I have a 32GB black Nexus 5 ordered and waiting for it. A lot of you have already seemed to ordered/received screen protectors and cases for the Nexus 5 and I was just wondering is a screen protector and/or a case necessary? Is the Nexus 5 likely to be damaged without a case?
If a screen protector is required, what's the difference between a plastic protector, such as from XtremeGuard, or a 'tempered glass' one from Spigen?
Thanks for any help provided.
HiddenAdmiral said:
I have a 32GB black Nexus 5 ordered and waiting for it. A lot of you have already seemed to ordered/received screen protectors and cases for the Nexus 5 and I was just wondering is a screen protector and/or a case necessary? Is the Nexus 5 likely to be damaged without a case?
If a screen protector is required, what's the difference between a plastic protector, such as from XtremeGuard, or a 'tempered glass' one from Spigen?
Thanks for any help provided.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can expect wear and tear on any device. How much occurs depends on what you do to protect it and how careful you are with it. Personally, I hate cases but now that I'm no longer with sprint and use off contract phones I like to protect the resale value of my phone and keep it in mint condition.
As for the tempered glass screen protectors, I have no experience with them. I try to stay away from things that break, such as glass.
adrian089 said:
You can expect wear and tear on any device. How much occurs depends on what you do to protect it and how careful you are with it. Personally, I hate cases but now that I'm no longer with sprint and use off contract phones I like to protect the resale value of my phone and keep it in mint condition.
As for the tempered glass screen protectors, I have no experience with them. I try to stay away from things that break, such as glass.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wholeheartedly agree with this statement. I've always kept a case and screen protector on my phones. Reselling these phones when you're ready to upgrade goes much smoother when your phone is in mint condition, with absolutely no wear and tear on it. If someone is going to buy it from you and hand over $200+ in cash, it makes them feel better when the phone looks 2 weeks old rather than over a year old.
The only fear I have is denim stains on the white one. I always keep my phone case-less as I never drop my phone ever. I'm thinking about a case just to prevent denim stains. I got denim stains on my HTC One I'm using now and got them off by using a magic eraser, but I don't want to have to do that every month. Hopefully it's just a HTC problem
Sent from my HTC One using xda app-developers app
I get the importance of maintaining the phone in good condition, but doesn't putting a case on ruin the aesthetic appeal of the phone and a screen protector reduce the clarity and brightness of the screen? And doesn't a case also make the phone bulkier and heavier?
If so, you all believe this comes secondary to maintaining your phone in good condition?
To me it just depends. If you are capable and willing to fork out the money to replace a broken screen in the unfortunate case that you drop and crack it, then don't use a case. If you aren't, then use a case
HiddenAdmiral said:
I get the importance of maintaining the phone in good condition, but doesn't putting a case on ruin the aesthetic appeal of the phone and a screen protector reduce the clarity and brightness of the screen? And doesn't a case also make the phone bulkier and heavier?
If so, you all believe this comes secondary to maintaining your phone in good condition?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
While it does lower the overall aesthetic appeal of the phone, I only buy cases that I feel are pleasing enough to the eye. The added bulk isn't usually a concern for me. I also only buy clear screen protectors, so the clarity of the screen isn't affected (to my eyes at least). It does negate most anti-glare features if a phone has them, but again, I've never personally noticed it in the past.
I consider cases and screen protectors a one-time insurance plan purchase for my phone. In 6 years of owning differend smartphones, I've only ever dropped my phone 2 times, and the cases saved both phones. To me, that is a higher priority than the incredibly minor (IMO) aesthetic "hit" that the case provides.
To each their own, though.
HiddenAdmiral said:
I get the importance of maintaining the phone in good condition, but doesn't putting a case on ruin the aesthetic appeal of the phone and a screen protector reduce the clarity and brightness of the screen? And doesn't a case also make the phone bulkier and heavier?
If so, you all believe this comes secondary to maintaining your phone in good condition?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Google play store is selling some pretty nice looking cases with nexus on the back like on the phone itself. As for screen protectors, I don't notice them unless you don't do the best job putting one on and get a ton of bubbles.
Here's a tip for putting on screen protectors if you're like me and you suck at it. Get them to do it at a cell phone store lol.
