Have just got an M8, sadly its on an really old version of android 5.1 and looking to update it using a custom rom.
one issue though is i really like Android pay/Banking apps to work so cant root or leave bootloader unlocked i dont think?
which ROM would you recommend preferably noughat if you feel its stable on the M8 and how can i make sure both android pay and banking apps work successfully ? do i need to make sure something is locked/not touched?
many thanks! an eager HTC fan!
jackvdbuk said:
Have just got an M8, sadly its on an really old version of android 5.1 and looking to update it using a custom rom.
one issue though is i really like Android pay/Banking apps to work so cant root or leave bootloader unlocked i dont think?
which ROM would you recommend preferably noughat if you feel its stable on the M8 and how can i make sure both android pay and banking apps work successfully ? do i need to make sure something is locked/not touched?
many thanks! an eager HTC fan!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
don't root the rom or use a rootless rom
you can use magisk but safteynet is getting updates this days and magisk will get updates also it's just need time
unlocked bootloader is fine on this device only root is breaking safteynet
ahmed.ismael said:
you can use magisk but safteynet is getting updates this days and magisk will get updates also it's just need time
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Magisk 13 beta is out, which should pass Safetynet. But it is beta, and some folks are having various issues/bugs.
Also, on my current daily driver device (OnePlus 3T) I've tried Magisk 12 with the Magisk module "Universal Safetynet Fix" and it passes Safetynet.
Link to various Magisk threads, if the OP is interested: https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk
You are completely right, it's the typical "cat and mouse game", where Google doesn't like Safetynet bypassed, will keep updating it; and topjohnwu (dev of Magisk) will keep trying to bypass it. Really annoying, for those of us that just want control of their phone (for simple things like Viper4A, Titanium, etc.) but still want access to banking apps, Netflix, etc.
Hi,
I have Samsung S9 phone (Exynos version) with official Lineage OS 17 installed. Also I have Magisk (package renamed, Magisk Hide is active) as root control app.
Recently I've bought Galaxy Watch (not 2 or 3), installed Wearable, changed system props to be able to run it (as described here: https://forum.xda-developers.com/ga...earable-app-rooted-phone-help-t3838503/page10) and everything works OK, except inability to pay with watch.
When I run Samsung Pay from Wearable app, it tells about unauthorized modifications and exit.
I've found this interesting log, named com.samsung.android.samsungpay.gear.log in the root of internal storage.
In this log (which is XML) I see a section "detections", and there I see next stuff:
<Detection>
Date Time Source Policy Summary Current Warning Ver Name Description
2020-08-15 09:14:31 [7107] 52355100 00004000 00004000 00004000 5.3.0 (ROOTED ) com.topjohnwu.magisk
2020-08-15 09:19:06 [7107] 52355100 00004000 00004000 00004000 5.3.0 (ROOTED ) com.topjohnwu.magisk
</Detection>
I've double-checked, in Magisk I hide it from this Samsung app.
So, my question is - why it still able to detect magisk? And what I can do to be able to pay with watch?
Thank you for pointing this file out. Exactly what I was looking for.
Mine, too, says Magisk is found.
I still can't get the Samsung Wear App to work, but good to get confirmation what it is detecting, Magisk in this case.
I was getting this error on LineageOS even before Magisk. I specifically installed Magisk to see if that hide feature would help.
Now at least I can go back to plain LineageOS without Magisk and see what it says.
Thanks.
DulacLancelot said:
Thank you for pointing this file out. Exactly what I was looking for.
Mine, too, says Magisk is found.
I still can't get the Samsung Wear App to work, but good to get confirmation what it is detecting, Magisk in this case.
I was getting this error on LineageOS even before Magisk. I specifically installed Magisk to see if that hide feature would help.
Now at least I can go back to plain LineageOS without Magisk and see what it says.
Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Eh. I uninstalled Magisk. And the LineageOS root functionality is disabled. Wear Samsung Pay still detects root, and flags it multiples times as "MAGISK-11" or "MAGISK-2" or "framework".
Samsung Pay will never work on rooted devices. It's related to knox services.
w41ru5 said:
Samsung Pay will never work on rooted devices. It's related to knox services.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wrong. I've had Samsung pay working on my watch with rooted pixel 3a xl
And i have it on my rooted Pixel 2 XL....
