Develop Bugs

trying to flash twrp; it just hangs!

Hi all,
*I've unlocked bootloader
* Have tried fastboot boot TWRP.img, as well as tried flashing TWRP RC1 via the Skipsoft toolkit.
Every way I've tried the phone just sits at the TWRP boot screen and doesn't allow me to go any further..
Any help here would be truly appreciated!
Cheers,

I've been having the same issue tonight. Re-flash the stock image, go through the whole setup process and make sure you add a lockscreen pin, then flash TWRP. That is what worked for me. I still can't flash a Rom though for some reason. It's driving me insane.

dutchy716 said:
I've been having the same issue tonight. Re-flash the stock image, go through the whole setup process and make sure you add a lockscreen pin, then flash TWRP. That is what worked for me. I still can't flash a Rom though for some reason. It's driving me insane.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're braver than me. I haven't had my Pixel XL long but this is the first phone I've ever owned where I am afraid to try and install a custom recovery and ROM. With the dual partitions and what I hear about TWRP still being buggy it just seems like Google didn't want people to run anything but pure Android on the Pixels.

dutchy716 said:
I've been having the same issue tonight. Re-flash the stock image, go through the whole setup process and make sure you add a lockscreen pin, then flash TWRP. That is what worked for me. I still can't flash a Rom though for some reason. It's driving me insane.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same issue here, but no solution. Adding a lockscreen pin didn't change anything for me. I just get a teamwin image but it just sits there & doesn't actually open TWRP. My bootlocker is unlocked but thats as far as I can get 7.1.2 with May security. I have tried reloading everything and followed commonly recommended steps.
Any suggestions greatly appreciated. I would love to get this thing rooted and get some ROM flexibility - even to just get rid of the Nav Bar ....

mikefnz said:
Same issue here, but no solution. Adding a lockscreen pin didn't change anything for me. I just get a teamwin image but it just sits there & doesn't actually open TWRP. My bootlocker is unlocked but thats as far as I can get 7.1.2 with May security. I have tried reloading everything and followed commonly recommended steps.
Any suggestions greatly appreciated. I would love to get this thing rooted and get some ROM flexibility - even to just get rid of the Nav Bar ....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have never had a problem. Make sure your using the rc1 fast boot TWRP. Should be fastboot boot twrp.img. I change file name to this or copy and paste. Then you install rc1 or rc2 zip.
I know you will have problems if you try to install the wrong file.

mac796 said:
I have never had a problem. Make sure your using the rc1 fast boot TWRP. Should be fastboot boot twrp.img. I change file name to this or copy and paste. Then you install rc1 or rc2 zip.
I know you will have problems if you try to install the wrong file.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am doing exactly as you mentioned.. flash rc1.img, however the phone does not go beyond the boot screen, it just sits there.... Can I ask what steps you are taking prior to flashing twrp? Thanks!

mazubo said:
I am doing exactly as you mentioned.. flash rc1.img, however the phone does not go beyond the boot screen, it just sits there.... Can I ask what steps you are taking prior to flashing twrp? Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmm are you on may bootloader because i think modifying the boot partition causes bootloop without the boot signature?

XtraArrow said:
Hmm are you on may bootloader because i think modifying the boot partition causes bootloop without the boot signature?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes I am.. should I downgrade to 7.1.1? Tjere was no mention of that issue in the skipsoft toolkit thread... Weird!

mazubo said:
Yes I am.. should I downgrade to 7.1.1? Tjere was no mention of that issue in the skipsoft toolkit thread... Weird!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sure, i guess.. or you could just manually flash the April bootloader. a lot easier.

XtraArrow said:
Sure, i guess.. or you could just manually flash the April bootloader. a lot easier.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok, would flashing just the bootloader wipe the phone? Also how would I find just the bootloader? Thanks for the suggestion, I haven't flashed just a bootloader before..