HiddenAdmiral said:
I get the importance of maintaining the phone in good condition, but doesn't putting a case on ruin the aesthetic appeal of the phone and a screen protector reduce the clarity and brightness of the screen? And doesn't a case also make the phone bulkier and heavier?
If so, you all believe this comes secondary to maintaining your phone in good condition?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can always go with a Bumper Case if you want to maintain the "aesthetic appeal" of the case:
http://www.amazon.com/i-Blason-Goog...qid=1383319857&sr=8-2&keywords=nexus+5+bumper
With screen protectors, there are many, many types available.. some will reduce the clarity/brightness, you just have to choose what best fits for you (especially going universal where you cut your own out).
I agree with the other statements, though. I always use a case on my phones, regardless how I feel about its beauty. My current HTC One, which is an awesome looking device, resides in its case
Might I recommend Poetic Borderline bumper! I had one on my Nexus 4 last year and my brother has one for his iPhone. Very nice, very protective, and stills shows off the nice back.
Necessary? No... But neither is dropping a phone or any other accidental damage.
It's better to spend $30 and be protected than not at all.
tkoreaper said:
Necessary? No... But neither is dropping a phone or any other accidental damage.
It's better to spend $30 and be protected than not at all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Depends on the person really. I myself personally use cases to have a better grip to the phone to prevent accidental drops rather than the protection. I haven't dropped my Galaxy Nexus or Nexus 4 in the time that I've used them.
The protection is always nice as well, as long as it isn't too bulky and offers the minimal protection to the point where nothing would get cracked. At least thats how I see it. Theres a lot of high quality cases that are $10-$20 as well.
Struggling with this myself. I always grab a black Diztronic but the official Google cases tempt me and the actual design of the 5 seems more resilient than in past years.
bmstrong said:
Struggling with this myself. I always grab a black Diztronic but the official Google cases tempt me and the actual design of the 5 seems more resilient than in past years.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 on that.. the back of the phone itself seem very grippy. I'm telling myself whether or not to buy a case or just use the phone naked since I am a pretty careful person. I'll probably just get the phone when it gets here and try it for a day or two and if I'm not satisfied then I'll buy a case. Maybe get a slim case just incase.
zephiK said:
+1 on that.. the back of the phone itself seem very grippy. I'm telling myself whether or not to buy a case or just use the phone naked since I am a pretty careful person. I'll probably just get the phone when it gets here and try it for a day or two and if I'm not satisfied then I'll buy a case. Maybe get a slim case just incase.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I guess the best thing would be to go into the N7 2013 forums and look at how those have held up. Since they share a similar design language and materials, I'm hoping it translates into the smaller package. Plus, they used Ceramic buttons as well. (My Lumia 920 buttons have held up incredibly over then last year.)
no case or screen protector
HiddenAdmiral said:
I get the importance of maintaining the phone in good condition, but doesn't putting a case on ruin the aesthetic appeal of the phone and a screen protector reduce the clarity and brightness of the screen? And doesn't a case also make the phone bulkier and heavier?
If so, you all believe this comes secondary to maintaining your phone in good condition?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Get one of the anti gravity cases, actually makes it lighter.
I'll spray my screen with Thompsons water seal.
I usually go naked, but I'll use a case for the N5 because the camera sticks out a bit.
trsix said:
Get one of the anti gravity cases, actually makes it lighter.
I'll spray my screen with Thompsons water seal.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And with Thompson's you can really get that special shine
Oops, now for some on topic. I am using a moto x naked in all its glory and plan on selling it to recoup m n5 costs and its something you case and protector folks miss out on. The gains far outweigh the risks in my opinion. I also had my launch day n4 naked about 90% of the time and the wife now has it and goes naked too Don't rob yourself of the true experience, I used to always have a case and protector on but not anymore :good:
raiderep said:
And with Thompson's you can really get that special shine
Oops, now for some on topic. I am using a moto x naked in all its glory and plan on selling it to recoup m n5 costs and its something you case and protector folks miss out on. The gains far outweigh the risks in my opinion. I also had my launch day n4 naked about 90% of the time and the wife now has it and goes naked too Don't rob yourself of the true experience, I used to always have a case and protector on but not anymore :good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree. I'm extra careful with my phone. I've had screen protectors, which have all been taken off. I bought the Spigen case (clear back) and hated it. It would stick to the back of the N4, which made it look like it had liquid between the two. I ended up just sticking with the bumper from Google. It's really all the protection I need, and it really looks classy. I wish they'd make a bumper of the same form for the N5.
