Why safetynet do not pass on any custom rom? - Moto Z Play Questions & Answers

I tired all arm64 custom roms for moto z play, some arm, tried mixing with all kernels and magisk/without magisk.
And i can't pass safetynet on all these configurations

That's the point of SN. Those ROMs aren't certified by Google so they don't want you to pass. That's not a problem of any ROM, that's how it's intended to work

But I have passed with magisk

Artim_96 said:
That's the point of SN. Those ROMs aren't certified by Google so they don't want you to pass. That's not a problem of any ROM, that's how it's intended to work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But on my old phone, i was using custom roms (not certificed), and SN was passing.

mijing said:
But I have passed with magisk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
With ROM you using?

dawidrejowski said:
With ROM you using?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Im using official Validus ..you can try universal safety net fix to pass safety net.I'm using this.

dawidrejowski said:
But on my old phone, i was using custom roms (not certificed), and SN was passing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How old of a phone? My last phone (HTC One M8) passed on custom ROMs because it didn't seem to report the bootloader was unlocked. But I have safety net passing on custom ROMs on my Z play thanks to magisk and universal safteynet fix beta 5.

mijing said:
Im using official Validus ..you can try universal safety net fix to pass safety net.I'm using this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you mean by "universal..." - magisk? if so, which release are you using? Thanks!

KrisM22 said:
What do you mean by "universal..." - magisk? if so, which release are you using? Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Universal safetyNet Fix(v2 Beta 5) is the module of Magisk

mijing said:
Universal safetyNet Fix(v2 Beta 5) is the module of Magisk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is a very old one - could you please attach it to your post for a few minutes? TIA!

KrisM22 said:
That is a very old one - could you please attach it to your post for a few minutes? TIA!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it is too old but till now it is usefull as you can see

mijing said:
Yes it is too old but till now it is usefull as you can see
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I found it up on
https://androidfilehost.com/?fid=673368273298984533
is that it?
I'll go try it on AOSP 8.1 Alberto97

Yes,It Is. but I dont Know about AOSP Is it will work or not

mijing said:
Yes,It Is. but I dont Know about AOSP Is it will work or not
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lots of red messages so far - what version of magisk MANAGER are you using? (magisk/settings/about) - I tried 4.3.1 but no go.
EDIT I see you're running 16 of magisk, but have added module 14 2-5. How did you manage to add that?

KrisM22 said:
lots of red messages so far - what version of magisk MANAGER are you using? (magisk/settings/about) - I tried 4.3.1 but no go.
EDIT I see you're running 16 of magisk, but have added module 14 2-5. How did you manage to add that?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes I'm using v16 of magisk with module
Go to magisk manager - module - + bottom (for add Module) install it
If installation fail you can flash with recovery that's it.
(My English? )

mijing said:
But I have passed with magisk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Edit: Never mind I saw what Rom you were running.

mijing said:
Yes I'm using v16 of magisk with module
Go to magisk manager - module - + bottom (for add Module) install it
If installation fail you can flash with recovery that's it.
(My English )
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your English is excellent!!!
I now have a very tiny understanding of Magisk Modules...
I started with 1600 this time (it later updated the mgr).
I thought this failed before so it may be necessary to try to add module with magisk, let it fail, then boot to recovery, flash that old 2 beta 5 zip (flash goes fine) , and reboot and I find that old 2 beta 5 zip is now in magisk modules. YOU THE PERSON!!! (gender non-specific version of you da man!)
I went on to do my usual of install TBPro, restore my stuff(obviously root works), reboot to recovery to backup at this point. and test. SafetyNet passes fully, Pogo plays, Netflix shows in gpstore. And I now have a working 8.1 on my MZP.
HUGE THANKS for your patience!!!!!!!

