Anyone running a treble GSI on top of Miui 10.2 vendor? - Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 Pro Questions & Answers

Hi folks,
I was installing the phh-treble on my device today, and ran into a bootloop.
Is anyone succesfully running it on top of a Miui 10.2 vendor partition?
I fastboot flashed back Miui 10.0.6 vendor from here and it boots, but this is only a workaround and Wifi is dead
Thanks!

Mokee rom is usually the best vendor to use.

[email protected] said:
Mokee rom is usually the best vendor to use.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks :good:
Interesting that this vendor should do better than the stock vendor

user822 said:
Thanks :good:
Interesting that this vendor should do better than the stock vendor
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This phone is weird ? like that. I am not sure but I read it that people only had success with mokee but also people have try MCAOSP and Ancient might work too since @guzman uses it now for his own ports for the OOS and the zenui pie ports.

Related

lineageos for 5t

Any idea why we don't have lineageos for 5t yet or when it will be available
Because it would be wasting time to put hard work on old 14.1 Lineage when 15.1 will come up. But there is no official release date.! Read Lineage Changelog
5t-Lineageos
i have build Lineageos for 5t build i cant test if it is gonna boot or not because i own a oneplus 5, so if some one want to test it...
https://mega.nz/#!rFwmSYyB!oR95S-ODQ4lyQZvj3ATRPG0QISoIjQihxGxk7hgwBVM
jef_00 said:
5t-Lineageos
i have build Lineageos for 5t build i cant test if it is gonna boot or not because i own a oneplus 5, so if some one want to test it...
https://mega.nz/#!rFwmSYyB!oR95S-ODQ4lyQZvj3ATRPG0QISoIjQihxGxk7hgwBVM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll be your guniepig. I'll try to flash it once I go home from work and give you updates
big_b0sss said:
I'll be your guniepig. I'll try to flash it once I go home from work and give you updates
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
nicee:good::good:
One question before I flash the lineageos on 5t,I have downloaded the zip file from the link and it says lineageos 15 which is based oreo so wouldn't my 5t need to have oreo bootloader in order to be able to successfully flash and boot? Since 5t runs on nougat wouldn't it be more sensible to flash lineageos nougat rather than oreo? Do you have any lineageos nougat build for 5t that I can test as well incase lineageos 15 doesn't flash or boot up
Edit: couldn't flash ended up with error 7
Careful. I flashed Liquid Remix 8.1 and it wiped my internal storage. Not saying this will happen to you, but make a backup on your PC!
you guys impede development
dcd1182 said:
you guys impede development
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How so?
which sources did you use for this? did you use the cheeseburger source?
jef_00 said:
5t-Lineageos
i have build Lineageos for 5t build i cant test if it is gonna boot or not because i own a oneplus 5, so if some one want to test it...
https://mega.nz/#!rFwmSYyB!oR95S-ODQ4lyQZvj3ATRPG0QISoIjQihxGxk7hgwBVM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
for now i reccomend all developers to build a los 14.1... because for now there are these stable sources and the base of this device is android 7.1.1
i like lineage and need burn in protection features
oreo will be later and probably lineage will skip los 15 and pass to los 15.1 based on 8.1 oreo
Alessandro999 said:
for now i reccomend all developers to build a los 14.1... because for now there are these stable sources and the base of this device is android 7.1.1
i like lineage and need burn in protection features
oreo will be later and probably lineage will skip los 15 and pass to los 15.1 based on 8.1 oreo
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Would really like that
xocomaox said:
Careful. I flashed Liquid Remix 8.1 and it wiped my internal storage. Not saying this will happen to you, but make a backup on your PC!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is because liquid remix you are supposed to be running decrypted. It is stated in OP5 thread in flashing instructions.
yung40oz84 said:
That is because liquid remix you are supposed to be running decrypted. It is stated in OP5 thread in flashing instructions.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I didn't read their thread. Just got a flash able zip from their web host. Figured it was due to encryption.
Help Development
What's the best way to assist with developing Lineage OS for the 5T?
Options (AFAIK):
Donate somewhere
Test builds on device and report bugs
xocomaox said:
I didn't read their thread. Just got a flash able zip from their web host. Figured it was due to encryption.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well then to be honest, you have no one to blame other then yourself for that fail. Never flash something without reading the thread on it. Bad things happen as you learned.
zelendel said:
Well then to be honest, you have no one to blame other then yourself for that fail. Never flash something without reading the thread on it. Bad things happen as you learned.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Re-read my original post. I am warning others about it, not blaming anyone. I lost no data (other than the zips I was flashing), merely noted the wipe.

