with using the xml file, in the past I haven't found that its worth the effort...
jshames said:
I tried it and I don't see any clear improvement over the built in app, either with distortion or with the photo quality itself. In fact the native app 64 mp mode is much clearer
I admit that I haven't bothered with using the xml file, in the past I haven't found that its worth the effort...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Use it with hdr+ option on. Otherwise you cant see anyting different.
Nihat2003lol said:
Use it with hdr+ option on. Otherwise you cant see anyting different.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only when I use the "enhanced HDR+" is there a difference, but that's like night mode where it takes a few seconds to take the shot
I saw a youtube review and comparison using this version and the stock app. The reviewer perhaps could see the difference (pixel peeping), but it was not obvious to me

Question Gcam for Edge X30 / Edge 30 Pro / Edge Plus 2022 (Working Night Mode, Face Retouch + Config File)

Hi All,
This may be the best Gcam version for Edge X30.
I created the config file to make everything work flawlessly.
1. Face retouch working for all cameras
2. Night sight is also working
3. Tweaked the post processing a little to brighten up the shadows but still keep the exposure the same (no overblown highlights)
Install Gcam and load config file.
Let me know what you think or if there is any improvement required with the
Working great here, only 60 fps video is lag.
Will this work with the moto edge 30 pro? Its the global version of edge X30.
@aniketk1 , works on Moto Edge 30 Pro without a problem.
would it be ok to try this on the edge plus 2022? thanks
wickets said:
would it be ok to try this on the edge plus 2022? thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. Basically the Edge x30, Edge 30 Pro and Edge Plus 2022 are all the same models with different names.
ijuanp03 said:
Yes. Basically the Edge x30, Edge 30 Pro and Edge Plus 2022 are all the same models with different names.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thank you
What about the new Edge 30, will it work? I don't wanna brick the phone... Thanks in advance
How do I move the options arrow toggle thing? Almost entire convered by the pin hole front cam, took me a lot longer than I'd like to admit to figure out how to get to the camera settings
Thank you a lot for providing this XML file. However, I would like to know if there is any way to enable the Macro feature (available in the original Moto camera). I've tried modifying the configuration, with manual Focus and activating the Third Axilliary Camera (which resulted b/w, by the way) but I couldn't achieve it.
If someone has any info about that, or another config, I would be extremely grateful!
PS: I have an Edge 30 Pro
All the photos get pink tint arround the edges of the photo, is there a fix for this?
MiguelEsteves said:
All the photos get pink tint arround the edges of the photo, is there a fix for this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the same problem with selfies, but they tend to be reddish for me. Too many problems, at the end I've switched back to the original Moto camera, I always shoot in Professional mode and I'm currently satisfied of the results
bitkris said:
I have the same problem with selfies, but they tend to be reddish for me. Too many problems, at the end I've switched back to the original Moto camera, I always shoot in Professional mode and I'm currently satisfied of the results
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah the pro mode is actually great! I was just trying to get good hdr raw files from the gcam, I got used to my now dead Mi 10T Pro, it had a great camera, but was worse than this in everything else :')
I just reloaded the config file and the photos seem better on the normal cameras. Selfie cam has purple/reddish on the border of the image.
The app works very well! The only problem I encountered is that trying to use the ultrawide sensor in video mode, the app crashes.
Using moto edge 30.
Any way I can fix?
Thanks!
MiguelEsteves said:
All the photos get pink tint arround the edges of the photo, is there a fix for this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Easy fix. Go to Settings > Advanced > Black Level
Back Camera - auto
Front Camera - off
I also have another problem, in astro mode it doesn't do long exposures, is there a way to make it do long exposures?
On my Xiaomi Mi10T Pro it could do astro photography with multiple long exposures and it could take arround 2min.
Also even on my older Lenovo P2 it could do 10sec long exposures.
Please help, I wanna put this mediocre camera up to its paces
ijuanp03 said:
大家好,
这可能是 Edge X30 最好的 Gcam 版本。
我创建了配置文件以使一切正常工作。
1.面部修饰适用于所有相机
2.夜视也有效
3. 稍微调整后期处理以提亮阴影,但仍保持曝光不变(没有过度高光)
安装 Gcam 并加载配置文件。
让我知道您的想法或是否需要改进
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
感谢
Hey just wanted to point out, if you have the video in I believe 60 frames per second, if you switch to the front camera, then back to the main shooter, it causes the program to crash.
Not sure if that's caused by my lack of knowledge of where to put the config file, I just saved a random config, and copied over what was posted in this thread into that folder, then deleted the one I created.
Guys, can you post some Night Sight pics taken with Gcam and Edge 30 phones?
ijuanp03 said:
Hi All,
This may be the best Gcam version for Edge X30.
I created the config file to make everything work flawlessly.
1. Face retouch working for all cameras
2. Night sight is also working
3. Tweaked the post processing a little to brighten up the shadows but still keep the exposure the same (no overblown highlights)
Install Gcam and load config file.
Let me know what you think or if there is any improvement required with the
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How do you load the config file?
Nevermind, found your instructions