mazubo said:
I am doing exactly as you mentioned.. flash rc1.img, however the phone does not go beyond the boot screen, it just sits there.... Can I ask what steps you are taking prior to flashing twrp? Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That strange. I just flash a factory image from Google
Set up a security pattern
Enable adb debugging
Fastboot boot twrp 3.0.2-0 rc1 IMG
Make sure it asks for your security pattern if it doesn't reboot to bootloader and fastboot twrp again, and keep repeating until it does
Install twrp 3.1.0.0 rc2 or rc1 zip
If your using may bootloader's fish VBS 6 zip
And it should stick, if you flash. Anything else that messes with boot flash that VBS zip at the end again

mazubo said:
Ok, would flashing just the bootloader wipe the phone? Also how would I find just the bootloader? Thanks for the suggestion, I haven't flashed just a bootloader before..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you download the offiial april firmware, you can manually extract it from the .zip then you would do this command in fastboot :--------- fastboot flash bootloader PUTFILEHERE.img
EDIT: Are you able to get into TWRP by any chance??

mac796 said:
That strange. I just flash a factory image from Google
Set up a security pattern
Enable adb debugging
Fastboot boot twrp 3.0.2-0 rc1 IMG
Make sure it asks for your security pattern if it doesn't reboot to bootloader and fastboot twrp again, and keep repeating until it does
Install twrp 3.1.0.0 rc2 or rc1
If your using may bootloader's fish VBS 6 zip
And it should stick, if you flash. Anything else that messes with boot flash that VBS zip at the end again
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmm, maybe this is where I've gone wrong.. I thought the need to create a security pin/pattern was only if coming from a previously rooted state, or from a custom ROM. I will try this as well and report back.. thanks!

XtraArrow said:
If you download the offiial april firmware, you can manually extract it from the .zip then you would do this command in fastboot :--------- fastboot flash bootloader PUTFILEHERE.img
EDIT: Are you able to get into TWRP by any chance??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unable to get into twrp as previously mentioned. I flash the IMG file, then it just hangs on the TWRP boot screen..

mazubo said:
Unable to get into twrp as previously mentioned. I flash the IMG file, then it just hangs on the TWRP boot screen..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Alright, try doing what I mentioned. Download April firmware, extract the bootloader.img from it and flash using command above.

XtraArrow said:
Alright, try doing what I mentioned. Download April firmware, extract the bootloader.img from it and flash using command above.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This seems likely to work. Thanks for the suggestions, and I'll report back! Cheers!

mazubo said:
This seems likely to work. Thanks for the suggestions, and I'll report back! Cheers!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm no expert but it's seems like a decent suggestion. Let us know how it goes.

@mazubo
You keep stating that you just flash the image. Are you flashing it from the bootloader then trying to boot to recovery?
You have to boot TWRP from your PC first. Then from TWRP you can then "flash" TWRP.
Just wanted to make sure that was a step you were taking!

Just wait. It will take little longer
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk

freddy0872 said:
@mazubo
You keep stating that you just flash the image. Are you flashing it from the bootloader then trying to boot to recovery?
You have to boot TWRP from your PC first. Then from TWRP you can then "flash" TWRP.
Just wanted to make sure that was a step you were taking!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, I have tried fastboot to flash the TWRP img, as well as skipsofts toolkit. I guess I've been using the term "flash" for fastboot, as I haven't been able to use twrp yet.. I understand that you need to flash the TWRP img via pc and then flash the TWRP zip, then SuperSU or magisk, whatever your poison may be !

[Q] Can't access to TWRP Recovery

Hi guys, sorry if posting another thread about this problem, but I haven't found anything useful for my case. The problem is I can't boot in recovery. I flash the TWRP img (latest version but I also tried with others) and the process goes without problems, then I DON'T reboot the system or even power off the phone, I directly send the command via command line (adb-fastboot) or via phone to go to the recovery. It seems to work at first look, but before the recovery starts the phone reboot and goes in OS. Now, could the problem be related to the BLOD bug of this devices? I applied the 4core fix for my OS version (January security patch) but I also seen that on the XDA thread they uploaded the 4core version recovery img so maybe the problem is due to this bug which prevent me from enter in the recovery, probably I'm just saying a bunch of stupid things.
Last information: the only way I managed to enter in TWRP recovery was by doing this on fastboot:
fastboot flash recovery recovery.img
fastboot boot recovery.img
But now even this method won't work.
Thanks in advance.