KrisM22 said:
Your English is excellent!!!
I now have a very tiny understanding of Magisk Modules...
I started with 1600 this time (it later updated the mgr).
I thought this failed before so it may be necessary to try to add module with magisk, let it fail, then boot to recovery, flash that old 2 beta 5 zip (flash goes fine) , and reboot and I find that old 2 beta 5 zip is now in magisk modules. YOU THE PERSON!!! (gender non-specific version of you da man!)
I went on to do my usual of install TBPro, restore my stuff(obviously root works), reboot to recovery to backup at this point. and test. SafetyNet passes fully, Pogo plays, Netflix shows in gpstore. And I now have a working 8.1 on my MZP.
HUGE THANKS for your patience!!!!!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Im glad you have fix your problem

KrisM22 said:
Your English is excellent!!!
I now have a very tiny understanding of Magisk Modules...
I started with 1600 this time (it later updated the mgr).
I thought this failed before so it may be necessary to try to add module with magisk, let it fail, then boot to recovery, flash that old 2 beta 5 zip (flash goes fine) , and reboot and I find that old 2 beta 5 zip is now in magisk modules. YOU THE PERSON!!! (gender non-specific version of you da man!)
I went on to do my usual of install TBPro, restore my stuff(obviously root works), reboot to recovery to backup at this point. and test. SafetyNet passes fully, Pogo plays, Netflix shows in gpstore. And I now have a working 8.1 on my MZP.
HUGE THANKS for your patience!!!!!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check for Bluetooth and wifi if they are working correctly. I flashed the fix on AOSP and my Bluetooth crashed, needed to restore backup.

Related

Magisk on Pixel / Pixel XL - does it work yet?

So I've been trying to get magisk working for a while on Pixel XL and magisk version 11 still gives the unable to mount /system error.
Anyone find a workaround yet? Not being able to use Android Pay is annoying...
wireaudio said:
So I've been trying to get magisk working for a while on Pixel XL and magisk version 11 still gives the unable to mount /system error.
Anyone find a workaround yet? Not being able to use Android Pay is annoying...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey... Check the last paragraph of this post: https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=71502787&postcount=17 named "What's Next"
Cheers...
I've also been curious about this but everything I've read says it's just a matter of the dev of Magisk being able to implement into how the Pixel works. Looking forward to that *hopefully* happening sometime in the future!
bravesfan171 said:
I've also been curious about this but everything I've read says it's just a matter of the dev of Magisk being able to implement into how the Pixel works. Looking forward to that *hopefully* happening sometime in the future!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is the exacts developer's words. It's been posted 23 hours ago:
topjohmwu said:
For the long awaited Pixel support, I think I'll start working on it, but the complexity of that device might take a very long time for me to understand, since I do not own the device. I can only borrow my friend's device for not that long of a period of time, so progress shall be really slow. I'll not get the Pixel device now, because I don't think it is worth the price and the hassle for me to import it into Taiwan, but I'll definitely get the Pixel 2 to replace my current daily driver lol.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks guys! Much appreciated!
wireaudio said:
Thanks guys! Much appreciated!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hello... Maybe take a look at this: https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=71573863&postcount=1029
Cheers...
Works perfectly. March Pure Nexus w/ PN kernel. Installed the V4A module too. Mario works. Pay works. Safety net passes 100%. Use TWRP RC2 and make sure to flash TWRP again after flashing Magisk.
funkybrunk said:
Works perfectly. March Pure Nexus w/ PN kernel. Installed the V4A module too. Mario works. Pay works. Safety net passes 100%. Use TWRP RC2 and make sure to flash TWRP again after flashing Magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm getting an error when installing Magisk 11.6 on the Pixel, says:
"Updater process ended with Error: 1
Error installing zip file Magisk-v11.6-Pixel.zip"
Anyone else run into this with a fix?
----------------------------------------------------
Just wiped everything, still no go.
Getting the exact same error. This seems like an error with TWRP or the zip file I'm using.
The error pops up during the "Unpacking boot image" stage.
You need to used TWRP RC2. Your errors are because you are on RC1
funkybrunk said:
You need to used TWRP RC2. Your errors are because you are on RC1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So I'm using PN with EX kernel. Does magisk work with EX? Just flash the rc 2 zip while on RC 1?
318sugarhill said:
So I'm using PN with EX kernel. Does magisk work with EX? Just flash the rc 2 zip while on RC 1?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it works on PN, and yes it will work with EX but EX doesn't give you the same options in aroma (as SuperSU) because it isn't recognizing magisk root.
pcriz said:
Yes it works on PN, and yes it will work with EX but EX doesn't give you the same options in aroma (as SuperSU) because it isn't recognizing magisk root.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok thanks. Will flashing the PN Rom switch the kernel back. or will I have to flash that manually
318sugarhill said:
Ok thanks. Will flashing the PN Rom switch the kernel back. or will I have to flash that manually
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
PN has its own kernel so I am assuming yes it will.
pcriz said:
PN has its own kernel so I am assuming yes it will.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok. Hopefully dirty flashing will just reset the kernel
318sugarhill said:
Ok. Hopefully dirty flashing will just reset the kernel
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I should've been more definitive in my answer. Yes it will replace the kernel when you flash the rom, my bad.
I was using pure Nexus with Ex kernel....I flashed PN Rom (dirty flash) just to reset kernel....Flashed TWRP RC1 zip zip....Reboot system, then reboot recovery and flashed TWRP RC2 zip, reboot system, reboot to recovery flashed Magisk then reboot system again. Reboot to recovery flashed vendor img for PN and all is good. Enabled magisk hide in magisk app settings.....Then under magisk hide I hid it from DirecTV Now app. All safety net tests pass. Needed a build prop edit for directTV now to work correctly but all other apps blocked because of root are now working.
Thanks for the assistance
Does magisk work on 7.1.2?
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
bb12489 said:
Does magisk work on 7.1.2?
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Working fine for me with Latest ElementalX Kernel
liam_davenport said:
Working fine for me with Latest ElementalX Kernel
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good deal. What do you think would be the best way to update to 7.1.2? I have TWRP recovery and elementalX at the moment. Should I flash stock boot.img, then update? I Imagine I would have to flash magisk again though.
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
has anyone gotten any of the modules to work ?