Further ROM Development?

With the official release of 8.0, will the current ROMs for our devices such as RROS continue to be worked on?
Sent from my BND-L24 using Tapatalk
Soapy! said:
With the official release of 8.0, will the current ROMs for our decice such as RROS continue to be worked on?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We should be able to flash generic system images for project treble I'm hoping.
I imagine that project treble will revolutionize rom development, not end it. I see this as a really exciting time!
Me wondering which custom ROM to flash.
Lineage or RR builds here
Or those generic treble builds at treble forum
optionalmgrr.la said:
Me wondering which custom ROM to flash.
Lineage or RR builds here
Or those generic treble builds at treble forum
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AOSP Treble works, but steer clear of AOKP.
Soapy! said:
AOSP Treble works, but steer clear of AOKP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thx all function works? Camera?
BTW how about The specific builds here in 7x ROM forums?
optionalmgrr.la said:
Thx all function works? Camera?
BTW how about The specific builds here in 7x ROM forums?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AOSP Treble ROM has a few quirks on the 7X. The battery life isn't as good as stock EMUI and BT randomly crashes. As for RROS, I would search through the thread to find what you're looking for.
Soapy! said:
AOSP Treble ROM has a few quirks on the 7X. The battery life isn't as good as stock EMUI and BT randomly crashes. As for RROS, I would search through the thread to find what you're looking for.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A few quirks? Mean?
My AOSP Treble quirks:
-BT crashes randomly
Apparently, it's much worse with magisk as BT becomes unusable upon FCing until you restart your phone.
-Battery life isn't as good as stock EMUI
-Apps force close randomly when you wake your device.
-You have to clear Google Play cache every time you reboot just to install new apps or else they will be stuck on "Download Pending".
That's quite a lot.
Better use the specific builds here in 7x maybe
Do you guys think VoLTE will be available in any of the Roms?

can somebody create list of GSI supported ROM for lenovo p2 specific discussion?