Some people just take the philosophy of being careful and go without a case or screen protector, while others take precautions through cases and screen protectors. You could be a very careful person and still end up dropping your phone by accident, or you could have a case plus a screen protector and never drop it anyway.
There is no "right answer", every person has to decide for themselves depending on how they weigh the pluses and minuses.
Related
Just wondering because I stopped using them with the Captivate. I did get a RealLook when this phone was new but have since dumped it. I have carried the phone in my pocket with coins and even keys at times and nary a scratch. The glass is far better to slide on in its native state.
I never used cases because they made the phone thick and skins only protect against scratches which for a device I may have all of 18 months doesn't matter much. Its a handset not a work of art. LOL One of the features I like best is how thin the handset is and how slick the glass is in it's native state.....
The back case is nearly indestructible and easily replaceable.
So who else doesn't go for the $20 "screen protectors" and $20 cases? The only case I would think would protect a phone in a drop would be a very soft shock absorbing one that doesn't transfer the shck to the device anyway which collects crap and makes it difficult to get out of ones pocket.
As far as resale goes I found I may get $25-$50 less for a phone with wear marks. Less Money that would have been spent on "protective devices anyway...I sold a NEW in the box Captivate for $229 and a used one for $190 with wear...(and am currently looking for a beat up working Captivate for a spare.)
There are a lot of people who doesn't use a 20 US$ case or protective screen. But IMO, that's a bad idea. That screen could get scratched and it also could get damaged if you drop it. All depends on how you care the device. I think it's better to have a protective screen than having a scratch on it.
I care about myself and not on the 'bare' list. Have a protective screen and a CM Tough.
Regards.
ithehappy said:
There are a lot of people who doesn't use a 20 US$ case or protective screen. But IMO, that's a bad idea. That screen could get scratched and it also could get damaged if you drop it. All depends on how you care the device. I think it's better to have a protective screen than having a scratch on it.
I care about myself and not on the 'bare' list. Have a protective screen and a CM Tough.
Regards.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here. Why would I risk a 600$ device for a few bucks?
I don't care if my case make my phone thicker, I'll use a 3200mA battery anway.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA Premium App
I've never used cases on phones but have ordered a Neo Hybrid today, should be with me by the end of the week...
Dropped the current bane of my existence a number of times, perils of being a biker...
Phone is Wednesday so I'll have a couple days with it bare, I'm optimistic that I'll be converted to a case user... The Neo looks great and before I got lumbered with the BB I was using a Desire so I'm used to that thickness anyway...
OK the question was for those WHO DO NOT use a case...I am well aware of the minions who are anal about scratches and dings or the worrisome drop now and then..
I just wanted to see how many do not use either and just use their handsets as they were designed. I understand completely why those who do buy cases and "screen protectors" do so. I also understand the fear factor used in selling "various highly technological" pieces of clear plastic for $10 for the Gorilla glass.
I actually tried to scratch my glass with a key and could not while a friend watched in horror. LOL "Scratch resistant" is an understatement for Corning's glass. A small scratch would not bother me if it did happen though. But I do know it would take a lot to do so.
I don't really like cases and screen protector. I did not use a case or screen protector for my sgs1 and its always kept in my pocket. After 5 months it got a small scratch on screen and around the casing. I sold it for £180 when I got GS2. I was not planning to get a case for it but after a week scratches on the back appear just from putting on top of the desk and moving it around. I had to buy a case for it which im not really satisfied. I recently bought another case barely there chrome but sent it back coz it looks cheap.
I would prefer no case if only sammy put a different finish on the back. I don't think gs2 will need screen protector as it is glass. it won't get scratch(i hope). If it drops and break. I'll just claim it on the insurance to get it sorted.
I like to feel the phone and how light and thin it is.
But when I'm not using it I have a Mofi case + a DIY Aluminium case to protect it.
+ I'm always very careful with my equipment.
