MIUI 10 Stable vs Beta - Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 Pro Questions & Answers

Hello! What is your experience using MIUI 10 Beta ? How stable is it and are there any critical bugs in it? How do things go with energy consumption? How quickly do bugs fix there?

I want to know that did Xiaomi stopped beta program for miui 10? Or it's just they didn't provide weekly build today?
Because i'm on miui 10 beta and didn't recieve any uodate today. So i thought maybe since they have launched public stable buil so they have stopped beta program. Is it true?

KuldeepShivankar said:
I want to know that did Xiaomi stopped beta program for miui 10? Or it's just they didn't provide weekly build today?
Because i'm on miui 10 beta and didn't recieve any uodate today. So i thought maybe since they have launched public stable buil so they have stopped beta program. Is it true?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is because their devs are on holidays. They do this annually, they made a post about this and the next beta build comes at 11/10.
MIUI Beta and Stable are largely the same for now. Both are good in battery life and performance but I found MIUI 10 a bit stuttering with animations and scrolling compared to MIUI 9.6.4. Also weirdly the graphics options in PUBG has been reduced with MIUI 10. Don't know why.. Switched to MSM-X Pie Rom for now.

kbajey said:
It is because their devs are on holidays. They do this annually, they made a post about this and the next beta build comes at 11/10.
MIUI Beta and Stable are largely the same for now. Both are good in battery life and performance but I found MIUI 10 a bit stuttering with animations and scrolling compared to MIUI 9.6.4. Also weirdly the graphics options in PUBG has been reduced with MIUI 10. Don't know why.. Switched to MSM-X Pie Rom for now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How? What about Anti Roll back? I was in Resurrection remix before Miui 10 but after miui 10 i have to stick with it because of ARB policy. Also miui 10 public build has no finger print lock option. But i'm on beta build so everything seems to be working fine here for now.

KuldeepShivankar said:
How? What about Anti Roll back? I was in Resurrection remix before Miui 10 but after miui 10 i have to stick with it because of ARB policy. Also miui 10 public build has no finger print lock option. But i'm on beta build so everything seems to be working fine here for now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Arb doesn't apply to custom ROMs. You can switch between custom ROMS as usual. Just don't go back to a older version of MIUI. Fingerprint works in stable build for me.

kbajey said:
Arb doesn't apply to custom ROMs. You can switch between custom ROMS as usual. Just don't go back to a older version of MIUI. Fingerprint works in stable build for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh. Thanks. Then i'll definitely try Android Pie based Custom ROMS. But Camera quality becomes worse in Custom ROMS.
What's the point of having a good camera hardware if it's in no use in custom ROMS.

KuldeepShivankar said:
Oh. Thanks. Then i'll definitely try Android Pie based Custom ROMS. But Camera quality becomes worse in Custom ROMS.
What's the point of having a good camera hardware if it's in no use in custom ROMS.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wrong.
Most of the custom roms for whyred come with mi A2 camera pre installed,the you can add gcam onto that.there is no difference between miui and custom camera.because its not the operatint system that defines quality of the picture taken with camera,its the application you are using.
If its a better application or same,there wont be any difference.

reza6d said:
Wrong.
Most of the custom roms for whyred come with mi A2 camera pre installed,the you can add gcam onto that.there is no difference between miui and custom camera.because its not the operatint system that defines quality of the picture taken with camera,its the application you are using.
If its a better application or same,there wont be any difference.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does portrait mode works in custom ROM camera (Mi a2 cam)?

KuldeepShivankar said:
Does portrait mode works in custom ROM camera (Mi a2 cam)?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes my friend.
Both on miA2 cam and gcam.portrait works.

reza6d said:
Yes my friend.
Both on miA2 cam and gcam.portrait works.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Cool. Thanks. ??

reza6d said:
Wrong.
Most of the custom roms for whyred come with mi A2 camera pre installed,the you can add gcam onto that.there is no difference between miui and custom camera.because its not the operatint system that defines quality of the picture taken with camera,its the application you are using.
If its a better application or same,there wont be any difference.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually in my oneplus one and oneplus 5 custom roms doesn't give same camera quality as stock roms. That's why i'm afraid to flash custom rom on redmi note 5 pro. :/