RegularSam said:
Hi guys, sorry if posting another thread about this problem, but I haven't found anything useful for my case. The problem is I can't boot in recovery. I flash the TWRP img (latest version but I also tried with others) and the process goes without problems, then I DON'T reboot the system or even power off the phone, I directly send the command via command line (adb-fastboot) or via phone to go to the recovery. It seems to work at first look, but before the recovery starts the phone reboot and goes in OS. Now, could the problem be related to the BLOD bug of this devices? I applied the 4core fix for my OS version (January security patch) but I also seen that on the XDA thread they uploaded the 4core version recovery img so maybe the problem is due to this bug which prevent me from enter in the recovery, probably I'm just saying a bunch of stupid things.
Last information: the only way I managed to enter in TWRP recovery was by doing this on fastboot:
fastboot flash recovery recovery.img
fastboot boot recovery.img
But now even this method won't work.
Thanks in advance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What happens if you try to look your bootloader, fastboot oem lock, and then boot back into the bootloader. Is it locked? Or does it stay unlocked?
Sent from my [device_name] using XDA-Developers Legacy app

jd1639 said:
What happens if you try to look your bootloader, fastboot oem lock, and then boot back into the bootloader. Is it locked? Or does it stay unlocked?
Sent from my [device_name] using XDA-Developers Legacy app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmm, wait, maybe I didn't catch what you were sayin, with "try to look your bootloader" you meant "try to LOCK your bootloader" right?
Because yesterday I've made root with Magisk, if I try to lock the bootloader I risk to brick the phone, isn't it true? Thanks anyway for your reply.

jd1639 said:
What happens if you try to look your bootloader, fastboot oem lock, and then boot back into the bootloader. Is it locked? Or does it stay unlocked?
Sent from my [device_name] using XDA-Developers Legacy app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I found the trick. I applied from fastboot the two commands that I mentioned:
fastboot flash recovery recovery.img
fastboot boot recovery.img
Only difference? I didn't run the Command Prompt as administartor, as I did yesterday (I also tried before this operations using PowerShell without success), WOW. Now before reboot the phone I allowed the modification to the partition in TWRP recovery, I saved logs from kernel and recovery and I'm trying to make a backup. I will tell you the results.
Yesterday I've also tried to flash the recovery by using Flashify without success, just sayin.
EDIT:
After rebooting the stock recovery returned. I hate this thing. I've also renamed this two files:
recovery-from-boot-p
install-recovery.sh
It didn't work.

jd1639 said:
What happens if you try to look your bootloader, fastboot oem lock, and then boot back into the bootloader. Is it locked? Or does it stay unlocked?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any thoughts? Sorry if I ask but this problem is stopping me from go further with modifications on my device, I would like to install the ElementalX kernel.

RegularSam said:
Any thoughts? Sorry if I ask but this problem is stopping me from go further with modifications on my device, I would like to install the ElementalX kernel.[/QUOTE
From the bootloader boot recovery (twrp), fastboot boot twrp.img. Then flash supersu in twrp. Then boot back into the bootloader and flash twrp, fastboot flash recovery twrp.img. Twrp should stick then. Note: twrp.img is the full name of the twrp image file you're using.
Sent from my [device_name] using XDA-Developers Legacy app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

Or, as you are already rooted, you could just try flashing TWRP from the official TWRP app. That should make it stick.
EDIT: Just noticed that you've already tried with Flashify. You could still try with the official app but if that doesn't work, do what jd1639 said.

CazeW said:
Or, as you are already rooted, you could just try flashing TWRP from the official TWRP app. That should make it stick.
EDIT: Just noticed that you've already tried with Flashify. You could still try with the official app but if that doesn't work, do what jd1639 said.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've already tried with the official app and unfortunately I had no success. Anyway, as I said before, by locking again the bootloader couldn't occur a bootloop due to the root?

RegularSam said:
I've already tried with the official app and unfortunately I had no success. Anyway, as I said before, by locking again the bootloader couldn't occur a bootloop due to the root?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Locking the bootloader will not cause a boot loop if you're rooted. The reason I asked what happens when you lock the bootloader is that the 5x had had issues with the emmc going bad. A sure sign of that is the bootloader not staying locked after locking it and booting back up.
Sent from my [device_name] using XDA-Developers Legacy app