I have dropped my phones (yes, in all of my phones in the past 4 years) a grand total of 2 or 3 times. I take very good care of my phones, but I always at least have a thin case. But one thing that I'll never do is go without a screen protector. If the back or sides scratch, oh well. Value dropped. But if the screen gets scratch, that would bother me until I get a new phone. It ruins the image. So when I'm about to get a new phone, I order off e-cell those cheapo screen protectors that work VERY well, which I never change because they do a very good job! They usually take about 4-5 days to arrive (from the UK to here in Spain). I like those screen protectors, too. Hehe.
I don't use a screen protector or a case. Had the phone about 3 months now, have developed some very light scratches on the screen which you can only see with the display off. I think they're in the oleophobic layer on the outside of the glass and not the screen itself.
Why? Because I can't stand the way a plastic screen protector feels, my finger drags across them and the image is always blurry.
Hello,
after more than 2 Years with the IPhone 4 I'll become next week the HTC One Black Vodafone Germany.
Please be so kindly and give me some urgent handling recommendations...do I need a display protection, any cases or whatever....?
Many thanks.....
speedmaster.nl said:
Hello,
after more than 2 Years with the IPhone 4 I'll become next week the HTC One Black Vodafone Germany.
Please be so kindly and give me some urgent handling recommendations...do I need a display protection, any cases or whatever....?
Many thanks.....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It depends on how careful you are with your phone, but I would definitely recommend a case and screen protector to avoid getting scratches, if nothing else.
tyler.durden said:
It depends on how careful you are with your phone, but I would definitely recommend a case and screen protector to avoid getting scratches, if nothing else.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm very careful but I agree with you for a screen protector and a case, any recommendation for the case, I saw the origin HTC bi color case but some people said it makes scratches....!?!
speedmaster.nl said:
I'm very careful but I agree with you for a screen protector and a case, any recommendation for the case, I saw the origin HTC bi color case but some people said it makes scratches....!?!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That depends on how much protection you want and if you mind covering up the back of the phone (it's nicer than most phones so some people rather not).
http://www.basalent.com/htc-one-2013-m7-hybri-flex-crystal-clear-pctpu-case-white.html
That's the one I have, and I like it a lot. Protects the sides and the back, without covering the aluminum body.
sohungry said:
That depends on how much protection you want and if you mind covering up the back of the phone (it's nicer than most phones so some people rather not).
http://www.basalent.com/htc-one-2013-m7-hybri-flex-crystal-clear-pctpu-case-white.html
That's the one I have, and I like it a lot. Protects the sides and the back, without covering the aluminum body.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I never have much issue with screen scratches (usually) but I'd still err on the side of caution and do at the very least a screen protector. I'm going to replace my ZAGG (which I'm hoping is just scratched and not a crack on the screen ) with one of those fancy shmancy glass screen protectors with the rounded edges.
felacio said:
I never have much issue with screen scratches (usually) but I'd still err on the side of caution and do at the very least a screen protector. I'm going to replace my ZAGG (which I'm hoping is just scratched and not a crack on the screen ) with one of those fancy shmancy glass screen protectors with the rounded edges.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ha ha, I have one of those fancy shmancy glass screen protectors. It feels nice and looks nice, but there are bubbles in the corners
TPU skin is good enough if you have good reflexes.
While it is falling, you'll probably break its fall by hitting it up. Plus you can find absolutely clear TPU skins.
A case is a must, screen protector is not.
What I do is whenever I get a brand new phone, I always start with a good protective case and a screen protector. After a few months, I gradually get thinner cases and usually end up with those 0.3-0.5mm thin cases that makes the phone feel nice and less bulky. If you plan to rock the phone naked, I'd recommend a phone pouch.
Sent from the "ONE" phone for me
Thank you very much for the quick response I'm still searching for a good frame or case, is it true that the origin HTC bi color case leaves scratches on the phone I won't believe it .....?! I also hope that the black version is scratch resistant some people said not......I just talked with a Vodafone assistant to change the black against the silver but he said to me that himself have the black one and I looks quite better and after two month usage without any case he have no scratches. I'll take the black one, it comes next week and I will give you a first impression.
Can't await
sauprankul said:
A case is a must...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
WHY?
ro_explorer said:
WHY?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its not REALLY a must IMO. The phone actually holds up very well. Yesterday i purposefully put the phone in the same pocket with a bunch of coins and it scratched the aluminum but the scratches wiped right off. If you drop things than that would be a different story at aluminum can easily dent :good:
That was my point also ... it looks a little exaggerated to say that a case is a must.
