Related
I just purchased one on amazon from ArmorSuit. Gotta be one of the best screen protectors out there. Way Way better then skinomi and the majority that is out there. 5/5 stars. Just my honest opinion. Want to help out those who are looking for something of quality. Go ahead and give it a try, you wont regret it.
amazon.com/gp/product/B0055851VA
Also want to say that their customer service is top notch. Love it.
Just got my Armor Suit and it is the best screen protector I've ever used. 5 stars.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA Premium App
Is invisible shield just not good anymore?
I think I'll try this Armorsuit...I just received the SGP screen protector....suck and overpriced..lucky I got it from Amazon...easy return service....
I got the Steinheil Ultra Crystal (SQ) and the fit (some air around the camera) and quality is really good (been using Steinheil screen protectors for years on my phones). I got my from Amazon.com and its kinda expensive but its like $21/year =).
This isn't the place I got my, but you can see all the different types.
http://cretouch.com/samsung-galaxy-c-210_238.html
couldn't find one here, hence bought a notebook screen protector and pruned it for perfect fit on my galaxy tab plus used the remnant for my phone.
I'm worried if I put an Invisibleshield screen protector on my GT 10.1 it will leave a permenant haze or film on the the screen when I decide to take it off. Can anyone offer any information? Thank you
I got this.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=140566290274&ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT
3x screen protectors for $10 shipped. They're matte. Fit almost perfect (1mm smaller than the actual glass to prevent lifting).
I dont see any reason for a screen protector other than wanting to have a matte screen to remove the glare.
5thElement said:
I dont see any reason for a screen protector other than wanting to have a matte screen to remove the glare.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Most of us actually prefer our screen (gorilla glass or not) scratch-free. Having a protector gives you ease of mind when rubbing a smudge or fingerprint off too.
Itaintrite said:
I got this.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=140566290274&ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT
3x screen protectors for $10 shipped. They're matte. Fit almost perfect (1mm smaller than the actual glass to prevent lifting).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just installed that exact same one from the same seller. Fits perfectly, especially around the camera and ambient light sensor. It adds a little bit of a grainy texture to the display, but all anti-glare films I've used do that. Not sure if it's really got an anti-grease / oleophobic coating as mine has some decent fingerprints, but the matte surface hides it well.
Tip to line it up the first time: before you take off the backing, line it up how you want it. Scotch tape it 3x on one of the edges, preferrably the one with the pull-tab for the backing. Make a tape handle for the opposite end of the screen. When you're ready to install it, hold the tape handle and pull the backing off with the tab, then pull the handle tight as you lay down the protector.
Trust me, I went through at least 7 different screen protectors (I got the Asus, Acer, and Samsung) and this is by far the best one out there. Good luck.
sabor504 said:
Trust me, I went through at least 7 different screen protectors (I got the Asus, Acer, and Samsung) and this is by far the best one out there. Good luck.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How does it stack up against InvisibleShield and the other 3M Scratchguard types? I usually don't like the texture on those.
Don't know about the ones I've been hearing about in this thread, but I've got InvisibleShield on my Galaxy Tab 10.1 and I'm probably never taking it off. It works wonders and I have the same protector for my HTC Evo. Never need another screen protector once you go InvisibleShield.
I myself have been searching for a screen protector for my tab. I have the invisishield on my evo4g, and I find that it adds quite a bit of sticky friction to swiping, or any time you drag your finger across the screen. It's not so important on the phone as it would be on the tab, so here's my question:
What sp will offer some protection, but doesn't add much friction to the touch experience.
Appreciate the input!
nottechspecd said:
I myself have been searching for a screen protector for my tab. I have the invisishield on my evo4g, and I find that it adds quite a bit of sticky friction to swiping, or any time you drag your finger across the screen. It's not so important on the phone as it would be on the tab, so here's my question:
What sp will offer some protection, but doesn't add much friction to the touch experience.
Appreciate the input!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The one I mentioned above is smooth. The matte finish makes it feel more like high gloss paper than glass. I'm considering buying a clear protector from the same company though as the "sparkly" effect that the matte finish adds to the screen (esp. things that are solid green for some reason) is getting on my nerves.
I have the zagg invisibleSHIELD maximum protection, is was a little skeptical at first but really like it now the i have had it on for a coupke weeks. There is more grip to the tablet now, but i can still slide my fingers over the screen with no issues. I will say this though, if you have never installed something like this take your time whrn installing it.
Sent from my GT-P7510 using XDA Premium App
Apologies if it has already been asked, i may have missed it.
I'd like to have a specific anti-glare screen protector, the glossy screen is not bad but still very reflective, a part from the usual fingerprints issue.
Any product that suits my needs?
Tia
Try the matte screen protector from SGP
kelvintwc said:
Try the matte screen protector from SGP
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks man, appreciated.
Hello all,
I am looking for some advice on the SPIGEN Screen Protector Steinheil (Ultra Fine or SQ Crystal Clear). My main concern is too keep the spen as precise as possible, as if im using it bareback. I have seen the Zagg Invis on some of my friends and tried it and I just dont like the drag, rubbery feeling and scratch like marks it leaves.