Install Magisk
Enable MagiskHide
MagiskHide all Samsung apps
Rename Magisk Manager
Do this before opening Samsung Pay
Hi all,
Does anyone know how the 5T behaves with Android 10/11 in regards to SafetyNet? I am thinking of replacing the ageing Android 9 install with the new android 10 or maybe even android 11 - but I'd like to find out if I will be having problems with mobile banking software (nordea, danske bank, jyske bank etc) - Mobilepay - and maybe the national ID solutions as well.
Does anyone of you have experience with that? are you having issues? I suppose its not really specific for the 5T...
I can still pass SafetyNet using Magisk on Android 10.
EvalType is basic on the OnePlus 5T at the moment, so Google are not checking for an unlocked bootloader.
I'm in the UK, however if your banking software works on Android 9, it still should on Android 10. No problems with my UK banks, Android Pay or Pokemon Go.
j_jorgensen said:
Hi all,
Does anyone know how the 5T behaves with Android 10/11 in regards to SafetyNet? I am thinking of replacing the ageing Android 9 install with the new android 10 or maybe even android 11 - but I'd like to find out if I will be having problems with mobile banking software (nordea, danske bank, jyske bank etc) - Mobilepay - and maybe the national ID solutions as well.
Does anyone of you have experience with that? are you having issues? I suppose its not really specific for the 5T...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you want to switch to an A11-CustomRom you have to install MAGISK v21!
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases
nicorvienne said:
If you want to switch to an A11-CustomRom you have to install MAGISK v21!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have read a little about it - thanks! But I've also read posts with people saying that its not working on A11 with SafetyNet? Are you on A11 with banking apps etc? I suppose the Pokemon app is a valid test as well..:laugh:
j_jorgensen said:
I have read a little about it - thanks! But I've also read posts with people saying that its not working on A11 with SafetyNet? Are you on A11 with banking apps etc? I suppose the Pokemon app is a valid test as well..:laugh:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi, yep - my device is running A11-DerpFest; SatyNet passes & banking app (VISA) is working!
how to pass the safetynet on A11 derpfest os
I have been unable to use Jyske Bank on rooted Samsung (Android 10) with Magisk Hide, but Mobilepay works fine.
Hey guys, has anyone gotten Gpay to work on lineage 19.1? I have done the following and have had very odd results. Firstly, I am passing safteynet and my device is registered as play certified in Google play store. I'm seeing where sometimes gpay won't open at all and when it does it says it is unable to load my payment methods.
Specs:
OS - linageOS 19.1 (latest build as of this post)
GAPPS - Mindthegapps (latest build as of this post)
Steps taken:
Installed magisk, enabled zygisk and rebooted
Installed magisk hide props module then rebooted
Installed shamiko module then rebooted
Installed universal safteynet fix (zygisk) then rebooted
Configured denylist in magisk checking GPS (all), and Gpay (all) rebooted
Changed device fingerprint with magisk hide props module to a certified one then rebooted
Additional steps taken:
I cleared data from GPS, play store and Gpay and rebooted
I tried a different device fingerprint and rebooted (clearing data like above afterwards and rebooting again)
I have done a complete fresh install of my OS and tried again from scratch.
I also tried seeing is renaming magisk would help at all, it didn't
It appears I'm getting nowhere with this. If anyone has gotten it to work and has some insight it's be greatly appreciated!
Nevermind, looks like it was an issue from having the pixelify module installed as well. After I removed it it started working just fine.
deathblade said:
Nevermind, looks like it was an issue from having the pixelify module installed as well. After I removed it it started working just fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey deathblade!
Thanks for helping me out on the other thread.
Just wanted to check in, did you use the official build or the unofficial one with the Pixel Goodies? I'm intending/hoping to have full functionalities of Google Pay using the unofficial build, but from your post it seems that I can't have the Pixel experience if I want the ROM to work with Google Pay?
HW898 said:
Hey deathblade!
Thanks for helping me out on the other thread.