Magisk on the OnePlus 5T

Anyone had any success flashing Magisk on the 5T yet? I've tried + it flashes fine, but WiFi doesn't work; neither mobile data.
Semi solution:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-5t/development/rom-freedomos-2-0-2-t3709708
The ROM comes with Magisk (I can't say first hand since I don't have a phone yet)
Yes magisk working but dont Format Data.
Hmmm, I have it without issues (I think).
Followed this post: https://forums.oneplus.net/threads/oneplus-5t-unlock-bootloader-flash-twrp-root-nandroid-efs.685403/
@Theberge43 on the 5t not the 5 right? Did you flash v14 or v14.something i.e the beta version? Thanks!
madyoda said:
@Theberge43 on the 5t not the 5 right? Did you flash v14 or v14.something i.e the beta version? Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On the 5T indeed. Used this link (from the mentioned thread): https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/beta-magisk-v13-0-0980cb6-t3618589
@Theberge43 magisk code 1456 + it's fully working for you? Interesting thanks - I'll try it again as it didn't work for me!
madyoda said:
@Theberge43 magisk code 1456 + it's fully working for you? Interesting thanks - I'll try it again as it didn't work for me!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here is my Magisk.
@Theberge43 nice thanks! About to try
@Theberge43 yup that worked thanks! No idea what happened the first time - possible corrupt zip or faulty flash I guess!
Maybe I spoke a tad too soon. If I reboot, the modem goes again. If I then reboot, it comes back, etc etc. Weird!
Schrotty35 said:
Yes magisk working but dont Format Data.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
At what point should not format the data? If you are on the stock rom, you have to go on recovery and directly flash magisk?
(When i flash magisk, i reboot always on recovery...and i can't flash FreedomOS with modified TWRP or Blue_spark....)à
I actually flashed the official version and not beta. Works perfectly fine on OP5T (latest OxygenOS update).
No problems at all with magisk. Not using any guide, just flashed twrp, dm-verity patch from jcadduono, magisk 14.0
Both 4G and WiFi work as expected.
v14.3 here with no issues. Was just in a badspot for the first screen shot. Went right back to LTE
mad-murdock said:
No problems at all with magisk. Not using any guide, just flashed twrp, dm-verity patch from jcadduono, magisk 14.0
Both 4G and WiFi work as expected.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dm patch not need.
can't wait to get my 5t , first thing is installing magisk and adaway
Schrotty35 said:
Dm patch not need.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
With me i must flash dm verity to start on the system
samtab37 said:
With me i must flash dm verity to start on the system
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok have you a link for working version on 5t?
Schrotty35 said:
Ok have you a link for working version on 5t?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is the same as OnePlus 5: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YMHqtyILolheUuJtjpmCbL6hHKD5MQo0/view?usp=drivesdk
I try new version (v6) of no verity but don't work, for me this file is the only way to boot
Envoyé de mon ONEPLUS A5010 en utilisant Tapatalk

