Hello everyone i wanted your suggestion on whether to buy redmi n5p or not now that it has anti rollback what would u suggest i should buy this device or asus Zenfone max pro m1. Please Help Me.
yes you can buy rn5 as all the phone that available on store now still using miui 9 so you will not be affected.
For development prefer Redmi Note 5 pro over Zenfone Max Pro M1.
SHAWN_FROST said:
Hello everyone i wanted your suggestion on whether to buy redmi n5p or not now that it has anti rollback what would u suggest i should buy this device or asus Zenfone max pro m1. Please Help Me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
With the release of Android Oreo, Google introduced anti-rollback feature as a security measure which ensures that your data is safe when your device is stolen or if any attacker tries to downgrade.
But according to Google's documentation, the anti-rollback feature should be turned-off automatically when the bootloader is unlocked. But when Xiaomi implemented anti-rollback, they made it impossible for the user to disable that even by unlocking bootloader due to which few users ended up with bricked devices.
And this is the violation of Google's documentation. Hopefully they'll push an update soon to tackle this issue and if they don't, our beloved devs will sure find a way
So, if you want development then Redmi Note 5 Pro is your cup of tea go ahead and buy it there's nothing to worry about "anti-rollback" else go for Zenfone Max Pro M1.
Anti roll back is a system which enabled & can be disabled but the rn5p is good device...if you do everything except flashing roms manually nothing bad will happen
I already bought a global version redmi note 5. all works fine. But from aliexpress it arrives in about 26 days.
I need another phone soon. So asked someone to bring one from China directly - redmi note 5.
I am going to flash the global rom by myself. But while searching online, someone said I need the redmi note 5 pro ROM, and there's also redmi note 5 ROM and redmi Note 5 plus ROM. Which one should I choose?
is it possible to flash global ROM by myself? or it will brick the phone?
anyone has the similar experience? from China version Redmi Note 5 to Global version Redmi Note 5.
libralibra said:
I already bought a global version redmi note 5. all works fine. But from aliexpress it arrives in about 26 days.
I need another phone soon. So asked someone to bring one from China directly - redmi note 5.
I am going to flash the global rom by myself. But while searching online, someone said I need the redmi note 5 pro ROM, and there's also redmi note 5 ROM and redmi Note 5 plus ROM. Which one should I choose?
is it possible to flash global ROM by myself? or it will brick the phone?
anyone has the similar experience? from China version Redmi Note 5 to Global version Redmi Note 5.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If it had snapdragon 636 on the chipset, you are on the right forum.
libralibra said:
I already bought a global version redmi note 5. all works fine. But from aliexpress it arrives in about 26 days.
I need another phone soon. So asked someone to bring one from China directly - redmi note 5.
I am going to flash the global rom by myself. But while searching online, someone said I need the redmi note 5 pro ROM, and there's also redmi note 5 ROM and redmi Note 5 plus ROM. Which one should I choose?
is it possible to flash global ROM by myself? or it will brick the phone?
anyone has the similar experience? from China version Redmi Note 5 to Global version Redmi Note 5.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On one hand there is Redmi note 5 Pro and Redmi note 5 AI. They share the codename WHYRED. Both have Snapdragon 636. Also dual camera setup. Most ROMS for whyred means they will work on both these phones.
On the other hand there is Redmi 5 Plus. It has a snapdragon 625 and a single camera. I believe the codename is VINCE for Redmi 5 plus.
new at xiaomi that if your phone is china region you cant install golbal rom. and viceversa global phone cant install china rom. i read it on miui forum. do some research on that before buyinh china region phone .
fadgry said:
If it had snapdragon 636 on the chipset, you are on the right forum.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I'm sure it's sd636.
raptorddd said:
new at xiaomi that if your phone is china region you cant install golbal rom. and viceversa global phone cant install china rom. i read it on miui forum. do some research on that before buyinh china region phone .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry I had China version and can install global miui freely
XsConfused said:
On one hand there is Redmi note 5 Pro and Redmi note 5 AI. They share the codename WHYRED. Both have Snapdragon 636. Also dual camera setup. Most ROMS for whyred means they will work on both these phones.
On the other hand there is Redmi 5 Plus. It has a snapdragon 625 and a single camera. I believe the codename is VINCE for Redmi 5 plus.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It looks like this should be redmi note 5 AI, that's how xiaomi advertises it in China. The current one global version I got from aliexpress has dual camera as well. But hardly to say it's AI or not.