jd1639 said:
RegularSam said:
Any thoughts? Sorry if I ask but this problem is stopping me from go further with modifications on my device, I would like to install the ElementalX kernel.[/QUOTE
From the bootloader boot recovery (twrp), fastboot boot twrp.img. Then flash supersu in twrp. Then boot back into the bootloader and flash twrp, fastboot flash recovery twrp.img. Twrp should stick then. Note: twrp.img is the full name of the twrp image file you're using.
Sent from my [device_name] using XDA-Developers Legacy app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Seriously, this thing is driving me crazy. Tried to go with your suggestions but I can't boot in the recovery, no way. I have also flashed the original recovery and the tried to get in with fastboot boot twrp.img, no success. I can't figure out why I have this problem.
EDIT: great, now even flashing the stock recovery doesn't work, the phone reboot every time I try to get in any recovery. I have no words.
EDIT 2:
GUYS, I think I've found the solution. As I said in the main post, I was thinking that maybe the problem was due to the BLOD bug, in fact the common twrp.img that you can find on the twrp page uses all the 6 cores of the Nexus 5X causing the rebooting which I mentioned. Now, I found this version of twrp 3.1.1 which is modified to use 4Cores, thanks to the user XCnathan32 and his thread about BLOD bug: https://forum.xda-developers.com/nexus-5x/general/untested-nexus-5x-bootloop-death-fix-t3641199.
Now it seems like the TWRP Recovery is stick to the phone and I'm really happy to say that. Thanks for all your support, you were very patient!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

Sprint Root questions and clarification

Hello XDA, I am trying to figure out all the steps to get mainly Twrp, Magisk, Viper and, Substratum working correctly without any hiccups. I have been reading the forums all day and trying to get all the files necessary to get all that working and the files to revert to stock if it doesn't work. I know after the Bootloader is unlocked I won't be able to relock it due to no Moto signed boot images. I just don't want to brick it and be here with other problems later.
So far I have done the following
1. Installed ADB and Fastboot + Drivers
2. Done everything to get the code to unlock bootloader
3. Downloaded the files to flash twrp from (https://forum.xda-developers.com/z2-force/development/twrp-3-1-1-0-moto-z2-force-nash-t3687421)
4. Downloaded the latest stock NCX26.122-59-8 to extract the boot img and patch it with Magisk manager from (https://forum.xda-developers.com/z2-force/how-to/to-stock-roms-t3672859)
I think I have everything I need to get it rooted. Here's where I get kinda confused. My phone (XT1789-03 Sprint) is on NCXS26.122-59-8-11 November patch (I think the S is for sprint lol). Would It be okay to flash the Magisk patched boot img from the one I downloaded after I unlock the bootloader? Is Twrp necessary? Is there anything else I need to know about? Thanks in advance.

This forum just died? What the hell noone helps anymore???
Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk

TWRP is official now. Download the bootable image from https://twrp.me/motorola/motorolamotoz2force.html and the corresponding zip. Boot to twrp and flash the zip. Flash Magisk and install what you want that needs root. Hint: I'd advise the Viper4Android from Magisk modules in the magisk app.

Uzephi said:
Boot to twrp and flash the zip.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you mean by this? Fastboot flash TWRP, but then flash what zip?

breakerfall said:
What do you mean by this? Fastboot flash TWRP, but then flash what zip?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do NOT flash the twrp img. "Fastboot boot imagename.img" then flash the twrp zip if you wish to have it as your recovery. You can find both on twrp.me.

This hard.. even with instructions u don't know what to flash where and what it will achieve lol. I just want unlock and root. What's the easiest way to do that on sprint z2 force?
So far I understand u need to install twrp to root with magisk, then use twrp to flash magisk Img, then boot up install magisk apk and u should be rooted. Hope I've got that all right.
But do any of the images on this site also unlock gsm on sprint or TMobile?
Sent from my Moto Z (2) using Tapatalk

Uzephi said:
Do NOT flash the twrp img. "Fastboot boot imagename.img" then flash the twrp zip if you wish to have it as your recovery. You can find both on twrp.me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not trying to be a **** here, but what exactly do you mean by imagename.img? .. the twrp.img file? and if I don't want TWRP as recovery, then are you saying that it will remain stock if I don't flash the twrp.zip file?
I recently did this on an Essential phone, and the process was: fastboot flash TWRP.img, reboot to TWRP (recovery), flash stock boot.img, then flash magisk.zip.
The last phone I rooted/rommed before that was a Nexus 6, and **** was different then.