Related

is there a working gcam port for redmi 5a MIUI 10

I was using "GoogleCamera-Pixel2Mod-Arnova8G2-V8.apk" In MIUI 9 and it worked fine after enabling camera2api causing the stock camera app to crash. But in MIUI 10 even after enabling camera2api stock camera is working and gcam is not. I have tried BSG, Arnova8G2 and scrubber gcam ports none of them seem to work.
NaAnBcEhEuL9A8K7 said:
I was using "GoogleCamera-Pixel2Mod-Arnova8G2-V8.apk" In MIUI 9 and it worked fine after enabling camera2api causing the stock camera app to crash. But in MIUI 10 even after enabling camera2api stock camera is working and gcam is not. I have tried BSG, Arnova8G2 and scrubber gcam ports none of them seem to work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From what I have heard GCam is useless on MIUI 10 stable as it does not have Camera2 application programming interface implemented in it, which means adding the line HAL3....... Or using camera2api module by magisk wont enable it. So to use gcam u either have to use Cusrom or go back to miui 9 or just wait till xiaomi implements this API in their further updates.
adityam0338 said:
From what I have heard GCam is useless on MIUI 10 stable as it does not have Camera2 application programming interface implemented in it, which means adding the line HAL3....... Or using camera2api module by magisk wont enable it. So to use gcam u either have to use Cusrom or go back to miui 9 or just wait till xiaomi implements this API in their further updates.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Very sad feeling. I don't think Xiaomi will add it back. If they will add it in the future then why did they remove it in the first place. That's it I'm moving to a custom rom.
NaAnBcEhEuL9A8K7 said:
Very sad feeling. I don't think Xiaomi will add it back. If they will add it in the future then why did they remove it in the first place. That's it I'm moving to a custom rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They may add it. At least it was supposed in beta 8.11.8 but i can't say for sure since beta updates for riva have been suspended since the 8.11.1 update for testing oreo. U can check out this article.
https ://www.gizmochina.com/2018/11/12/miui-10-v8-11-8-beta-rom-opens-doors-for-google-camera-app-support/
U can wait for a few days if u wish. Good luck if ur going custom. Hope i too could do so.
adityam0338 said:
They may add it. At least it was supposed in beta 8.11.8 but i can't say for sure since beta updates for riva have been suspended since the 8.11.1 update for testing oreo. U can check out this article.
https ://www.gizmochina.com/2018/11/12/miui-10-v8-11-8-beta-rom-opens-doors-for-google-camera-app-support/
U can wait for a few days if u wish. Good luck if ur going custom. Hope i too could do so.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for the reply I already downloaded a custom rom but haven't flashed yet. There isn't any custom rom feature packed lile MIUI for redmi 5a. I can wait until the next update.
NaAnBcEhEuL9A8K7 said:
Thank you for the reply I already downloaded a custom rom but haven't flashed yet. There isn't any custom rom feature packed lile MIUI for redmi 5a. I can wait until the next update.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As a matter of fact there is. Have u tried Xiaomi.eu roms? They arey based on MIUI china version but heavily debloated and with a lot of perks.
adityam0338 said:
As a matter of fact there is. Have u tried Xiaomi.eu roms? They arey based on MIUI china version but heavily debloated and with a lot of perks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I haven't heard about Xiaomi.eu till now. Will try soon.
adityam0338 said:
As a matter of fact there is. Have u tried Xiaomi.eu roms? They arey based on MIUI china version but heavily debloated and with a lot of perks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Now I'm using Xiaomi.eu MIUI 10 stable ROM. Still no camera2 api support.
NaAnBcEhEuL9A8K7 said:
Now I'm using Xiaomi.eu MIUI 10 stable ROM. Still no camera2 api support.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry about that. I didn't know about it.
adityam0338 said:
Sorry about that. I didn't know about it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But everything else is much better than MIUI Global ROM.
This is working
http://en.miui.com/thread-4817920-1-1.html
oke thanks will try it
Hi.
oke nice. working perfectfull using serjo GCAM
ovan febriawan said:
oke nice. working perfectfull using serjo GCAM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which ROM are you using?
Good