If it helps I do alot of art work and sketches, i just can't drag a Cintiq around.
Any thoughts would be great.
Thanks.
codeflight said:
Hello all,
I am looking for some advice on the SPIGEN Screen Protector Steinheil (Ultra Fine or SQ Crystal Clear). My main concern is too keep the spen as precise as possible, as if im using it bareback. I have seen the Zagg Invis on some of my friends and tried it and I just dont like the drag, rubbery feeling and scratch like marks it leaves.
If it helps I do alot of art work and sketches, i just can't drag a Cintiq around.
Any thoughts would be great.
Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the Spigen SPG Ultra Fine. The install was easy. I do screen installs in my bathroom with the shower on hot so that the humidity is up. It prevents dust from floating in the air.
The screen went on easily, smoothed out easily, and looks great. The smudge / finger print resistance is great so far and the pen works with no issue aside from the traces of what you wrote being left on the shield. It wipes off though.
But you can definitely see what I'd call a chalk-like outline on the screen after using the pen so regularly cleaning will be necessary with this shield.
I have a ultra fine on my n7k and its nice. Held up good so far 8 months down the road. .
Sent from my GT-N7000 using Tapatalk 2
it's definitely less rubbery than Zagg, if you don't like any drag, change your wacom pen nib to the pure white one. It's dam smooth with it.
The ultra fine isnt even close to zagg in the way it feels....
Sent from my GT-N7000 using Tapatalk 2
tokendog said:
I have the Spigen SPG Ultra Fine. The install was easy. I do screen installs in my bathroom with the shower on hot so that the humidity is up. It prevents dust from floating in the air.
The screen went on easily, smoothed out easily, and looks great. The smudge / finger print resistance is great so far and the pen works with no issue aside from the traces of what you wrote being left on the shield. It wipes off though.
But you can definitely see what I'd call a chalk-like outline on the screen after using the pen so regularly cleaning will be necessary with this shield.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As meticulous as I am, I made all precautions for adhering the Spigen Clear protector. Cleaned my surroundings in the bathroom, washed my hands, Steamed the room with fogged mirrors, and closed door and STILL static and dust particles!! The more I tried, the more dust there was! I gave up about a half hour later with about 30 dust particles under the protector. Plus, those small adhesive strips they provide to a terrible job in removing dust from the back side of the protector. Years ago, I bought a Boxwave protector for my GF's Sony Clie TH55. Obviously a smaller screen, but no problem what so ever and NO precautions necessary. $22 down the drain which is too much for a piece acetate with adhesive. Probably cost pennies to make. The printing and assembly of the product box probably cost more.
For big screens like this one, you guys should get wet apply protectors.
I got Xtremeguardz, and they're amazing. No dust, and I switched the pen tip to one of the plastic one so there's no residue and it flows smoothly.
Sent from my SGH-T989 using Tapatalk 2
theking_13 said:
For big screens like this one, you guys should get wet apply protectors.
I got Xtremeguardz, and they're amazing. No dust, and I switched the pen tip to one of the plastic one so there's no residue and it flows smoothly.
Sent from my SGH-T989 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, if Spigen sends out an other one free of charge, then I'll take further precautions like wearing a hazmat suite IN the shower.
Just an update:
I went ahead and purchased the Ultra Crystal and the Ultra Fine. Both were very easy to apply I just followed this video on youtube. Since I cant post links just search this in youtube "Installation And Review Of Steinheil Screen Protector Galaxy Tab 10.1".
I applied the Ultra Fine on a Galaxy Tab and the Ultra Crystal on my Galaxy Note 10.1 both with ease.
To follow up the results of my original question about possible spen scratch marks.
Ultra Crystal: The black nib left no signs of scratch marks, though there was slight resistance.
Ultra Crystal: The white nib felt smooth and similar to bareback. But when I turned off the Note, I noticed marks everywhere. I tried to wipe it off and had no luck. Dissapointed at this point I tried to do more research on my desktop to find another screen protector. Approximately 30 minutes later I come back to my Note and lo' and behold the spen scratch marks were gone. I don't know if the protector has some self healing property but it is certainly different from the Zagg I have seen on my friends were the marks stayed.
As for fingerprints, the Ultra Crystal does pick up prints, were the Ultra Fine does not.
Codeflight, what's the quality of the ultra fine one like? I believe it is anti-glare or matte, so does it pixellate the screen or make it harder to read in any way? Must you turn up the brightness to compensate?
I got the ultra-fine (matte) a couple days ago and I'm pretty happy with it. I found the solid white plastic s-pen tip works much better than the black tip, and I've yet to notice any marks or scratches after a couple days of solid note taking. Like any matte screen protector, it diminishes the sharpness of the screen somewhat and requires a slight bump in brightness to compensate, but I read a lot of pdfs and the reduction in glare is worth it to me. I haven't noticed any pixelation or grain effect.
holgalee said:
Codeflight, what's the quality of the ultra fine one like? I believe it is anti-glare or matte, so does it pixellate the screen or make it harder to read in any way? Must you turn up the brightness to compensate?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Beetmonger has already posted, I have had similar experiences with the Ultra Fine, so in addition to your question about brightness, Yes I do have to turn up brightness a couple of notches.
codeflight said:
Just an update:
I went ahead and purchased the Ultra Crystal and the Ultra Fine. Both were very easy to apply I just followed this video on youtube. Since I cant post links just search this in youtube "Installation And Review Of Steinheil Screen Protector Galaxy Tab 10.1".