breakerfall said:
Not trying to be a **** here, but what exactly do you mean by imagename.img? .. the twrp.img file? and if I don't want TWRP as recovery, then are you saying that it will remain stock if I don't flash the twrp.zip file?
I recently did this on an Essential phone, and the process was: fastboot flash TWRP.img, reboot to TWRP (recovery), flash stock boot.img, then flash magisk.zip.
The last phone I rooted/rommed before that was a Nexus 6, and **** was different then.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, just boot it. If you flash, your phone will boot to recovery. Don't flash the TWRP image!!
---------- Post added at 07:25 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:24 PM ----------
jmagi said:
So far I understand u need to install twrp to root with magisk, then use twrp to flash magisk Img, then boot up install magisk apk and u should be rooted. Hope I've got that all right.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You don't flash the TWRP.img file!!! You fastboot boot it. It will temp boot to twrp

Uzephi said:
Yes, just boot it. If you flash, your phone will boot to recovery. Don't flash the TWRP image!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ahhhh!
Fastboot boot TWRP.img, then just flash the magisk.zip in TWRP, right?
Thank you!
Also, @jmagi -- you shouldn't have to manually install the magisk apk. Flashing the magisk.zip in TWRP should result in a Magisk app in your "all apps" next time you boot.

Uzephi said:
Yes, just boot it. If you flash, your phone will boot to recovery. Don't flash the TWRP image!!
---------- Post added at 07:25 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:24 PM ----------
You don't flash the TWRP.img file!!! You fastboot boot it. It will temp boot to twrp
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ohhh thats how it works. So i dont have to install twrp from playstore?
Sent from my Moto Z (2) using Tapatalk

jmagi said:
Ohhh thats how it works. So i dont have to install twrp from playstore?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, you don't

Uzephi said:
No, you don't
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok got it thank you. So fastboot boot twrp, and from twrp flash magisk.img then run magisk after bootup.
I too havent rooted a phone since droid4 which was just doubleclick a bat file lol. All this twrp stuff is new to me. Hope i got it right. Love this phone. Might get another one soon and the qwerty keyboard mod is expected on amazon within a couple months. Only reason i upgraded.
Sent from my Moto Z (2) using Tapatalk

jmagi said:
Ok got it thank you. So fastboot boot twrp, and from twrp flash magisk.img then run magisk after bootup.
I too havent rooted a phone since droid4 which was just doubleclick a bat file lol. All this twrp stuff is new to me. Hope i got it right. Love this phone. Might get another one soon and the qwerty keyboard mod is expected on amazon within a couple months. Only reason i upgraded.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Some people had issues and needed to wipe user data after flashing magisk

Messed up with TWRP

Hi all, got TWRP installed OK on my Pixel 2 XL, hit reboot and then it goes straight back into TWRP, but with no Touch. So, thought I could flash a new kernel (Flash?) but... no ADB! I guess the phone hasn't probably booted so ADB can't see the phone.
Any options at this point?!

rendez2k said:
Hi all, got TWRP installed OK on my Pixel 2 XL, hit reboot and then it goes straight back into TWRP, but with no Touch. So, thought I could flash a new kernel (Flash?) but... no ADB! I guess the phone hasn't probably booted so ADB can't see the phone.
Any options at this point?!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If your phone boots back to bootloader on reboot, you did something wrong. Reflash system imgs and start over.

Thanks! Is that a matter of following the guides on the official google download page and getting the factory images?

rendez2k said:
Thanks! Is that a matter of following the guides on the official google download page and getting the factory images?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. If you don't want your data wiped, open the install.bat file and take off the -w.
Did you unlock your bootloader correctly? Unlock critical? I believe the pixel 2 xl is the only phone where that has to be done.

Boot into bootloader and fastboot flash recovery.img again, once your in recovery, flash the recovery.zip from your storage again, then reboot recovery.... its happened to me, usually when I switch slots, all I have to do is reflash recovery.
Also note, If I am trying to boot at that point (rather than flash a ROM), I usually just flash the kernel and magisk and I'm good to go.