Thanks for your reply. I'll download some whyred ROM to give it a go. Really scared to brick it as there is no way to unbrick but visit xiaomi service center, which has none locally here.
fadgry said:
Sorry I had China version and can install global miui freely
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Really thanks for your reply. I'm going to jump on the same boat as you now. From my research, I need:
1 unlocked BL using one xiaomi account old enough (than 360 hours)
2 download global ROM from some where.
3 flash in fastboot.
Any advice on that? Is it difficult to flash? Anything I missed? Do I need turn any other options in develop mode like USB debug or anything similar?
raptorddd said:
new at xiaomi that if your phone is china region you cant install golbal rom. and viceversa global phone cant install china rom. i read it on miui forum. do some research on that before buyinh china region phone .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If it's true I would be very sad since I cannot return it anyway.
libralibra said:
Really thanks for your reply. I'm going to jump on the same boat as you now. From my research, I need:
1 unlocked BL using one xiaomi account old enough (than 360 hours)
2 download global ROM from some where.
3 flash in fastboot.
Any advice on that? Is it difficult to flash? Anything I missed? Do I need turn any other options in develop mode like USB debug or anything similar?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you plan to unlock UBL first you can flash the recovery rom via updater instead flashing via fastboot. It is more convenient if you rarely touch the pc
redmi note 5 is VINCE
redmi note 5 pro is WHYRED
so any miui rom having name mentioned VINCE is NOT for you!
fadgry said:
If you plan to unlock UBL first you can flash the recovery rom via updater instead flashing via fastboot. It is more convenient if you rarely touch the pc
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks. but i'm not sure what you are talking about. what's the recovery rom? how can i flash it via updater?
do i need to unlock BL first before flash it?
libralibra said:
thanks. but i'm not sure what you are talking about. what's the recovery rom? how can i flash it via updater?
do i need to unlock BL first before flash it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes you need UBL before flashing recovery rom via updater. You will find 2 version of MIUI on their website, fastboot and recovery version
libralibra said:
thanks. but i'm not sure what you are talking about. what's the recovery rom? how can i flash it via updater?
do i need to unlock BL first before flash it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Normally when you are on Official stable or developer MIUI ROM, you can just download the recovery file of any other Official MIUI rom and use the updater app(just select the update package and it will start installing). It works a lot of the times. So you dont really need unlocked bootloader if this method works. Please note that it works on official MIUI roms only.
In case it doesn't work you need to unlock the bootloader. Then you have two options. Either you can use TWRP recovery to flash recovery file ROMS(usually a .zip file). Or you can use fastboot roms for which you need a pc(with miflash tool).
One ANNOYING thing about bootloader unlocking. You have to add the Mi account to your phone manually(in developer options). After that there is a cooldown of 72,360 or 720 hours depending on your phone model. Mostly its 720 hours now. After the cooldown you can unlock your bootloader.
XsConfused said:
On one hand there is Redmi note 5 Pro and Redmi note 5 AI. They share the codename WHYRED. Both have Snapdragon 636. Also dual camera setup. Most ROMS for whyred means they will work on both these phones.
On the other hand there is Redmi 5 Plus. It has a snapdragon 625 and a single camera. I believe the codename is VINCE for Redmi 5 plus.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
exactly, it's really not hard at all
SALVO9 said:
exactly, it's really not hard at all
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In some places the Redmi 5 plus is known as simply the Redmi Note 5. It causes a lot of confusion.
XsConfused said:
Normally when you are on Official stable or developer MIUI ROM, you can just download the recovery file of any other Official MIUI rom and use the updater app(just select the update package and it will start installing). It works a lot of the times. So you dont really need unlocked bootloader if this method works. Please note that it works on official MIUI roms only.
In case it doesn't work you need to unlock the bootloader. Then you have two options. Either you can use TWRP recovery to flash recovery file ROMS(usually a .zip file). Or you can use fastboot roms for which you need a pc(with miflash tool).