I applied the Ultra Fine on a Galaxy Tab and the Ultra Crystal on my Galaxy Note 10.1 both with ease.
To follow up the results of my original question about possible spen scratch marks.
Ultra Crystal: The black nib left no signs of scratch marks, though there was slight resistance.
Ultra Crystal: The white nib felt smooth and similar to bareback. But when I turned off the Note, I noticed marks everywhere. I tried to wipe it off and had no luck. Dissapointed at this point I tried to do more research on my desktop to find another screen protector. Approximately 30 minutes later I come back to my Note and lo' and behold the spen scratch marks were gone. I don't know if the protector has some self healing property but it is certainly different from the Zagg I have seen on my friends were the marks stayed.
As for fingerprints, the Ultra Crystal does pick up prints, were the Ultra Fine does not.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
one review I read says there is no hole for the sensor?
wyou2 said:
one review I read says there is no hole for the sensor?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. I can confirm that.
Using ultra crystal. Slightly more rubbery but love it after i change to the white pen nib.
One of the good screen protectors is the clearplex protector. Check it out here: http://clearplex.myshopify.com/coll...r-shield-guard-protector-skin-cover-case-note
thanks for the post kenny but the OP is asking specifically about the spigen. That clearplex is already in the "what is the best protector" thread.no need to hijack this one.
Does the ultra fine affects the sensor, since there is no hole for it?
Sigh. I think I'm just too sensitive. I found the Ultra Fine unbearably scratchy. I just installed the Crystal and it still feels pretty different from the bare screen. It's definitely rubbery, and whenever my stylus catches any dust particle it feels like I'm scratching sand onto the screen. Plus sometimes it even squeaks! Maybe I just can't have a protector if I'm using a stylus. I'm waiting for a Just Like Glass protector for my new Nexus 7, and if the stylus works on it I might just try one for the Note.
Sent from my GT-N8013 using Tapatalk 2
Update: 12/16/12
Been using this for 3 days and I'm very satisfied with it:
How it feels - It feels like touching a regular paper but smoother.
Spen tip - White tip
Big improvement: I can put my palm on the screen without zooming in on the note, I guess my palm slides a little on the glass surface causing it to zoom.
Screen doesn't look as dirty because of the finger prints.
Can read longer because the screen isn't too bright and glare is greatly reduced.
Overall I like it because it feels like writing on a paper rather than glass. I'm not really a fan of writing on glass and since I was little I've been writing on paper ^_^v
Original post:
Well I finally got my Ultra Fine and all I can say is wow. I had moko screen protector before and I've felt it restrict my fingers from doing swipes and forget about the spen. I took that moko screen off my note after 30 minutes from installation. The end result with any screen protector is subjective, but I do urge you guys to try Ultra Fine.
Install: Easy if you follow the directions. Orient your note "portrait" so the camera/sensor would be on your left side and the charging port will be on your right. clean with provided solution and towel. Peel off about 1~2 inches. Align it close to the edge from top and peel halfway let the screen protector adhere it self. double check for any dust particle then proceed installing to the rest of the tablet. Squeeze out the bubbles and check for dust particles. I had 1 dust particle and used the supplied tape to lift the edge and another tape to get the dust. So let me say it again. only peel off the backing halfway to reduce dust particle from getting between the screen and protector.
Spen - use the white tip and don't need to press to hard to write ^_^ it feels good writing.
Brightness compensation - Very Subjective. I like mine with cool feeling so that means dimmer.
Fingerprints - Reduced greatly.
I'll update with images.
The Ultra Fine sound amazing for stylus/art use; But how lacking is the visual quality of watching movies on netflix and such? I heard the brightness/sharpness is slightly degraded. I was wondering if you'd even notice after maxing out the the brightness? I don't normally do screens but this tablet is so awesome. Want to keep it that way.
So... screen protectors... are they actually any use?
Do they protect from scratches? Or do they just make your device harder to use because the screen loses sensitivity?
I'd be interested in people's opinions
I recommend using screen protectors because
- they prevent the glass from getting scratches. Sand scratches glass easily. Screen protector helps.
- they can reduce glare from screen. Glare is the reflection you see on the screen that makes it much harder to see what's on screen.
- they can be cleaned with lesser care... any slight wet cloth can clean screen
- they don't cause any loss of sensitivity
- you can start using the plastic nib for the spen as it lasts much longer than rubber nibs. And having a screen protector gives a much better experience with plastic tips for spen.