STABLE GCAM 6.1 - No patch and no root

Hello guys!
I finally found a stable 6.1 gcam for our beloved whyred. My model is Chinese AI red. I am currently using Havoc OS 2.4 (Android 9) without any patch, root or modified kernel. All standard of rom itself.
The apk's author is marlin-ku (https://www.celsoazevedo.com/files/android/google-camera/dev-marlin-ku/)
Notice: You need camera2api enabled!
Recommendations:
Disable 4k video (use full hd)
HDR on the front camera DOES NOT WORK (but if you disable it, everything works)
Download: https://f.celsoazevedo.com/file/cfiles/gcm1/gc_6.1.021_whyred_05dm.apk
Mirror 2: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1qkGyZmehNtkF2wsu48nWXaERU6DYK_CB/view?usp=sharing
Peace :highfive:
My configs
https://ibb.co/album/djOqiv
does it work in stock miui??
Sent from my Redmi Note 5 Pro using Tapatalk
EMONESSboy said:
does it work in stock miui??
Sent from my Redmi Note 5 Pro using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I do not have the MIUI to test, just Havoc OS, but a person who has tested it and said it did not work.
Either way, feel free to test and post your evaluation to us :good:
EMONESSboy said:
does it work in stock miui??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only with MIUI Pie
N1ck474 said:
Only with MIUI Pie
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Forced closed for me, I'm on 9.4.25 Global Beta without any modifications including locked BL.
xell75 said:
Forced closed for me, I'm on 9.4.25 Global Beta without any modifications including locked BL.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You need enabled camera2 API to use any type of GCam
N1ck474 said:
You need enabled camera2 API to use any type of GCam
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay that sucks, then I'm out. I not wanna modify my phone or use any custom Rom so long my phone gets offical updates. But thanks for the info.
xell75 said:
Okay that sucks, then I'm out. I not wanna modify my phone or use any custom Rom so long my phone gets offical updates. But thanks for the info.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're right, Xiaomi should enable camera2api by default, on MIUI Pie it's just a value on build.prop, nothing more nothing less, it's awfull marketing
I have camera2api enabled but get only forced close.
I'm using MASIK 4.1 Miui pie. Front camera work fine for photos and videos. One bug is superzoom in front camera video with 60fps.
But finally we can use one GCAM TRUE Stable.
Thank you
working like a charm with masik 4.1,thanks
habbadda said:
I have camera2api enabled but get only forced close.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What is your ROM? Kernel? Firmware? Do you have root?
Im on LineageOS 16 with Magisk 19.1 and 9.4.18 firmware installed.
habbadda said:
Im on LineageOS 16 with Magisk 19.1 and 9.4.18 firmware installed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Very interesting. I have the latest version of Havoc OS 2.4, on my Chinese note 5 with stable firmware 10.3.4, with absolutely nothing else (root, patch camera, kernel) and this was the most stable version I've ever installed on my whyred. Everything works, minus HDR on the front camera and the 4k video. Everything else works perfectly here.

From global rom to... which rom ?