[MAGISK] [8.0] ARCore with modded Google Camera

Hey,
I've created a small magisk module, with that you can use the Argument Reality function inside the Google Camera.
It works on AOSP 8.0 Beta and Stable, maybe it also works on nougat.
When you want to test it on other devices than the Mi A1, please don't forget to make a backup even if bootloop and such things are very unlikely.
Wehen you have a device where it also works you are allowed to create a thread, only condition link me and very important Arnova8G2 because without his work it would not be possible.
Installation instructions:
The modules can easily flashed inside the Magisk Manager or with TWRP.
To get it fully working you have to flash both modules
Downloads:
All in one version:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/mi...re-modded-google-camera-t3720269/post75090632
ARcore Basic files:
https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=1C3pylJpeK9bc93L56v1JWrjJNXnNbU06
ARcore Basic files V2:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/16YyJN1PTDMZ5WPQ_F2VFZuyTJlAOmAyi/view?usp=sharing
Apps Module:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/12t5jRzlEM0tz1mkyKqjwu0RS8yZ37IeY/view?usp=sharing
Apps Module V2:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/19rtu2nUAcH2WKCBbGbm2F75uXsfwKXt4/view?usp=sharing
Do not thank me, just thank him @Arnova8G2
Thanks for your contribution! Will try as soon as I get the oreo beta working on my phone.
Unable to flash via magisk
Unable to flash via TWRP nor Magisk, maybe cause data partition is encripted
fosco_ said:
Unable to flash via TWRP nor Magisk, maybe cause data partition is encripted
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My storage is also encrypted and it works.
AnnePunk said:
My storage is also encrypted and it works.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What version of Magisk and Magisk Manager?
fosco_ said:
What version of Magisk and Magisk Manager?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Latest Magisk Beta: v14.5 (code: 1456)
Magisk Manager: v5.4.3
AnnePunk said:
Latest Magisk Beta: v14.5 (code: 1456)
Magisk Manager: v5.4.3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can't get Magisk Manager to install any module, it says something like /data/magisk not setup....
Yash98 said:
I can't get Magisk Manager to install any module, it says something like /data/magisk not setup....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Had the same bug, reinstall magisk with the Magisk Manager, reboot and try again.
I can flash other zip.. But these two can't be flashed on magisk
Rakibboss said:
I can flash other zip.. But these two can't be flashed on magisk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmm for me it works
Whatever, i managed to do it via this method
https://forum.xda-developers.com/redmi-note-3/themes/mod-updated-6-11-17-google-camera-hdr-t3701190
Yash98 said:
I can't get Magisk Manager to install any module, it says something like /data/magisk not setup....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
"I can flash other zip.. But these two can't be flashed on magisk"
You must create an folder "magiskmanager" on internal sd card...then it works
I will try for Android Nougat. Thank you
It doesn't work on nougat .i tried
Hello, install without problems, but I would like to know which Gcam application exactly should I I must use, Thanks.
anyone got it working ?
jeneb11 said:
anyone got it working ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not working on Redmi Note 4 stock global miui9 with camera2 api enabled. Tried with both magisk, and TWRP, AR Stickers stoped.
how can you install magisk on oreo? when i booted to the twrp, it asks for my pattern and when i draw the pattern, it says pattern failed. so please tell me how can you install magisk on oreo
jigs4wkiller said:
Hmm for me it works
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which magisk version??