- they are damn cheap. Don't like them... no problem.. throw them
Sent from my GT-N8013 using Tapatalk
I went all out & picked up an Invisishield at BB. Yes, it was about $30.00 (-minus 20% for Rewards club event) but is was worth it in my mind & I will be doind the same with my Nexus 10. I really like the frogz type protectors, but the Invishield is really starting to grow on me as they are nearly impossible to damage. I have had it gouged to hell & in a warm environment after a few hours it always "heals itself". It is a bit tacky feeling (tacky sticky, not tacky cheap), so it is a bit hard or weird to get used to at first, but then you learn to touch lightly & all is well. Like stated above, the plastic S-Pen tip is MUCH better for use with screen savers, especially this type, but the device works just as well with the S-Pen without any loss of sensitivity.
smrsxn said:
I recommend using screen protectors because
- they prevent the glass from getting scratches. Sand scratches glass easily. Screen protector helps.
- they can reduce glare from screen. Glare is the reflection you see on the screen that makes it much harder to see what's on screen.
- they can be cleaned with lesser care... any slight wet cloth can clean screen
- they don't cause any loss of sensitivity
- you can start using the plastic nib for the spen as it lasts much longer than rubber nibs. And having a screen protector gives a much better experience with plastic tips for spen.
- they are damn cheap. Don't like them... no problem.. throw them
Sent from my GT-N8013 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't use a screen protector and frankly I don't see the need to.
The only advantage I see is the reduction in glare and even that depends on which screen protector you bought.
They DO cause a reduction in sensitivity, I have used a couple before on other devices (like my Note Phablet) and have thrown them all away.
A microfiber cloth cleans easily, and I use the plastic nib SPen HEAVILY and there are no scratches.
If you are paranoid though, then by all means. There are pretty cheap ones available
I always install a screen protector because it cuts down on finger prints. Last 3 have been Ghost Armour. They don't drag on your finger/S-Pen like the invisible shield or feel spongy. Also, clear like glass. And lifetime warranty.
All my gadgets have screen protectors. Better safe than sorry. Have protector on my note as well and no difference on using stylus at all. Smooth and write the same as without screen protector. I have anti glare kind and so easy to take care of finger prints as well. Overall I would highly recommend to get one.
Sent from my GT-N8013 using xda premium
There is a thread somewhere in here where the s pen is scratching the screen.
That made me buy one.
I always, always use screen protectors. Better sure than sorry right?
hamacting said:
So... screen protectors... are they actually any use?
Do they protect from scratches? Or do they just make your device harder to use because the screen loses sensitivity?
I'd be interested in people's opinions
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So... Stupid questions... Are they actually any use?
There are about 1.000 similar questions in all mobile threads. So what do you think? Will a protective transparent cover protect your screen? What do you think? Please make an quess.
Sorry my friend for my reply but I tried to stop myself without any success.
Thank you for the intelligent replies to this thread.
It's good to see that lots of you find that they don't cause problems in using them; the last time I bought one I found that it did cause a loss of accuracy on the device I was using - but that was a few years ago and I am sure that the technology will have moved on.
regards,
/alan
Review for Carbon Fibre
Hi, I am getting a note 10.1 and want a carbon fibre blue ghost armour for it, would it affect the accuracy or will it scrape of what , thanks in advance!!!
The anti glare ones really degrade the screen vibrancy.
Sent using Tapatalk2 from my Note 10.1; the choice of Royalty
I recently applied the MinGuard Anti-Glare screen protector and my default stylus is acting strange. Don't know if it's the protector or the stylus. After installing the protector, I immediately changed to the white nib which glides better than the one.
But when clicking on buttons(not swiping) using the stylus, the tablet does not react sometimes. Takes several tries to successfully click on a button. It doesn't matter how hard I press, the angle in which I press, or how long I press. Now, when I use my finger to click on a button, it works as it should.
For instance, when I bring up the Task Manager and click with the stylus between Ram Manager and Active Appllications" the tablet does not react many times. Or even if I try to click the "X" to close the Task Manager, it takes many times to close. Or if I click the buttons in Snote to change my pen tip, it takes many times to bring it up. This issue doesn't occur all buttons.... I can click on the system buttons in the lower left no problem or app buttons.
Do you guys think the screen protector is the culprit? Or bad stylus? Thanks so much.
I THINK I found the issue. It was the magnets in my book cover. When I position the flap(which contains the magnets) out of the way, it works much better...but not perfect. so I think the protector takes away from stylus sensitivity a bit. Magnets effecting the stylus was discussed in this thread: S-Pen Inaccurate
I recieved this one yesterday that I got from Amazon:
amFilm (TM) Premium Screen Protector Film Clear (Invisible) for Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 (10.1-Inch) and Galaxy Note 10.1 (2-Pack) [in AM retail packing]
It took me both supplied protectors to really apply what I consider almost perfect. I believe there are like 2-3 really small dust particles near the camera but I didn't want to risk ruining my 2nd attempt. I applied it last night. No issues at all with my pen or screen. Mine has the white tip on. I decided on this particular product because it's clear and had great reviews. Glad I chose this one and better safe than sorry for my screen, but to each their own.
i tried to put on a screen protector but then my s-pen didn't flow well !!!
which kind of screen protector do you recommend ?
thanks
cama-cama said:
i tried to put on a screen protector but then my s-pen didn't flow well !!!
which kind of screen protector do you recommend ?
thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
none
cama-cama said:
i tried to put on a screen protector but then my s-pen didn't flow well !!!
which kind of screen protector do you recommend ?
thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi cama-cama. Read my post above yours. I pasted the one I ordered off Amazon. It was easy to apply. I have had NO issues with my pen. I wrote this reply with my pen.