can somebody create list of GSI supported ROM for lenovo p2 specific discussion?
I know GSI images will be supported in all treble enabled ROM but this kind of discussion will help users and devs.
Thanks.
MAILUS said:
can somebody create list of GSI supported ROM for lenovo p2 specific discussion?
I know GSI images will be supported in all treble enabled ROM but this kind of discussion will help users and devs.
Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have tried Android P and Havoc OS. They both works good and can be use as a daily driver.
shabab malik said:
I have tried Android P and Havoc OS. They both works good and can be use as a daily driver.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you share link to Havoc OS rom you used?
mcfotty said:
Can you share link to Havoc OS rom you used?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here is the list of all GSI available
https://github.com/phhusson/treble_experimentations/wiki/Generic-System-Image-(GSI)-list
shabab malik said:
Here is the list of all GSI available
https://github.com/phhusson/treble_experimentations/wiki/Generic-System-Image-(GSI)-list
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Am confused,I was able to run P flashed with Los treble for Lenovo and on link cant find Havoc os treble for lenovo
Pls can you explain how you did it?
mcfotty said:
Am confused,I was able to run P flashed with Los treble for Lenovo and on link cant find Havoc os treble for lenovo
Pls can you explain how you did it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here is the link
https://androidfilehost.com/?fid=5862345805528057827
BTW official version of the havoc is already available for our device now.
shabab malik said:
Here is the link
https://androidfilehost.com/?fid=5862345805528057827
BTW official version of the havoc is already available for our device now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So after decrypting on twrp I can flash above linked ROM and P gsi .
Correct me please
mcfotty said:
So after decrypting on twrp I can flash above linked ROM and P gsi .
Correct me please
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Follow this guide
https://forum.xda-developers.com/lenovo-p2/how-to/how-to-flash-android-p-semi-gsi-lenovo-t3817088
Whichever GSI rom you wanted to flash this would be the procedure just flash the GSI you wanted to but i recommend taking a full backup of your current rom if anything goes wrong.
shabab malik said:
Follow this guide
https://forum.xda-developers.com/lenovo-p2/how-to/how-to-flash-android-p-semi-gsi-lenovo-t3817088
Whichever GSI rom you wanted to flash this would be the procedure just flash the GSI you wanted to but i recommend taking a full backup of your current rom if anything goes wrong.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have setup android P GSI using LOS initially, but you mentioned Havoc and P GSI as being better, and was hoping for a setup without LOS.
Thanks a lot.
mcfotty said:
I have setup android P GSI using LOS initially, but you mentioned Havoc and P GSI as being better, and was hoping for a setup without LOS.
Thanks a lot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I haven't said anything is better i just said that i have try these GSI. Android p is nice but have some bugs like fingerprint gesture and camera that's why i left that rom.
Havoc is officially release for our device so i will not recommend you to flash Havoc GSI. Here is the link
https://forum.xda-developers.com/lenovo-p2/development/rom-havoc-os-t3823765
Just flash it as a normal rom.
shabab malik said:
I haven't said anything is better i just said that i have try these GSI. Android p is nice but have some bugs like fingerprint gesture and camera that's why i left that rom.
Havoc is officially release for our device so i will not recommend you to flash Havoc GSI. Here is the link
https://forum.xda-developers.com/lenovo-p2/development/rom-havoc-os-t3823765
Just flash it as a normal rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I rather remain on Crdroid cos casting to my TV works great
What are the ROMs working in SELINUX enforcing mode?
MAILUS said:
What are the ROMs working in SELINUX enforcing mode?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Official Lineage 15.1 and roms made by fullbustah (Since they are based on mike lineage 15.1).
MAILUS said:
What are the ROMs working in SELINUX enforcing mode?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried Pixel Experience and DoT OS official GSIs and they both working in enforced mode
Kielbek said:
I tried Pixel Experience and DoT OS official GSIs and they both working in enforced mode
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does fingerprint gesture works in any GSI you have tried?
I was thinking to try Resurrection Remix GSI.
shabab malik said:
Does fingerprint gesture works in any GSI you have tried?
I was thinking to try Resurrection Remix GSI.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nah, device-specific functions like FP gestures don't work out of box. Someone posted somewhere on our forums flashable zip for GSI's to make that function work. It's fresh thread, saw it today. I only did quick GSI test but everything else seems to work just fine.
I'm going to fully test one of these treble ROMs in upcoming days but actually I'm thinking which one should I flash.
Kielbek said:
Nah, device-specific functions like FP gestures don't work out of box. Someone posted somewhere on our forums flashable zip for GSI's to make that function work. It's fresh thread, saw it today. I only did quick GSI test but everything else seems to work just fine.
I'm going to fully test one of these treble ROMs in upcoming days but actually I'm thinking which one should I flash.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Resurrection remix would be great?
shabab malik said:
Resurrection remix would be great
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
RR is pretty nice and have a lot of customisation so why not. Already downloading proper official images so I can start testing soon
Kielbek said:
RR is pretty nice and have a lot of customisation so why not. Already downloading proper official images so I can start testing soon
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tested RR ? Feedback?
MAILUS said:
Have you tested RR ? Feedback?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep and I was frustated while testing it. I can't recommend using official GSI version since it was broken and horrible experience. Even simple things like changing accent colour, theme was not working properly. I encountered some irritating bugs that just pissed me off which leaded me to instant ROM change. And I was not the only one. The biggest flaw was that I couldn't register my device to use google services properly. Even if I managed to get certification it was just gone after couple of minutes. Not saying about SafetyNet because passing it wasn't even possible.
I don't know how's the current state but I recommend to use Fullbustah's P2 version if you want have most stable RR experience.
I should have screenshots of what I experienced with that GSI somewhere, I will try to find them tommorow.