I've just unlocked by Redmi note 8t (willow) and have to choose which custom rom to install, among the several options.
I'm oriented for an AOSP experience (Havoc, for example) but I'd no want compromises: I need a stable, full features and well supported system.
Does Xiaomi.eu remain the best choice under these last three points ?
TapaSte said:
I've just unlocked by Redmi note 8t (willow) and have to choose which custom rom to install, among the several options.
I'm oriented for an AOSP experience (Havoc, for example) but I'd no want compromises: I need a stable, full features and well supported system.
Does Xiaomi.eu remain the best choice under these last three points ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
All A10 AOSP roms has bugs, like aux camera doesnt work and hardware composer (only 1 rom with hwc fixed, hentai rom by dyneteve).
So current status of aosp development is they are waiting for official miui A10 beta release, for the blobs, which currently still closed beta and hopefully release by this month.
If you dont want compromises, just wait in miui based rom or try aosp 9 roms and if you want aux to work you have to set selinux to permissive.
arshy said:
All A10 AOSP roms has bugs, like aux camera doesnt work and hardware composer (only 1 rom with hwc fixed, hentai rom by dyneteve).
So current status of aosp development is they are waiting for official miui A10 beta release, for the blobs, which currently still closed beta and hopefully release by this month.
If you dont want compromises, just wait in miui based rom or try aosp 9 roms and if you want aux to work you have to set selinux to permissive.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've decided to go with mmx, based on xiaomi.eu
I think it can be a good choice.
To set selinux to permissive how can I proceed, if You know ?
TapaSte said:
I've decided to go with mmx, based on xiaomi.eu
I think it can be a good choice.
To set selinux to permissive how can I proceed, if You know ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you on miui based rom, you dont have to that, aux works just fine, only aosp 9 roms need to be permissive.
Just enter this command in terminal;
su
setenforce 0
arshy said:
If you on miui based rom, you dont have to that, aux works just fine, only aosp 9 roms need to be permissive.
Just enter this command in terminal;
su
setenforce 0
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Via adb ?
rn8t
No other opinions about this topic ?
I'm still stuck on which is best choice among Xiaomi.eu, miui.it and miuimix.
rn8t
I'm using the beta from ROM builder site, and it is definitely a smoother experience, the stock EU that mine came with had quite a few lags.
https://mi-globe.com/miui-firmware-rom-builder/
TapaSte said:
No other opinions about this topic ?
I'm still stuck on which is best choice among Xiaomi.eu, miui.it and miuimix.
rn8t
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using msm Xtended and it perfect for me for my opinion it's the best rom that I tried among other roms
fox_queen said:
I'm using msm Xtended and it perfect for me for my opinion it's the best rom that I tried among other roms
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Srinivas build?
fox_queen said:
I'm using msm Xtended and it perfect for me for my opinion it's the best rom that I tried among other roms
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
aosp based?
which known bugs ?
Sent from my Redmi Note 8T using Tapatalk
Just came to eu for 2 days after unlock the phone, and has no bug to find out until now, using daily or play game (WOT). Maybe there is a little lag while combat many tanks at same place, but overall its smooth.
miui based is good enough, call recording built in, add some gestures, no bloatware except i dont like some miui apps (record, calendar, compass....) and have to replace them with gg one.
I pretended to try Pixel first, but like you, i need stable, dont worry about bugs and update n update n update...
hello.
just asking which rom did you go for, and how is the experience?
arshy said:
All A10 AOSP roms has bugs, like aux camera doesnt work and hardware composer (only 1 rom with hwc fixed, hentai rom by dyneteve).
So current status of aosp development is they are waiting for official miui A10 beta release, for the blobs, which currently still closed beta and hopefully release by this month.
If you dont want compromises, just wait in miui based rom or try aosp 9 roms and if you want aux to work you have to set selinux to permissive.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When xiaomi will release android 10 for ginkgo, the dev will use the display and other blobs from miui and them use them in aosp, which will fix bugs like hwc and camera, so there would be more stable custom rom, am i right?
njckjen said:
Just came to eu for 2 days after unlock the phone, and has no bug to find out until now, using daily or play game (WOT). Maybe there is a little lag while combat many tanks at same place, but overall its smooth.
miui based is good enough, call recording built in, add some gestures, no bloatware except i dont like some miui apps (record, calendar, compass....) and have to replace them with gg one.
I pretended to try Pixel first, but like you, i need stable, dont worry about bugs and update n update n update...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you please te us what ROM you're using and if you've been using it since this post? Looking for a MIUI experience with call recording and stability... Thanks.

Question [CLOSED] Best custom ROM?