There really is no point in using a screen protector for this tablet. Just get a flip case, don't be stupid with your tablet, and bam, no scratches, ever.
l33t p1mp said:
Sand scratches our screens very easily. Sand is everywhere, and can collect anywhere. It's basically just quartz, and when it sticks to something and rubs the screen, it ruins it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can be guaranteed to see micro scratches after a couple months without a screen protector. Your choice.
For those who have one installed or have tried them, which would be better? And which would work better with the pen input?
I moved from a clear screen to matte protector.
Both work with spen input. No difference for me... maybe an artist can tell u any finer differences.
Picking between matte and clear is your choice... google for pros/cons of each and see which works in your usage scenario.
Sent from my GT-N8013 using Tapatalk
smrsxn said:
I moved from a clear screen to matte protector.
Both work with spen input. No difference for me... maybe an artist can tell u any finer differences.
Picking between matte and clear is your choice... google for pros/cons of each and see which works in your usage scenario.
Sent from my GT-N8013 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh ok, that is good, no difference then. I went with clear, it has always been what I have used, no distortion in picture, it may have a bit more glare but much easier for me and cheaper. I will just change to a plastic tip then.
Im probably posting this too late.. But when you buy a screen protector for the note.. GET A PLASTIC ONE. not the vinyl self healing type . They do cause drag with the S pen .The cheaper ones work best.... I also use matte finish some of the anti fingerprint ones have a bit of a surface thats not perfect slick feels a bit more like paper. Kinda like the surface area of my Wacom Tablet...
erica_renee said:
Im probably posting this too late.. But when you buy a screen protector for the note.. GET A PLASTIC ONE. not the vinyl self healing type . They do cause drag with the S pen .The cheaper ones work best.... I also use matte finish some of the anti fingerprint ones have a bit of a surface thats not perfect slick feels a bit more like paper. Kinda like the surface area of my Wacom Tablet...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree, the plastic Screen protector have most accurately with spen touchs.
erica_renee said:
Im probably posting this too late.. But when you buy a screen protector for the note.. GET A PLASTIC ONE. not the vinyl self healing type . They do cause drag with the S pen .The cheaper ones work best.... I also use matte finish some of the anti fingerprint ones have a bit of a surface thats not perfect slick feels a bit more like paper. Kinda like the surface area of my Wacom Tablet...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yea I got cheap ones, 3 for $5 or so. I would never spend more than that on screen protectors.
erica_renee said:
Im probably posting this too late.. But when you buy a screen protector for the note.. GET A PLASTIC ONE. not the vinyl self healing type . They do cause drag with the S pen .The cheaper ones work best.... I also use matte finish some of the anti fingerprint ones have a bit of a surface thats not perfect slick feels a bit more like paper. Kinda like the surface area of my Wacom Tablet...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Add me to the list of those agree with this.
Can anyone recommend a particularly good matte protector that works well with S-Pen than is reasonably priced?
http://www.amazon.com/Galaxy-Note-10-1-Anti-Glare-Compatible/dp/B008Y6LG8W/ref=pd_sim_pc_15
i used the one from Spigen...the crystal clear on I believe..
http://www.spigen.com/tablets/samsung/galaxy-note-10-1.html
the S pen is smooth as silk on this one.. love it!
iRock48 said:
i used the one from Spigen...the crystal clear on I believe..
http://www.spigen.com/tablets/samsung/galaxy-note-10-1.html
the S pen is smooth as silk on this one.. love it!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have read a lot of good things about the spigen protectors, I just wished they made the tempered glass protectors for the Note 10.1.
.
I am away from using screen protectors for some years now and I never had problems so far with any damages on my scrren with Galaxy S9000, SII, SIII and Tab7 and now NOte 10.1.
Is there any other reason than protecting against scratches ?
LanEvo said:
Yea I got cheap ones, 3 for $5 or so. I would never spend more than that on screen protectors.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which one did you buy? Can you give me the link. I brought a clear one but I don't like the sticky feel of it.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T889 using Tapatalk 2
I got a matte one from eforcity on Ebay and was not impressed. It made the screen really distorted/blurry. I am going to try a clear one now.
Sean09 said:
I got a matte one from eforcity on Ebay and was not impressed. It made the screen really distorted/blurry. I am going to try a clear one now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree with Sean09.... any matte or anti glare screen protector I ever tried made the screen image less sharp.
Halted it.
kkretch said:
I agree with Sean09.... any matte or anti glare screen protector I ever tried made the screen image less sharp.
Halted it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I absolutely agree with that. Problem is that the GNote 10.1 has not the highest resolution and a matte protector will allways make the screen image less sharp. In the case of the GNote 10.1 it makes a huge difference for me. On my HoX with >300 ppi I can barely see the difference.