One ANNOYING thing about bootloader unlocking. You have to add the Mi account to your phone manually(in developer options). After that there is a cooldown of 72,360 or 720 hours depending on your phone model. Mostly its 720 hours now. After the cooldown you can unlock your bootloader.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for your clarification. I got one zip file from miui global forum download page. It looks like to be the recovery file you mentioned. Thank God I knew this from you since I thought it was the full fastboot flashable ROM. Who knows what will happen if I flash it via fastboot.
Another one from this forum is a tgz, unzip to tar. It might be the proper fastboot file but a version before anti rollback. I need to get the new phone in hand to check if I can flash it nor not.
I got my mi account e months ago. Should be OK to flash without waiting 720h. Hope so at least.
libralibra said:
Thanks for your clarification. I got one zip file from miui global forum download page. It looks like to be the recovery file you mentioned. Thank God I knew this from you since I thought it was the full fastboot flashable ROM. Who knows what will happen if I flash it via fastboot.
Another one from this forum is a tgz, unzip to tar. It might be the proper fastboot file but a version before anti rollback. I need to get the new phone in hand to check if I can flash it nor not.
I got my mi account e months ago. Should be OK to flash without waiting 720h. Hope so at least.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You need Unlocked bootloader to flash fastboot ROM. MiFlash will throw error message saying this cannot be flashed in locked bootloader.
One advantage of MiFlash is, software checks bootloader index and if you try to flash older version arb3 ROM(without antirollback) then software throws error message, unable to flash because bootloader index(anti3) is lesser than the present bootloader index(anti4)
Most of the people bricked their device while flashing older version of MIUI ROM in TWRP because twrp recovery will not check bootloader index value
Downloaded recovery ROM name starts with HMNote5ProGlobal
and downloaded fastboot ROM name starts with WHYRED these ROMs are for Redmi note 5 Pro (Indian version) and Redmi Note 5 (Global)
In India we have Redmi note 5 (Redmi 5 plus global) codenamed Vince
libralibra said:
I got my mi account e months ago. Should be OK to flash without waiting 720h. Hope so at least.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unfortunately, that wont work. My mi account is really old(3 years, unlocked bootloader of note 3 and 3 pro). Still I had to wait for 360h after adding mi account to my new Note 5 AI. And there is a new rule afaik and the waiting period is 720 hours now. Which translates to about a month. It is really frustrating, I know.
One more thing, "adding mi account" is not just logging in your mi account of your phone. You have to add the account in developer options.
XsConfused said:
Unfortunately, that wont work. My mi account is really old(3 years, unlocked bootloader of note 3 and 3 pro). Still I had to wait for 360h after adding mi account to my new Note 5 AI. And there is a new rule afaik and the waiting period is 720 hours now. Which translates to about a month. It is really frustrating, I know.
One more thing, "adding mi account" is not just logging in your mi account of your phone. You have to add the account in developer options.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ah.... That's the worst info. 720h is too....Too long. Dam xiaomi.
Do you have the link of ROM you flashed to China redmi note 5 AI? I need to make sure flash the right one.
Im about to unlock bootloader soon and i wanna know if this section is right for me cuz im kinda confused. I have redmi note 5 ai global (sd 636), if i would want to install custom rom it have to be for whyred or its something else too? It matters if i get this from here (rn5 pro) or normal redmi note 5 section ?
Yes, you need the whyred version..
only cpu is different？
wsdyleon said:
only cpu is different？
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Compare Xiaomi Redmi Note 8 vs. Xiaomi Redmi Note 8 2021 - GSMArena.com
www.gsmarena.com
if you like modding buy ginko. if u like miui and buy note 8 2021 ( but only mod you can do is rooting)
wetito said:
if you like modding buy ginko. if u like miui and buy note 8 2021 ( but only mod you can do is rooting)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hi, i'm new in this forum. is that because the device is new and there's not a lot of support for other roms right now? or is there a problem with biloba that makes it bad for modding
Good question!
I am used to Xiaomi devices having a huge modding base, so I got the Note 8 (2021)...
I unlocked bootloader, thinking it was a willow, and just realized I have a biloba...
Any custom rom in sight?
So far I only rooted my biloba. Probably you could try GSI Roms on it, but I haven't tried yet.
do you think i should download miui 14 mod on my phone crdroidmi my phone redmi note 8 pro
i think you should try and download every rom you are interested in and use it for a week. then make your decision. what do you expect from us ? what do you expect from a custom rom ? it wont turn your phone in an iphone 14 pro max. its still a weak smartphone