I intend to use the phone "naked" indoors. Any case will practically ruin the nice feeling of the phone itself. Of course, if you drop it then there are chances to ruin the nice finish.
I'm also using the phone outdoors, fr sports. For that purpose I ordered a trident kraken ams ... I hope it will do the job.
P.S.: I saw that a OEM housing is "only" 50 bucks, free shipping ... I guess I'll buy one just in case .
I would say that if you carry your phone in your pocket a case is a must. I generally like to go case-less (especially with a phone this pretty), but after having my One slip out of my pocket on a couple of occasions, I ended up getting a case (Poetic Atmosphere; the rubberized edges keep it from slipping out). If you intend on getting a pouch of some sort, I think case-free is fine.
Also, I don't have a screen protector and have no scratches, though I tend to be pretty gentle with my phones.
ro_explorer said:
That was my point also ... it looks a little exaggerated to say that a case is a must.
I intend to use the phone "naked" indoors. Any case will practically ruin the nice feeling of the phone itself. Of course, if you drop it then there are chances to ruin the nice finish.
I'm also using the phone outdoors, fr sports. For that purpose I ordered a trident kraken ams ... I hope it will do the job.
P.S.: I saw that a OEM housing is "only" 50 bucks, free shipping ... I guess I'll buy one just in case .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On Etradesupply, the OEM housing is only like 30 bucks.
I say a TPU case is a must because:
1) You WILL drop it at some point, it's anodized AL, not grippy plastic.
2) The case provides a lip, so if you put your phone face down, the screen won't touch the surface & scratch from w/e dirt is there.
3) The case will also keep the camera lens (or the anodized back) from touching any surfaces.
4) I wear a ring, and if I don't put a case on, the ring scratches ONTO the phone. That's not good.
If you're REALLY careful, then none of these matter. but it's hard to be perfect.
Besides, when I'm in bed, I can just quickly remove the case for a little bit. It feels nice.
This phone is just too good looking to cover up, IMO. I've been going naked since day one I don't have a single scratch on it. The aluminum housing is solid and whatever glass HTC used really resists scratching. My One X screen got covered in microscratches pretty quickly, but I haven't seen anything on this phone.
Just treat it with care and you can forget the case. CNET tried to destroy their test phone and couldn't do it.
I have a double dip case bought at once with the phone. Well .. the feeling simply does not compare with the case on. It just loos cheap and plastic'ish ... is worse than galaxy S4 actually. So, with all the risks involved I will go "naked" while in normal use and I will use the kraken ams for outdoors. That's all ...
I only like corner protection. I don't care about the back.
I used to have a screen protector on this but I don't like it, it doesn't make the display look as nice. I have since taken it off and have not gotten any scratches, not even micro ones. I think this display is more tough than previous GG2 screens. I had the ONE X+ and it scratched easily.
Get one of these: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2365102
After 8 hours....
....I'm going crazy with the phone, the App Store is horrible I found nothing what I need, i looking for the 8player and found many sites but not in the App Store, can't connect my iPhone via Bluetooth to import my contacts, also with the ipad...
The phone looks and feels awesome that's for sure but android is horrible, don't know what I should do.....please be so kind and give me recommendations, I won't give it back for the iPhone 5.......so I don't know what I should do!?!?!
speedmaster.nl said:
....I'm going crazy with the phone, the App Store is horrible I found nothing what I need, i looking for the 8player and found many sites but not in the App Store, can't connect my iPhone via Bluetooth to import my contacts, also with the ipad...
The phone looks and feels awesome that's for sure but android is horrible, don't know what I should do.....please be so kind and give me recommendations, I won't give it back for the iPhone 5.......so I don't know what I should do!?!?!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I respectfully disagree, as will most in this forum that Android is horrible.
Maybe you can post what apps you are looking for and other users can tell you if there are equivalent apps.
mfpreach said:
I respectfully disagree, as will most in this forum that Android is horrible.