Just wanted to check in, did you use the official build or the unofficial one with the Pixel Goodies? I'm intending/hoping to have full functionalities of Google Pay using the unofficial build, but from your post it seems that I can't have the Pixel experience if I want the ROM to work with Google Pay?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using the official build. I think the unofficial has everything needed to use Gpay and have some pixel things baked in. So might be worth a look in your case
deathblade said:
I'm using the official build. I think the unofficial has everything needed to use Gpay and have some pixel things baked in. So might be worth a look in your case
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Aite, I will try out the unofficial one and see if GPay works there too. Thanks for the headsup!
HW898 said:
Aite, I will try out the unofficial one and see if GPay works there too. Thanks for the headsup!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just remembered, the unofficial is setup to pass safteynet out the box, but more maybe needed for Gpay to work. Once you flash it try it out, if you run into issues I can provide what I did to get Gpay working
deathblade said:
Nevermind, looks like it was an issue from having the pixelify module installed as well. After I removed it it started working just fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi there, trying out the official build after experiencing some problems on the unofficial one. Any alternatives to pixiel-ing the ROM?
HW898 said:
Hi there, trying out the official build after experiencing some problems on the unofficial one. Any alternatives to pixiel-ing the ROM?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not that I've found, however I did notice if you install the pixelify module then uninstall it, it does seem to leave some stuff behind. Like I still have the option to use Hold for me and direct my call. So it might work out where you can install it to get the things you want then remove it to get Gpay working
deathblade said:
Not that I've found, however I did notice if you install the pixelify module then uninstall it, it does seem to leave some stuff behind. Like I still have the option to use Hold for me and direct my call. So it might work out where you can install it to get the things you want then remove it to get Gpay working
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see... So these also means stuff like Now playing etc. will be gone too right?
Also, did you experience the problems I've faced in the unofficial build? sounds cannot change etc. as posted in main thread
HW898 said:
I see... So these also means stuff like Now playing etc. will be gone too right?
Also, did you experience the problems I've faced in the unofficial build? sounds cannot change etc. as posted in main thread
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope now playing is still there. I really only used it the module to force call screening to show up. But I have pretty much everything I remember from stock plus a few phone related goodies. I never tried the unofficial build but on the official I do not have that issue
deathblade said:
Nope now playing is still there. I really only used it the module to force call screening to show up. But I have pretty much everything I remember from stock plus a few phone related goodies. I never tried the unofficial build but on the official I do not have that issue
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see... I will try installing the official one without magisk as I won't want to meddle with rooting stuff for now, will get back with results asap!
deathblade said:
Hey guys, has anyone gotten Gpay to work on lineage 19.1? I have done the following and have had very odd results. Firstly, I am passing safteynet and my device is registered as play certified in Google play store. I'm seeing where sometimes gpay won't open at all and when it does it says it is unable to load my payment methods.
Specs:
OS - linageOS 19.1 (latest build as of this post)
GAPPS - Mindthegapps (latest build as of this post)
Steps taken:
Installed magisk, enabled zygisk and rebooted
Installed magisk hide props module then rebooted
Installed shamiko module then rebooted
Installed universal safteynet fix (zygisk) then rebooted
Configured denylist in magisk checking GPS (all), and Gpay (all) rebooted
Changed device fingerprint with magisk hide props module to a certified one then rebooted
Additional steps taken:
I cleared data from GPS, play store and Gpay and rebooted
I tried a different device fingerprint and rebooted (clearing data like above afterwards and rebooting again)
I have done a complete fresh install of my OS and tried again from scratch.
I also tried seeing is renaming magisk would help at all, it didn't
It appears I'm getting nowhere with this. If anyone has gotten it to work and has some insight it's be greatly appreciated!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just also wanted to clarify in the case I decide to install magisk, which module do you install exactly? All of them? Zygisk/hide props module/shamiko/universal safetynet fix?
HW898 said:
Just also wanted to clarify in the case I decide to install magisk, which module do you install exactly? All of them? Zygisk/hide props module/shamiko/universal safetynet fix?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok so here is the breakdown:
Zygisk is not a module, but an implementation method used by modules. Magiskhide props is used to change the device fingerprint to a valid one that registers as protected by google play. Shamiko is for hiding root from Google play services, and Gpay (and whatever other apps may need it). Universal safteynet fix is used to help pass google safteynet checks (security). Not listed is the pixelify module used to add pixel exclusive features but of course with it install it cause havoc on Gpay and other apps so once installed it should be uninstalled.