Hello guys. I'm looking for best official custom ROM for my POCO F3. I'm planning to use it daily, so I want stable ROM without any BIG bugs. Can you tell me which ROM is best at this moment? (Your opinion). Thank you and sorry for bad English
I'd recommend the recommended. The mother rom (Xiaomi EU). [EU has nothing to do with europe]. It has the latest official Xiaomi rom features. Basically what Xiaomi updates comes directly to you through this rom (with pack of other features)
laid1995 said:
I'd recommend the recommended. The mother rom (Xiaomi EU). [EU has nothing to do with europe]. It has the latest official Xiaomi rom features. Basically what Xiaomi updates comes directly to you through this rom (with pack of other features)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, but I really hate MIUI. I want pure Android (havoc os, pixel experience or something similar)
JUD4SH said:
Yes, but I really hate MIUI. I want pure Android (havoc os, pixel experience or something similar)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, I am a OneUI fanboy. I don't like any of them all. but I'd have to get used to MiUI
The thing is you need to know what suits you the most and feel comfortable with. You can check the ones available here labeled as [Development].
I hope the guys here give you more intels of which could be the beat custom rom besides custom MIUI
Right now, hands down the best rom would be Arrow OS. Been using it for a couple of days now and the smoothness and experience is on next level.
I was previously using stable and then weekly EU rom.
raza_maestro said:
Right now, hands down the best rom would be Arrow OS. Been using it for a couple of days now and the smoothness and experience is on next level.
I was previously using stable and then weekly EU rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What about 120 hz refresh rate? Does it working well? Did you noticed any problems or bugs? (Connection, battery life, random restarts, etc.) Thanks for your reply
JUD4SH said:
What about 120 hz refresh rate? Does it working well? Did you noticed any problems or bugs? (Connection, battery life, random restarts, etc.) Thanks for your reply
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not yet. My phone hasn't arrived yet xD
I am so excited though. Once it arrives. I'm gonna unlock the bootloader. The earlier, the better.
laid1995 said:
Not yet. My phone hasn't arrived yet xD
I am so excited though. Once it arrives. I'm gonna unlock the bootloader. The earlier, the better.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using havoc os on my Xiaomi MI 9 and it's really good, but I don't know how it's working on POCO F3 .
JUD4SH said:
I'm using havoc os on my Xiaomi MI 9 and it's really good, but I don't know how it's working on POCO F3 .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
well. Havoc is available on F3. You should give it a shot and see how it goes. Maybe Youtube it. People give previews there.
JUD4SH said:
but I don't know how it's working on POCO F3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Havoc was the first Custom ROM for the F3, which didn't include GAPPS by default - so I gave it a try...
After many years of pure LOS/CyanogenMod, I am now running Havoc 4.5 on both the Poco F1 and F3. And it works great on both devices!
HentaiOS works fine to me :v I'm staying on it till any custom with working OTA comes up
esszett said:
Havoc was the first Custom ROM for the F3, which didn't include GAPPS by default - so I gave it a try...
After many years of pure LOS/CyanogenMod, I am now running Havoc 4.5 on both the Poco F1 and F3. And it works great on both devices!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok, I'll try havoc or hentaios thank you
reas0n said:
HentaiOS works fine to me :v I'm staying on it till any custom with working OTA comes up
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's banned on XDA. It's also not open source . As a havoc contributor I'm biased to havoc however most of the ROMs use the same device source and so are all stable. I think ArrowOS may be the most stable at the moment but I don't have a problem daily driving Havoc
JUD4SH said:
Ok, I'll try havoc or hentaios thank you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just a warning the HentaiOS dev is a bit rude...
For me PEX
Robert314 said:
Just a warning the HentaiOS dev is a bit rude...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you. I'm gonna try Havoc OS I like it on my old device
reas0n said:
HentaiOS works fine to me :v I'm staying on it till any custom with working OTA comes up
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Link for HentaiOS (Poco F3)?
esszett said:
Havoc was the first Custom ROM for the F3, which didn't include GAPPS by default - so I gave it a try...
After many years of pure LOS/CyanogenMod, I am now running Havoc 4.5 on both the Poco F1 and F3. And it works great on both devices!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just received my F3 and I am on the mandatory 7-day waiting period to unlock.
F1 is my current phone, running Havoc 4.5, and I want to install Havoc on the F3 too.
Did you notice any major bugs on the F3 version?
I know it's still too early for all features to be added, but -for example-, is 120hz refresh rate available as an option?
Thank you.
tsavman said:
is 120hz refresh rate available as an option?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes.
The only bug I faced so far is the adaptive charging: it does not work on official build (it did on unofficial ). But I'm not a 24/7 smartphone user and I don't run games on it.
reas0n said:
HentaiOS works fine to me :v I'm staying on it till any custom with working OTA comes up
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ArrowOS is supporting OTA. I feel it's the most stable and snappiest of the current AOSPs. Light and fast, without a bunch of features I don't really need

Question ArrowOS to miui 14

Just saw the android 13 based miui 14 got released for nabu. How could I flash the MIUI 14 from by current build?
MIFLASH[GUIDE]⚙ USE XIAOMI FLASH TOOL
FOR ALL XIAOMI BOOTLOADER MUST BE UNLOCKED https://new.c.mi.com/global/post/101245 https://en.miui.com/unlock/index.html ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- All your data...
forum.xda-developers.com
Hidden_Iye said:
Just saw the android 13 based miui 14 got released for nabu. How could I flash the MIUI 14 from by current build?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can flash the recovery rom like arrow os flashing method.
Just use miui zip rom
Keyvannn said:
You can flash the recovery rom like arrow os flashing method.
Just use miui zip rom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks!
Btw did you try miui 14? Is it a worthy switch as ArrowOS is working great atm
Hidden_Iye said:
Thanks!
Btw did you try miui 14? Is it a worthy switch as ArrowOS is working great atm
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nothing changed. Settings looks ****tier and Gboard has an arrow below it/raised up. That's about it.
Staying with arrowos, thanks for the feedback.
Good choice. The update to MIUI 14 only adds a few stuff, and most of them are not useful (at least for me). The only good thing about this update is that it asks for notification access on app install, but that's already baked into Android 13 and not MIUI's invention.
There aren't any performance improvements from what I can tell. Games are still in low resolution. Honestly I expected more from this update, MIUI has gone downhill.

Categories

Resources