Maybe you can post what apps you are looking for and other users can tell you if there are equivalent apps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hello Senior Member,
Thanks so much for your quick response, ok I'm impatient, I found the first app for my marantz av and the buffalo server which works its the bubbleUPnP and it works with the iPhone equivalent not still searching the for the 8player.
Hello!
Can LG Optimus G get scratched on Gorrila glass and does it requires additional case and screen protector to keep device unharmed (without scratches and visual defects) ?
Thanks!
Yes if use them your phone is protected
Sent from my LG-E975 using Tapatalk
greenmoonLV said:
Can LG Optimus G get scratched on Gorrila glass and does it requires additional case and screen protector to keep device unharmed (without scratches and visual defects) ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The short answer is yes, it can be damaged. Gorilla glass is not a guarantee against scratches -- it sure helps when you put your phone in a pocket with keys, coins and stuff, but a tiny grain of sand can still leave a scratch on it (not saying it necessarily will, but it certainly can). The back cover is relatively easily scratched and scuffed, especially in the corners (I have some visible wear marks on it, but don't have a second camera to take a photo right now). The bezel on this phone can also easily get nicked, as the plastic is pretty soft.
So, I would definitely recommend some protection, if you care about the appearance of your phone. I personally decided against using screen protectors quite a while ago, for number of reasons (I still use it on my tablet, but not on phones), and I just try to be careful with the screen. So far, so good. But a good case for me is a must. It also makes the OG easier and safer to handle, as the naked phone is quite thin and slippery. There is a lot of decent cases available for our phone. You can also take a look in the Accessories forum for some first-hand reviews and comparisons.
kt-Froggy said:
The short answer is yes, it can be damaged. Gorilla glass is not a guarantee against scratches -- it sure helps when you put your phone in a pocket with keys, coins and stuff, but a tiny grain of sand can still leave a scratch on it (not saying it necessarily will, but it certainly can). The back cover is relatively easily scratched and scuffed, especially in the corners (I have some visible wear marks on it, but don't have a second camera to take a photo right now). The bezel on this phone can also easily get nicked, as the plastic is pretty soft.
So, I would definitely recommend some protection, if you care about the appearance of your phone. I personally decided against using screen protectors quite a while ago, for number of reasons (I still use it on my tablet, but not on phones), and I just try to be careful with the screen. So far, so good. But a good case for me is a must. It also makes the OG easier and safer to handle, as the naked phone is quite thin and slippery. There is a lot of decent cases available for our phone. You can also take a look in the Accessories forum for some first-hand reviews and comparisons.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe you can suggest some good/cheap OG case?
greenmoonLV said:
Maybe you can suggest some good/cheap OG case?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As I said, just look around in the Accessories forum -- it's there for a good reason. You will find my review among other people's feedback.
kt-Froggy said:
As I said, just look around in the Accessories forum -- it's there for a good reason. You will find my review among other people's feedback.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you!
Yes still gorilla glass is not fully guaranteed
Yes, I think using a case is needed because a few months ago I didn't have a case, so my phone fell and now it has a broken corner. Now I use a hard silicone case.
I have not bought a case and mine is marked because of falls. I'm not happy with it. Buy a case .
Yes, I am using nikkin case.
I am using case and screen protector for more than 2 years and my phone looks almost like a new one
Didn't see anyone else talking about this on XDA. I though I would post my experience.
****This Product IS AMAZING*****
What is it?
Your touch screen comes with Gorilla Glass, which is great. It has an oleophobic coating on the screen that repels oils from your fingers, from your face. It is great. It also gives the screen that smooth finger sliding lower co-efficient of friction. That new phone screen feeling that I just love when I get a new phone. The problem is that it wears off after some time and you will notice after having the phone for a few months that the screen starts smudging and you start wiping the screen more and more to make it look clean. This drives me crazy and I can honestly admit that I have in the past purchased a new phone just so I could get that "New Screen Feeling". I once even traded in my Galaxy S2 used for a new S2 and spent $100 just to get the "New Screen Feeling".
Am I crazy?
Maybe but I am sure I am not the only one who loves a new screen. I absolutely hate screen protector with a passion, and I have tried multiple different protectors during my smart phone era but none did it for me except the ones that are made from tempered glass, but they suffer from the same fate of the coating wearing off and they are more susceptible to scratching then the stock screen.
So the solution?