what is the best GSIs rom

what is the best GSIs rom for mi max 3
thanks
For me,pixel experience is very fast and smooth.
Pick one: AOSiP, Descendant, PixelExperience or AOSP.
There's more but those are some reliable go-tos.
In my opinion, AOSiP and DotOS are the best. Very stable and with some customizations.
Doto OS, Ressurection Remix and Havoc OS
Dot OS has stopped GSI dev 6 months ago, since then theyve added way more features and gotten even better
Havoc also stopped GSi 6 months ago. i donated to them and begged em to try gsi or our phone . No luck
Ressurection remix is still putting out GSIs as of February, though their february build wouldnt boot on 2 of my phones
I have a 6gb/128gb blue mimax3. None of the gsis have booted successfully n my phone
caniranges said:
Doto OS, Ressurection Remix and Havoc OS
Dot OS has stopped GSI dev 6 months ago, since then theyve added way more features and gotten even better
Havoc also stopped GSi 6 months ago. i donated to them and begged em to try gsi or our phone . No luck
Ressurection remix is still putting out GSIs as of February, though their february build wouldnt boot on 2 of my phones
I have a 6gb/128gb blue mimax3. None of the gsis have booted successfully n my phone
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using DotOS on 10/03, Nfound version and it's great. The pixel experience only runs the versions until December and havoc has even stopped developing GSI. As for the issue of booting the device, it depends on which vendor GSI needs: pie or oreo. Look here - https://forum.xda-developers.com/mi-max-3/how-to/guide-how-to-boot-pie-gsis-fix-issues-t3895860 and here https://forum.xda-developers.com/mi-max-3/how-to/guide-beginners-guide-to-gsi-aosp-rom-t3910085 to see an idea.
Germano1980 said:
I'm using DotOS on 10/03, Nfound version and it's great.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks alot Germano,
i was in despair before you answered.
2 questions please--
Where did you find the DotOS Nfound version?
Could you please post a link?
Most important, When youre installing a GSI, first you install a Xiaomi.eu Rom,
Do you reboot and set up the Xiaomi.eu rom first, and then you factory reset.?
Or do you just install in recovery and factory reset immediately in recovery?
caniranges said:
Thanks alot Germano,
i was in despair before you answered.
2 questions please--
Where did you find the DotOS Nfound version?
Could you please post a link?
Most important, When youre installing a GSI, first you install a Xiaomi.eu Rom,
Do you reboot and set up the Xiaomi.eu rom first, and then you factory reset.?
Or do you just install in recovery and factory reset immediately in recovery?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1- The ROM you can find here: https://androidfilehost.com/?w=files&flid=291210;
2 - I installed Xiaomi.eu 9.3.14 and then DotOS following this guide here: https://forum.xda-developers.com/mi-max-3/how-to/guide-beginners-guide-to-gsi-aosp-rom-t3910085 - do exactly as described and everything will work out;
3- When Xiaomi.eu starts, it asks to log into the Mi account. I login only and then restart TWRP to install GSI.
I hope it helps you.
Thanks, Germano bro,
Im on AOSIP (02-17 version, cos latest version hasnt booted), and im going to try POSP tomorrow.
Dotos was fun and the best one that successfully booted, but im trying to get a GSI that has fonts. Im still delighted to have The DotOS as an option. I didnt have any idea it existed.
Cheers!!:good:
caniranges said:
Thanks, Germano bro,
Im on AOSIP (02-17 version, cos latest version hasnt booted), and im going to try POSP tomorrow.
Dotos was fun and the best one that successfully booted, but im trying to get a GSI that has fonts. Im still delighted to have The DotOS as an option. I didnt have any idea it existed.
Cheers!!:good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're welcome. DotOS and AOSiP are very similar in terms of functionality and stability. But I can only boot DotOS using xiaomi.eu 9.3.14 as a base. The roms that have "vanilla" in the name boot normally using the rom 9.3.14 (except those that need the oreo vendor).

AOSP ROM for Galaxy A50?

I got this phone a month or so ago, and since I did I've been curious to see if there'd be any custom ROM support. Is there any word of AOSP ROMS or anything like LineageOS?
A stable twrp must come first.
And we need pie vendor to boot up custom gsis.
bobandar said:
A stable twrp must come first.
And we need pie vendor to boot up custom gsis.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You have stock vendor because the phone is Treble

Categories

Resources