That is very unfortunate, cause I like the pros of matte screen protectors very much:
-Better touch/slide feeling
-More resistance for S-Pen -> feels more like paper
-Less fingerprints
-No reflections
But, you know, try it out, it's not like the protectors are very expensive...
I posted this on another forum I frequent, but feel its purpose could be better served in this thread.
Any screen protectors like this ArmorSuit MilitaryShield that feature a high gloss, spage-age alien technology with some crazy horse**** composite material that reforms and repairs itself: DO NOT EVER BUY THIS IF YOU WANT TO USE YOUR STYLUS!
The weird material this thing is made of has two properties which immediately prove about as negative as possible:
1. As soon as you put your stylus to the screen, it looks like you've stabbed a hole in the protector or screen itself. Writing just continues that streak and it honestly looks like you're scratching the **** out of your device.
2. If you're able to make it past that initial shock from thinking you've just destroyed your screen, you won't be able to write for long because this protector feels like it's made of super glue designed to bond stylus tips to its surface. Trying to write the title to a powerpoint slide I was transcribing in class ended up giving me about 1/3rd the first letter before jumping, completely skipping the next letter, and then just picking up / leaving off at random so it looked like I was trying to create some alien language.
Also, the ArmorSuit Military Shield shipped with a single screen protector and, not a joke or exaggeration, an instructional video (found on YouTube by the manufacturer) which literally instructs you to cover your hands and screen protector in this liquid found in the packaging; so much of it that you're dripping this **** all over the place while you try to slide the screen into place.
I don't know how the nub tipped styli work, as my stylus has a pen tip so your results could be wildly different.
However, for under $10 ($5 less than the ArmorSuit Shield above) I picked up a MiniGuard by MiniSuit and, silly naming aside, am extremely happy with the purchase.
Its matte finish isn't so apparent that it reduces the visual quality of the screen, yet it does help reduce glare and fingerprints/smudges. It provides a nice surface for the stylus to write without adding resistance while the stylus is pressed to the screen, or friction from a weird material hell-bent on keeping your stylus from writing for longer than .0000001th of a second without skipping.
The MiniGuard came with 3 screen protectors, a microfiber cloth, and a little cardboard card. This card is kind of small and feels like it could have easily been more useful had it been 1" wider. But, that's a non-issue because my earlier purchase did leave me with a way better air bubble pusher card.
I'm sure there are other protectors out there that do this job just as well if not better, but, from the two I've recently purchased and tried I figured sharing my experience on this front might help one of you avoid wasting money on something utterly useless.
nickhimself said:
...
However, for under $10 ($5 less than the ArmorSuit Shield above) I picked up a MiniGuard by MiniSuit and, silly naming aside, am extremely happy with the purchase.
...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the advice. You convinced me and I just bought one here (more convenient for European customers).
I already have a matte screen protector (bought cheap) so I know what to expect. Anyway I hope the miniguard will be of better quality and that, with three chances, I'll be able to install it better than the one I already have (with a couple of dust grains I couldn't get rid of).
I have the Armoursuit that nick mentioned, and I agree. The stylus drags on it big time. I have half a mind to just take the damn thing off.
Sent from my GT-N8013 using xda premium
I've been using some cheap, glossy screen protectors from Amazon for a year now and they work great. $8.99 for a 3 pack. Used with the white stylus nib gives a feeling of near stock.
amFilm (TM) Premium Screen Protector Film Clear (Invisible) for Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 (10.1-Inch) and Galaxy Note 10.1 (2-Pack) [in AM retail packing]
Sent from my GT-N8013 using xda app-developers app
Greetings all!
I'm interested in people's opinions and experiences for and against using a screen protector, particularly with regards to my expected usage patterns.
I plan to put my Note 8 in a book-cover style case (ie, a case with a protective cover that can be folded flat behind the case, such as, the official book cover, or this pic of the STM Skinny, for Note 10.1). I'm currently leaning towards the STM Cape (though I'm waiting to hear back from STM regarding several questions, such as confirmation that the case will indeed fold flat against the back). With most of these kinds of cases there is a soft type of inner lining that is intended to protect the device screen. And, if you fold the cover behind the back of the device you must be careful about where you lay the device as the soft inner lining can pick up dust, debris, etc. and then transmit those potentially abrasive items to the screen. As a side note, if anyone has come across a book style case that somehow avoids this problem I would be interested to hear about it!
I go back and forth about whether to bother with a screen protector or not. I am glad to know that there are good options if I do go with a screen protector (eg, the MiniGuard Screen Protector), but I do sometimes write with a heavy hand which I've read doesn't always work well with screen protectors (ie, it sounds like the protector can be a little spongy such that you can end up inadvertently digging into the screen protector a little, or at least experiencing an increased resistance).
But a part of me thinks that if I'm going to be trying to be careful about the surfaces I lay the opened Note on anyway (wherein the soft inner lining is being exposed to the table surface, etc.), then am I really gaining much/anything by adding a screen protector to the mix? To put it another way: Just because I add a screen protector, I'm not therefore going to be less careful about where I place the Note 8 because I'm still going to want to avoid the soft inner lining picking up debris.