Thanks all! I flashed the patched boot.img again and it seems to be working OK

OK, this whole thing is confusing me now! I get TWRP installed then I have to re-flash my boot.img before I quit TWRP (a magisk patched version of Flash) or the phone keeps booting to TWRP. Thats fine, but when I've flashed the boot.img I loose TWRP!

rendez2k said:
OK, this whole thing is confusing me now! I get TWRP installed then I have to re-flash my boot.img before I quit TWRP (a magisk patched version of Flash) or the phone keeps booting to TWRP. Thats fine, but when I've flashed the boot.img I loose TWRP!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes you do loose twrp after flashing the boot.img. the reason being that stock recovery resides in the boot.img. So when you flash it, bye..bye twrp! Why not just fastboot twrp, then once in twrp, flash the twrp installer zip, then flash your custom kernel(if used) then flash the magisk zip for root. :good:

Ok! So this is where I'm confused. The Flash Kernel is called boot.img? So I'm flashing it in twrp with the boot option?

rendez2k said:
Ok! So this is where I'm confused. The Flash Kernel is called boot.img? So I'm flashing it in twrp with the boot option?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No. Flash kernel is just the kernel, the boot.img is from the factory image. Flash the zip version of Flash kernel in twrp, then flash magisk.zip :good:

Ok. So here a shot of my confusion! The file I got from Flash is this one, flashkernel-taimen.v.2.30-boot.img. The three choices I'm being given by TWRP is boot, system or vendor?

rendez2k said:
Ok. So here a shot of my confusion! The file I got from Flash is this one, flashkernel-taimen.v.2.30-boot.img. The three choices I'm being given by TWRP is boot, system or vendor?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Download the 14mb FlashKernel-Taimen-v2.30.zip instead and put it in your phone to flash from within TWRP, followed by the magisk zip
http://nchancellor.net/downloads/kernels/taimen/8.1.0/stable/

rendez2k said:
Ok. So here a shot of my confusion! The file I got from Flash is this one, flashkernel-taimen.v.2.30-boot.img. The three choices I'm being given by TWRP is boot, system or vendor?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
DON'T DO THAT! You'll bootloop for sure!! Do what the post below says, and what I told you earlier!
Pyr0x64 said:
Download the 14mb FlashKernel-Taimen-v2.30.zip instead and put it in your phone to flash from within TWRP, followed by the magisk zip
http://nchancellor.net/downloads/kernels/taimen/8.1.0/stable/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

Thanks all! All sorted! Now, to Xposed or not to Xposed. That's the question. Seems to be tripping safetynet but that's another quandary

rendez2k said:
Thanks all! All sorted! Now, to Xposed or not to Xposed. That's the question. Seems to be tripping safetynet but that's another quandary
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There is no solution for that. Xposed always fails SafetyNet.

Is Xposed worth having these days? Are people still actively developing useful mods?

rendez2k said:
Is Xposed worth having these days? Are people still actively developing useful mods?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think it's worth it, for the following apps:

I've had so many problems with TWRP on this phone that I don't even flash it anymore. If I need to flash a zip file I just fastboot into TWRP and flash it that way. Kind of a pain in the ass but I don't flash many zip files anyway.

Fuse8499 said:
I've had so many problems with TWRP on this phone that I don't even flash it anymore. If I need to flash a zip file I just fastboot into TWRP and flash it that way. Kind of a pain in the ass but I don't flash many zip files anyway.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No problems with TWRP here. Maybe you are flashing to the wrong slot.

rendez2k said:
Is Xposed worth having these days? Are people still actively developing useful mods?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I keep hoping Xposed will go die in a fire. It causes more problems than it solves, to the point ROM developers will tell you not to bother reporting issues with it installed. Rovo knows his stuff, but his creation has caused more damage to custom ROM development than Cyanogenmod did in its last three years.

December update breaks magisk?

Hi all,
I've updated my 3xl to the december update like usual, flash-all.bat without -w. Afterwards, it boots fine, and in settings it clearly states that I'm running the December security patch.
However, when I boot into twrp (not installed) and flash magisk, android boots to just before asking my SIM PIN, says "Shutting Down", then reboots and gives me the message "Can't load Android System. Your data may be corrupt." etc. inside stock recovery.
Did the December update somehow break magisk? Anyone gotten it to work? I'd rather not do a factory reset if it's not needed.

Works fine for me.

Try re-flashing the December update with the - w deleted see if it boots up. Then try flashing magdisk manually on bkth a and b partitions

Working fine for me as well.