This coating can be reapplied for cheap. There are a few different brands that I have come across. I used a brand called Proteger ordered on eBay from Japan. Other brands I have seen are Fusso and Dynaflo LIQUID-ARMOR. It appears that they are all manufactured in Japan. Most bottles are between $15 - $20.
The instructions say to use 10 - 15 drops on the screen. This is not needed and WAY TOO MUCH. You can put 4 - 5 drops on your screen per coat. Best to do 4 coats. This is how I applied it.
- clean first with supplied micro fibre cloth
- 5 drops on screen
- rub with one finger covering the whole screen. I kept rubbing until it was almost completely dry.
- once it is dry the screen is very hazy. Use a clean rag or paper towel to wipe it off. Keep turning the rag to a clean dry spot until all haze is gone.
- repeat 3 more times. It is suggested that you wait 8 hours to allow each coat to cure. I only waited 10 minutes and got great results, but tonight I will allow it 8 hours while I sleep to cure another coat.
Results.
You will notice immediately that the screen feels like new. Even after first coat, but it improves with every coat. The more coats the more slick the screen is.
******Here is the best part*******
I noticed with my Nexus 5 and previous phone that I would always get these micro scratches from regular use. This would drive some people to get screen protectors but I rather micro scratches then a disgusting looking screen protector. I never really got deep scratches or gouges but I would always get micro scratches that you could only see at certain angles. Here is the kicker. After applying the Proteger coating THESE SCRATCHES ARE GONE edit** the ok the scratches are not completely gone but they are much less noticeable. You really have to try to see them now. Obviously this product isn't some sort of magic solution, and the scratches don't disappear. I reckon that it fills the fine scratches kinda like wax on your car. Either way less noticeable is good enough for me.
I even tried it on my crappy beat up Blackberry work phone that has a pretty scratched up screen and all of the scratches are now gone except for 2 deep ones, but even they are less noticeable. AMAZING.
This is a great product and I will recommend it to everyone that I know. The bottle I bought was 10ml and I have done 2 phones and I can't even see the level go down in the bottle, this product should last a long time.
Anyone else use this stuff. Please leave your comments and reviews.
kevjef420 said:
but I rather micro scratches then a disgusting looking screen protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Anker screen protectors I use are completely invisible, provided you apply them correctly. And to me, micro scratches are completely unacceptable for resale value purposes.
But good review, thanks for sharing, and to each their own.
Hmm maybe this would be great when applied on a cheap glass screan protector. A bit pricey, still.
Couldn't you just use RainX?
wolfen69 said:
The Anker screen protectors I use are completely invisible, provided you apply them correctly. And to me, micro scratches are completely unacceptable for resale value purposes.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly my experience. No one believes me when I tell them my phone has a screen protector applied to it. Also they have a very good anti-smudge coating which stops a lot of finger prints and makes the screen very easy to clean. And if you want to have a screen that looks and feels always as new as possible, just stick a new protector on the phone. I got 3 ones from Anker for just 5€. Obviously this only works if you put the screen protector on as soon as you unbox your freshly bought phone. IMO this is the only real way to prevent micro-scratches or any other type of scratches to harm the actual screen. If you want to sell your phone you can take the screen protector off and it looks as new (granted you have been using a case so the rest of your phone isn't scratched etc either)
idbl_fanatic said:
Couldn't you just use RainX?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I haven't personally used RainX, but I have heard some people get good results from it. That said, I still believe a true oleophobic coating is a better idea. I don't know how to feel about the chemical properties of RainX. Maybe I'm just paranoid...
Always wondered if those things actually worked....might get one now. Thanks.
spiderflash said:
Exactly my experience. No one believes me when I tell them my phone has a screen protector applied to it. Also they have a very good anti-smudge coating which stops a lot of finger prints and makes the screen very easy to clean. And if you want to have a screen that looks and feels always as new as possible, just stick a new protector on the phone. I got 3 ones from Anker for just 5€. Obviously this only works if you put the screen protector on as soon as you unbox your freshly bought phone. IMO this is the only real way to prevent micro-scratches or any other type of scratches to harm the actual screen. If you want to sell your phone you can take the screen protector off and it looks as new (granted you have been using a case so the rest of your phone isn't scratched etc either)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
wolfen69 said:
The Anker screen protectors I use are completely invisible, provided you apply them correctly. And to me, micro scratches are completely unacceptable for resale value purposes.