And of course the case itself should protect the Note 8 while in transport (especially a case like the STM Cape which should be very secure at staying closed).
I guess an implied question with all this is just how vulnerable is the screen on the Note 8? And how important is a screen protector when you're already using a case?
Obviously this is a personal decision that I have to come to for myself, but I am interested in people's thoughts on the above from any who wish to share based on the experience and perceptions.
Thanks!
I get it for all my devices and I typically purchase the wet apply self healing skins/screen protectors. I like the texture of the skin and it typically doesn't get damaged regardless of what I clean my device with.
A word of warning, the S-Pen kinda "warps" the skin more than usual. It tends to have a tangerine or orange like texture more than usual.
Sent from my GT-N5110 using XDA Premium HD app
I used to get screen protectors for my phones and tablets. Then I realized, my phones are often in my pockets, sometimes with my keys, etc. So there is an actual risk of scratching. My tablets, however, are generally in some kind of case with a cover and the only time the screen is "exposed" is when I'm using it...and I don't have adamantium claws or anything, so the risk of scratching the screen is nearly non-existent for me. So I don't waste the money anymore. With regards to the Note lineup, I'm not sure how well the S-Pen works through a screen protector either...
So I wouldn't say I am "against" them as much as I don't really see a need...
The screen protector doesn't affect the s pen accuracy (at least I don't notice any difference)
I usually apply one of the anti-glare types to protect against stupid things (like if it the case flap opens and it hits something in my backpack) and also so make the screen a little less shiny (my office lights are annoying on reflective surfaces)
Most high end tablets and phones have gorilla glass or other hardened glass which is pretty scratch resistant but i still feel better throwing a layer of plastic on...
Bonisaur said:
I get it for all my devices and I typically purchase the wet apply self healing skins/screen protectors. I like the texture of the skin and it typically doesn't get damaged regardless of what I clean my device with.
A word of warning, the S-Pen kinda "warps" the skin more than usual. It tends to have a tangerine or orange like texture more than usual.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for sharing details about the type of screen protector you use (including texture, etc.), as well as the S-Pen interaction. When you say "warps" do you mean that the skin of the screen protector is a little spongy and so it gives a little under the pressure of the S-Pen? Does that bother you, and how does it feel for writing, drawing, etc. then?
ExploreMN said:
My tablets, however, are generally in some kind of case with a cover and the only time the screen is "exposed" is when I'm using it...
So I wouldn't say I am "against" them as much as I don't really see a need...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I appreciate knowing that you approach your tablets that way and that things have worked well for you (ie, no screen catastrophes due to lack of screen protector). And I like your distinction between phones vs tablets regarding the potentially different sources of trauma they can be subjected to (adamantium claws notwithstanding ).
kisaten said:
The screen protector doesn't affect the s pen accuracy (at least I don't notice any difference).
I usually apply one of the anti-glare types...
Most high end tablets and phones have gorilla glass or other hardened glass which is pretty scratch resistant but i still feel better throwing a layer of plastic on...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the comment regarding S-Pen accuracy and for sharing your preferred screen protector type (eg, anti-glare). I also appreciate hearing your assessment of the glass in high end devices tending to be fairly durable (regardless of whether it is officially gorilla glass). Anti-glare is one of the things I have been considering. Does the anti-glare protector "dim" or "dull" the screen vibrancy (ie, colors, brightness, etc.) to a degree that bothers you?
Thanks for the great contributions thus far folks! These are exactly the kinds of comments, observations, etc. I was hoping for!
pluginalong said:
Thanks for the comment regarding S-Pen accuracy and for sharing your preferred screen protector type (eg, anti-glare). I also appreciate hearing your assessment of the glass in high end devices tending to be fairly durable (regardless of whether it is officially gorilla glass). Anti-glare is one of the things I have been considering. Does the anti-glare protector "dim" or "dull" the screen vibrancy (ie, colors, brightness, etc.) to a degree that bothers you?
Thanks for the great contributions thus far folks! These are exactly the kinds of comments, observations, etc. I was hoping for!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've used "gloss antiglare" and "matte antiglare" ones --I live in Japan and there are a tons of different screen protectors. I found that with the Elecom branded ones, the gloss "anti-glare" wasn't really anti glare (still looked reflective), but the Matte ones are pretty good (very little reflection).
The Matte protectors take a little getting used to (as you'd expect glass to look shiny and suddenly it looks a little dull. <- It doesnt dull the vibrancy of the colors or brightness, it just looks like a different texture like printing a photo on regular paper vs glossy paper.)
I enjoy having it because it kills the reflection of my office lights which was the main purpose for me to buy it.
The s-pen interactions feel the same regardless of matte or gloss (very smooth <- I have the s-pen with the eraser and changable tips and both the rubber and hard tips feel fine)
I would imagine that with a wet apply (self healing) skin, the texture would change the s-pen experience (i have a wet apply protector on my NDS and the stylus feels different on it because it has some grip and texture <- Hover would be the same but once you touch the screen perhaps it wouldnt be as smooth <- Bonisaur, care to weight in?
If you are asking the question, its on your mind. So you might as well just put a protector on, and give yourself peace of mind.