TLDR
Yes all of them
deathblade said:
Ok so here is the breakdown:
Zygisk is not a module, but an implementation method used by modules. Magiskhide props is used to change the device fingerprint to a valid one that registers as protected by google play. Shamiko is for hiding root from Google play services, and Gpay (and whatever other apps may need it). Universal safteynet fix is used to help pass google safteynet checks (security). Not listed is the pixelify module used to add pixel exclusive features but of course with it install it cause havoc on Gpay and other apps so once installed it should be uninstalled.
TLDR
Yes all of them
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Aite thanks for the help mate! just installed but apparently, i couldn't find gapps despite sideloading it.. might have to reinstall again
Hmm safetynet fix seems to fail, can't pass cts profile.. any step by step guides by any chance?
deathblade said:
Ok so here is the breakdown:
Zygisk is not a module, but an implementation method used by modules. Magiskhide props is used to change the device fingerprint to a valid one that registers as protected by google play. Shamiko is for hiding root from Google play services, and Gpay (and whatever other apps may need it). Universal safteynet fix is used to help pass google safteynet checks (security). Not listed is the pixelify module used to add pixel exclusive features but of course with it install it cause havoc on Gpay and other apps so once installed it should be uninstalled.
TLDR
Yes all of them
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
HW898 said:
Hmm safetynet fix seems to fail, can't pass cts profile.. any step by step guides by any chance?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's where magisk hide props comes in. I don't have a full guide that I know of but I could do a quick wtite up tomorrow for you
deathblade said:
That's where magisk hide props comes in. I don't have a full guide that I know of but I could do a quick wtite up tomorrow for you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I got it working after following a guide~
Unfortunately features like now playing isn't working. the rest is pretty much okay tho
HW898 said:
I got it working after following a guide~
Unfortunately features like now playing isn't working. the rest is pretty much okay tho
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You install the pixelify module? Also can you explain how it's not working?
deathblade said:
You install the pixelify module? Also can you explain how it's not working?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope, I didn't. Other than the modules to hide from banking apps as mentioned above, I installed a pixel launch module here to make it for pixel-like: https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/app-mod-pixel-launcher.4442077/
Other than that nothing else.
It doesn't;t work in the sense that it does not pick up music, even popular ones. The settings are there though, I can see them. It just doesn't identify any songs
HW898 said:
Nope, I didn't. Other than the modules to hide from banking apps as mentioned above, I installed a pixel launch module here to make it for pixel-like: https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/app-mod-pixel-launcher.4442077/
Other than that nothing else.
It doesn't;t work in the sense that it does not pick up music, even popular ones. The settings are there though, I can see them. It just doesn't identify any songs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is the pixelify module I installed then removed, you can give it a try.
GitHub - Kingsman44/Pixelify: Magisk module to enables pixel exclusive features and ui
Magisk module to enables pixel exclusive features and ui - GitHub - Kingsman44/Pixelify: Magisk module to enables pixel exclusive features and ui
github.com
What is the best new rom for banking app? thank u guys, great community
Whatever supports your specific banking app I guess.
FMMMG said:
What is the best new rom for banking app? thank u guys, great community
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've been using crDoid with GPay for months now, through many updates. Works fine with magisk deny list (added only google play and play services) and the modded safetynet fix magisk addon.
Mine works out of the box on ArrowOS 13 (no root)
I use Banko OS 13
jefffrom said:
I use Banko OS 13
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use Bank OS too
I run Evo-X V7.5 Build 6 and i never had issues with any banking apps,
i use Google Wallet, Santander, Natwest, Tescos Wallet, Samsung Pay,
you`ve got the gist, i like banking apps ,
Once you do the normal Magisk (hide your apps and rename ect) and hide the re-named Magisk using SDMaid it works GREAT.
As for a great community, there are very few issues with Evo-X and therefore not that much activity,
Aggelos released a minor update on the "Evox alioth Early release" Telegram channel today.
This ROM is Amazing and comes with "SMART CHARGING",
Happy Days.