Question Really no fix for HDR/DV dark scenes?

I was really satisfied with tablet until I started to watch DV and HDR movies (netflix, hbomax, plex). Searching internet and I could not find nothing to get rid of "ultra" black dark scenes in videos.
Is there any app that would change gamma of video or something like that?
I'm so disappointed that I'm looking which tablet should I buy and sell this one ... wrote to Xiaomi via email and via system bug report and no solution, it seems they really don't care for us - users of this tablet ...
Anyone with some "solution" out there?
I am using kodi + netflix plugin to force SDR streams
It takes some effort to set up and you lose some of netflix functionality (like downloads)
I think there's also similar plugins for other services (disney+, HBOmax, etc) but I have not personally tried them
It's a shame because xiaomi keeps marketing this device as Dolby Vision capable but we have to look for workarounds to disable this "feature"
Hopefully they will fix it if we provide enough reports, and now that the device got released in India it's expected to get more attention because it's a big market for Xiaomi
gregyk said:
I was really satisfied with tablet until I started to watch DV and HDR movies (netflix, hbomax, plex). Searching internet and I could not find nothing to get rid of "ultra" black dark scenes in videos.
Is there any app that would change gamma of video or something like that?
I'm so disappointed that I'm looking which tablet should I buy and sell this one ... wrote to Xiaomi via email and via system bug report and no solution, it seems they really don't care for us - users of this tablet ...
Anyone with some "solution" out there?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm also looking for this from weeks but no luck. We have to wait if Xiomi will fix this via update or we have to accept and start using as it is.
For the new tablet, you won't get any tablet in this price range which can beat mi tab 5 performance (except DV and HDR issue) if you want to wait then check realme tab having 870 processor and same specifications as mi pad 5.
Maybe new lenovo, but cost more
there is no fix for this, the screen is ips
Go to Advanced tools -> Video toolbox and add apps to video toolbox. Now when you open any added app, you will see a pill at top left corner. Drag it and select different styles of scenes. One of those styles disables HDR.
Sharath007 said:
Go to Advanced tools -> Video toolbox and add apps to video toolbox. Now when you open any added app, you will see a pill at top left corner. Drag it and select different styles of scenes. One of those styles disables HDR.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi sir. In which app should I perform these steps?
Sharath007 said:
Go to Advanced tools -> Video toolbox and add apps to video toolbox. Now when you open any added app, you will see a pill at top left corner. Drag it and select different styles of scenes. One of those styles disables HDR.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's not true at all. There's not a single option that disables HDR, they only apply filters to the apps you chose. HDR is on a system level and it cannot be disabled at this moment.
Toolbox might help if you chose the "Outside" style, but still crap with black/dark content.
skater96 said:
That's not true at all. There's not a single option that disables HDR, they only apply filters to the apps you chose. HDR is on a system level and it cannot be disabled at this moment.
Toolbox might help if you chose the "Outside" style, but still crap with black/dark content.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree. It doesn't solve the issue entirely but atleast I can see the picture a little better in bright environment.
Xiaomi should definitely address this.
Shan8nu said:
Hi sir. In which app should I perform these steps?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Settings -> Special Features -> Video toolbox -> Manage video apps
Sharath007 said:
Settings -> Special Features -> Video toolbox -> Manage video apps
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It works effectively in Chinese rom. I really like chinese rom better than global.
What ips has to do with HDR? There are ips tv with hdr.
Kajman said:
What ips has to do with HDR? There are ips tv with hdr.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah my thought exactly
People are saying this is an ips panel, display does not have enough brightness, etc.
Companies have been doing HDR on cheap displays for years
The ultimate goal of HDR is having better details in dark scenes.
You can still achieve this even if the display is ips or have average brightness, but you get the side effect of somewhat duller colors
But what I see on the Mi Pad 5 is definitely some kind of a software bug or miscalibration, because it does the exact opposite of HDR, it destroys scene details bright or dark
You can throw all the brightness in the world on this and it's not going to fix it
Kajman said:
What ips has to do with HDR? There are ips tv with hdr.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AssumedDiz said:
Yeah my thought exactly
People are saying this is an ips panel, display does not have enough brightness, etc.
Companies have been doing HDR on cheap displays for years
The ultimate goal of HDR is having better details in dark scenes.
You can still achieve this even if the display is ips or have average brightness, but you get the side effect of somewhat duller colors
But what I see on the Mi Pad 5 is definitely some kind of a software bug or miscalibration, because it does the exact opposite of HDR, it destroys scene details bright or dark
You can throw all the brightness in the world on this and it's not going to fix it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the problem is because the price, if you xiaomi change it with an amoled screen it will easily be 100$ more. your best bet is just sell your tab 5 now and buy a lenovo p11 pro with weaker processor but better screen.
and problems all the way, read their forums, it doesn't look good.
AssumedDiz said:
Yeah my thought exactly
People are saying this is an ips panel, display does not have enough brightness, etc.
Companies have been doing HDR on cheap displays for years
The ultimate goal of HDR is having better details in dark scenes.
You can still achieve this even if the display is ips or have average brightness, but you get the side effect of somewhat duller colors
But what I see on the Mi Pad 5 is definitely some kind of a software bug or miscalibration, because it does the exact opposite of HDR, it destroys scene details bright or dark
You can throw all the brightness in the world on this and it's not going to fix it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is a SW issue. DV and HDR is fine with just player and mpv-android. It just doesn't work on streaming platforms.
It's also weird that people point out it's only 500 nits. Many laptop displays, ipads, imacs etc have "only" 500 nits too and they do HDR and DV fine (by fine I mean no black crush issues). So xiaomi just needs to fix it asap.
I have created a post about it in the official miui forums
https://c.mi.com/thread-4072183-1-0.html
if you have this issue and interested in getting it fixed you can leave a reply there that you have the issue
hopefully then it gets enough attention from devs
also report it from your device Settings -> Feedback
AssumedDiz said:
I have created a post about it in the official miui forums
https://c.mi.com/thread-4072183-1-0.html
if you have this issue and interested in getting it fixed you can leave a reply there that you have the issue
hopefully then it gets enough attention from devs
also report it from your device Settings -> Feedback
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried to reply, but xiaomi forum is as crappy as them their software.
skater96 said:
I tried to reply, but xiaomi forum is as crappy as them their software.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah when I posted the link I had just modified the post to include one more sample
so it was probably under moderation
please try now and see if it works, someone posted a reply moments ago
or perhaps try using the app
AssumedDiz said:
yeah when I posted the link I had just modified the post to include one more sample
so it was probably under moderation
please try now and see if it works, someone posted a reply moments ago
or perhaps try using the app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nothing, not working. Crappy forum...

Categories

Resources