Plenty of reports on various devices of even Gorilla Glass getting scratched from what the owners swear as "normal usage". So don't take for granted that GG or other treated glasses won't scratch.
I'll agree that tablets are usually not exposed to the same use and abuse as a phone. But on the HTC Flyer tablet, the pen alone was enough to scratch the screen. Yes, that device is 2 years old at this point. But certainly a "high end" device for its time. With the screen getting scratched from the pen that was intended to be used with it.
It largely comes down to personal preference. There are plenty that don't use a screen protector on tablets or phones. I don't question that choice at all, I can certainly understand the reasoning (better feel, mostly). But the fact of the matter is, that once you do scratch the screen, there is really not going back, and it can't really be undone. So if you choose to go without a protector, you better be prepared to live with the consequences, if the screen does get scratched. There are inevitable post by folks that regret not using a protector (even on devices with Gorilla Glass) after getting the screen scratched up.
pluginalong said:
Thanks for sharing details about the type of screen protector you use (including texture, etc.), as well as the S-Pen interaction. When you say "warps" do you mean that the skin of the screen protector is a little spongy and so it gives a little under the pressure of the S-Pen? Does that bother you, and how does it feel for writing, drawing, etc. then?
Thanks for the great contributions thus far folks! These are exactly the kinds of comments, observations, etc. I was hoping for!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No problem! It has a slightly higher amount of push-pull to it. If you have a skin on any other device, I suggest you try "writing" over it. It has never once bothered me while I've taken notes for lecture or drew on Sketchbook. I can still use the S-Pen with pressure accuracy and without any hiccups. I.e. if I want to draw a straight line, it will be a straight line. When you hold the device at an angle though, you can see where the line is. It disappears over time as you just continue to draw over the skin or it just naturally heals. Like I said though, it has a very slight "tangerine" texture that is only visible if tilted at a certain angle or if there is a very intense glare. I only noticed it after reading a few reviews from Amazon.
kisaten said:
I've used "gloss antiglare" and "matte antiglare" ones --I live in Japan and there are a tons of different screen protectors. I found that with the Elecom branded ones, the gloss "anti-glare" wasn't really anti glare (still looked reflective), but the Matte ones are pretty good (very little reflection).
The Matte protectors take a little getting used to (as you'd expect glass to look shiny and suddenly it looks a little dull. <- It doesnt dull the vibrancy of the colors or brightness, it just looks like a different texture like printing a photo on regular paper vs glossy paper.)
I enjoy having it because it kills the reflection of my office lights which was the main purpose for me to buy it.
The s-pen interactions feel the same regardless of matte or gloss (very smooth <- I have the s-pen with the eraser and changable tips and both the rubber and hard tips feel fine)
I would imagine that with a wet apply (self healing) skin, the texture would change the s-pen experience (i have a wet apply protector on my NDS and the stylus feels different on it because it has some grip and texture <- Hover would be the same but once you touch the screen perhaps it wouldnt be as smooth <- Bonisaur, care to weight in?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for all that very helpful info!
redpoint73 said:
If you are asking the question, its on your mind. So you might as well just put a protector on, and give yourself peace of mind.
Plenty of reports on various devices of even Gorilla Glass getting scratched from what the owners swear as "normal usage". So don't take for granted that GG or other treated glasses won't scratch.
I'll agree that tablets are usually not exposed to the same use and abuse as a phone. But on the HTC Flyer tablet, the pen alone was enough to scratch the screen. Yes, that device is 2 years old at this point. But certainly a "high end" device for its time. With the screen getting scratched from the pen that was intended to be used with it.
It largely comes down to personal preference. There are plenty that don't use a screen protector on tablets or phones. I don't question that choice at all, I can certainly understand the reasoning (better feel, mostly). But the fact of the matter is, that once you do scratch the screen, there is really not going back, and it can't really be undone. So if you choose to go without a protector, you better be prepared to live with the consequences, if the screen does get scratched. There are inevitable post by folks that regret not using a protector (even on devices with Gorilla Glass) after getting the screen scratched up.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Very good points! And that is scary stuff regarding the HTC Flyer--I had not heard about that!
Bonisaur said:
No problem! It has a slightly higher amount of push-pull to it. If you have a skin on any other device, I suggest you try "writing" over it. It has never once bothered me while I've taken notes for lecture or drew on Sketchbook. I can still use the S-Pen with pressure accuracy and without any hiccups. I.e. if I want to draw a straight line, it will be a straight line. When you hold the device at an angle though, you can see where the line is. It disappears over time as you just continue to draw over the skin or it just naturally heals. Like I said though, it has a very slight "tangerine" texture that is only visible if tilted at a certain angle or if there is a very intense glare. I only noticed it after reading a few reviews from Amazon.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks--that is very helpful! I'm thinking then that for my preferences I'll probably lean more towards a dry apply (like the MiniGuard that's been reviewed here).
I'm using a cheap anti-glare matte screen protector from eBay with my Note 8. It doesn't affect the S Pen sensitivity the slightest and in fact makes it feel more like writing on paper. As a matte screen lover I have no complaints with it.