I would try flashing the stock boot and system images to both slots. It probably won't work but worth a try before doing a factory reset.
Sent from my [device_name] using XDA-Developers Legacy app

You have a corrupt backup copy of boot.img, Magisk grabbed that and used it for root.
Flash the stock boot.img to both slots and reroot.

mikepopo99 said:
Try re-flashing the December update with the - w deleted see if it boots up. Then try flashing magdisk manually on bkth a and b partitions
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
jd1639 said:
I would try flashing the stock boot and system images to both slots. It probably won't work but worth a try before doing a factory reset.
Sent from my [device_name] using XDA-Developers Legacy app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
TonikJDK said:
You have a corrupt backup copy of boot.img, Magisk grabbed that and used it for root.
Flash the stock boot.img to both slots and reroot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
First off, thanks for trying to help!
Flashing the stock boot.img "solves" the problem, I can boot and use the phone like normal, but without root obviously. Using the stock boot.img inside magisk manager to patch it with 17.3 and flashing that boot image to both partitions gives me this error again. I've also tried re-applying the December update at least 3 more times, with the same result. Any other ideas?

RogerXIII said:
First off, thanks for trying to help!
Flashing the stock boot.img "solves" the problem, I can boot and use the phone like normal, but without root obviously. Using the stock boot.img inside magisk manager to patch it with 17.3 and flashing that boot image to both partitions gives me this error again. I've also tried re-applying the December update at least 3 more times, with the same result. Any other ideas?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Flash the stock boot.img to both slots.
Reboot and check it.
Copy the Magisk zip to your phone.
Fastboot boot the TWRP img file, don't install it.
Use TWRP to install the Magisk zip, and you are done.

RogerXIII said:
First off, thanks for trying to help!
Flashing the stock boot.img "solves" the problem, I can boot and use the phone like normal, but without root obviously. Using the stock boot.img inside magisk manager to patch it with 17.3 and flashing that boot image to both partitions gives me this error again. I've also tried re-applying the December update at least 3 more times, with the same result. Any other ideas?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you have the previous version of Edge Sense Plus module installed? That sounds exactly like what happens if you install Magisk with that module still there. He put out a new one today.

sliding_billy said:
Do you have the previous version of Edge Sense Plus module installed? That sounds exactly like what happens if you install Magisk with that module still there. He put out a new one today.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you so much, this worked!
Instead of going back an Android version, I used this script, uninstalled all modules and re-flashed Magisk. It works perfectly now. Thanks again!

RogerXIII said:
Thank you so much, this worked!
Instead of going back an Android version, I used this script, uninstalled all modules and re-flashed Magisk. It works perfectly now. Thanks again!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good deal. That is why I always keep a copy of the Magisk uninstaller on the phone itself. As long as I can get to BL/temp TWRP .img, the worst I am out is the time it takes me to reconfigure Magisk.

RogerXIII said:
However, when I boot into twrp (not installed)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you use to get TWRP going when it's not permenantly installed? Just curious?
Fire Hound 8.1

Shaftamle said:
What do you use to get TWRP going when it's not permenantly installed? Just curious?
Fire Hound 8.1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The TWRP image from the official website, and then simply fastboot boot twrp.img

RogerXIII said:
The TWRP image from the official website, and then simply fastboot boot twrp.img
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok cool. Wasn't sure if there was an app like fashify or something.
Fire Hound 8.1

sliding_billy said:
Do you have the previous version of Edge Sense Plus module installed? That sounds exactly like what happens if you install Magisk with that module still there. He put out a new one today.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you are godsend my friend.

Touz604 said:
you are godsend my friend.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Glad you got it figured out.

RogerXIII said:
The TWRP image from the official website, and then simply fastboot boot twrp.img
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How can we boot the twrp from fastboot?
The one from official website doesn't support Android 10 I believe and I failed with the info says "too many links".

bbs3223474 said:
How can we boot the twrp from fastboot?
The one from official website doesn't support Android 10 I believe and I failed with the info says "too many links".
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You ca't yet.

bbs3223474 said:
How can we boot the twrp from fastboot?
The one from official website doesn't support Android 10 I believe and I failed with the info says "too many links".
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thread is from 2018

I am gonna check the official TWRP website for the workable TWRP for my Pixel 3 till I see your post
wangdaning said:
Thread is from 2018
Click to expand...
Click to collapse