Where can i find a version of busybox that will work?

i installed busybox from the playstore and it doesnt seem to want to install. I'm currently on twrp 3.2.1, magisk 15 and magisk manager 15.
equlizer said:
i installed busybox from the playstore and it doesnt seem to want to install. I'm currently on twrp 3.2.1, magisk 15 and magisk manager 15.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Use the Magisk Module Busy Box for Android NDK. Works great.
felosisman said:
Use the Magisk Module Busy Box for Android NDK. Works great.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Where do i find it? thx
EDIT: NVM flashed it in magisk. Is it still normal to get the "theres an internal problem........"?
equlizer said:
Where do i find it? thx
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Open Magisk Manager, go-to Downloads, find and download "BusyBox for Android NDK 1.27.2", reboot and profit.
Noob question but what is BusyBox and what's it's purpose
mackentosh said:
Noob question but what is BusyBox and what's it's purpose
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Busybox allows programs to perform actions on your phone using Linux commands. So some apps require it to run some commands and wont work without it.
equlizer said:
Where do i find it? thx
EDIT: NVM flashed it in magisk. Is it still normal to get the "theres an internal problem........"?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You shouldn't be getting that error anymore if you're using the latest Magisk release. He released version 15.0(1500) a couple days ago, but that was actually fixed in the last beta 14.6.
You would have to reflash your Kernel boot and dtbo and repatch though with the new version. I just used the Magisk Uninstaller script in TWRP, flashed the latest zip of flash Kernel then latest Magisk in TWRP and all good.

Question Magisk bootloop saver?

Anyone use the magisk bootloopsaver module with our phones? Wanted to make sure it wouldn't mess anything up before I installed it lol
Veid71 said:
Anyone use the magisk bootloopsaver module with our phones? Wanted to make sure it wouldn't mess anything up before I installed it lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Using it on OOS11. Saved me when one of the recent Magisk Canary releases had conflicts with modules and caused bootloops, it's a Godsend.
Basically if you bootloop because of modules, the boot animation stays on for like a minute, then the device restarts with all modules disabled (except for the Magisk Bootloop Saver module). You will need to re-enable them manually afterwards (and subsequently rebuild substratum themes etc).
Fishawy said:
Using it on OOS11. Saved me when one of the recent Magisk Canary releases had conflicts with modules and caused bootloops, it's a Godsend.
Basically if you bootloop because of modules, the boot animation stays on for like a minute, then the device restarts with all modules disabled (except for the Magisk Bootloop Saver module). You will need to re-enable them manually afterwards (and subsequently rebuild substratum themes etc).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Awesome thanks man!
Magisk has this by default for a long time now. pressing down vol key on boot will boot into safe mode with all modules disabled
Try this.
JohnFawkes said:
Magisk has this by default for a long time now. pressing down vol key on boot will boot into safe mode with all modules disabled
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
True, but this module makes it a normal boot not into safe mode.
TheKnux said:
Try this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will it work on a12l?
Tazist said:
Will it work on A12l?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
@Tazist Try it. Sorry, the xda app is ****ing stupid.
Does anyone have a fresh copy of this? I keep getting an unzip error. Is development dead?
Droid_Nut said:
Does anyone have a fresh copy of this? I keep getting an unzip error. Is development dead?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why not use magisk delta this have a bootloop protect build in
Thank you, should I patch the boot image or not?
ChrisFeiveel84 said:
Why not use magisk delta this have a bootloop protect build in
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Tell us more, is it a module, or a version of Magisk?
Droid_Nut said:
Thank you, should I patch the boot image or not?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For magsik delta ?
Droid_Nut said:
Tell us more, is it a module, or a version of Magisk?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is a magsik version from huskydg with build in bootloop protect and magisk hide
So its a fork of Magisk. https://magiskzip.com/magisk-delta/
ChrisFeiveel84 said:
For magsik delta ?
Is a magsik version from huskydg with build in bootloop protect and magisk hide
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Huskydg also made the bootloop module, so patch it for either?
Actually never mind I just patched it on 3 phones with no problem.
As far as Delta, the newest Lsposed requires Zygisk, so you might find that you will need that anyways as more modules go that route. Any ways, I will give Delta try some time.
ChrisFeiveel84 said:
For magsik delta ?
Is a magsik version from huskydg with build in bootloop protect and magisk hide
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I installed Delta, can I now turn off the bootloop module?
Droid_Nut said:
I installed Delta, can I now turn off the bootloop module?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No then when you enable it on magsik this isnatlled this modul
Few days ago, magisk brought update. I updated and restarted. 1st restart was ok, but 2nd restart after updating youtube revanved module caused bootloop. I had to flash firmware in, data gone. Will this module really help me if it happens next time or i should use TWRP. TWRP is not available for my device BTW. I will try to build it as it's open source.

Categories

Resources