But good review, thanks for sharing, and to each their own.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
U both talking about clear one or matte one?
Sent from my Nexus 5
atishey23 said:
U both talking about clear one or matte one?
Sent from my Nexus 5
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A matte one wouldn't be invisible, right?
atishey23 said:
U both talking about clear one or matte one?
Sent from my Nexus 5
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This one: http://www.amazon.de/gp/product/B00GHD28BS?psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_detailpage_o04_s00 (Yes it's german but you'll get it )
Thanks for this. I've had a hammerhead here for 26 months and just realized after buying another phone how bad the screen is regarding oil and smudges. It is rather ungodly and disgusting looking after taking a phone call. Based on searches the oleophobic coating is gone and I've been looking for a kit to reapply some of it at the very least. All the other products I've looked at do recommend multiple applications several hours apart.
Hopefully your fourteen month old review still holds true.
wolfen69 said:
The Anker screen protectors I use are completely invisible, provided you apply them correctly. And to me, micro scratches are completely unacceptable for resale value purposes.
But good review, thanks for sharing, and to each their own.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree, my experience with Tech Armor glass screen protectors has been good! The oleophobic coating is better than the one that comes with the nexus 5 and the scratch resistance is better. With a case on, you forget it is even there. I'd link you to it if i could!
Thanks for that information, I was only aware of Fusso before and that costs about £20 for 3ml, for about £30 you get 20ml of this stuff, way better value! I know what to get next time!
Hey, are you able to confirm if the Proteger coating actually works well. Read a few reviews and they all say it only last half a day while Fusso has great reviews. Don't want to waste £30 in it if it's no good.
Considering this is a general question and nothing to do with an in depth discussion on accessories, I decided to post this here. My whole life I've used screen protectors on phones. In recent years I've switched over to tempered glass.
Given the current state of tempered glass screen protectors for our devices, I haven't had the best of luck. Every one I've received from several different companies has either had a nasty rainbow hue, or dust get under the screen protector (due to adhesive only being on the edges). I know there's been some new tempered glass protectors released recently, but considering I paid for protection plan, I don't feel warranted to drop $50+ on a screen protector.
I have the Google Protection plan. I also plan on RMA'ing my device one day down the line due to a couple of issues I'm having, but I decided to wait as I am not completely bothered by them for now.
I'm honestly debating going screen protector'less, I do use a case, and will never consider removing that.
I feel if I ever do get some scratches, it wouldn't even matter considering I plan on RMA'ing the device eventually anyway. What are your thoughts?
Haven't worried about it on the last three phones. Never had a problem or scratch. And my phone sits on my handlebars on my motorcycle for most of the summer.
bigblueshock said:
Considering this is a general question and nothing to do with an in depth discussion on accessories, I decided to post this here. My whole life I've used screen protectors on phones. In recent years I've switched over to tempered glass.
Given the current state of tempered glass screen protectors for our devices, I haven't had the best of luck. Every one I've received from several different companies has either had a nasty rainbow hue, or dust get under the screen protector (due to adhesive only being on the edges). I know there's been some new tempered glass protectors released recently, but considering I paid for protection plan, I don't feel warranted to drop $50+ on a screen protector.
I have the Google Protection plan. I also plan on RMA'ing my device one day down the line due to a couple of issues I'm having, but I decided to wait as I am not completely bothered by them for now.
I'm honestly debating going screen protector'less, I do use a case, and will never consider removing that.
I feel if I ever do get some scratches, it wouldn't even matter considering I plan on RMA'ing the device eventually anyway. What are your thoughts?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, old habits die hard. Don't use a screen protector. They interfere with the phone, look like crap, don't fit right (curved glass), cause touch issues and are outrageously expensive. You'll be just fine with a decent case with a good lip unless you intentionally put coins, keys or other hard metallic objects in the same pocket. My .02 cents.
I don't use one for a couple of years now and never had a scratch.
Ever since curved glass, I started using wet apply screen protectors.
It "molds" to the sides, accommodating the curves and at times it's hard to tell there's something on my phone.
There is a bit of grain when viewing something with a white background, and you don't get the feel of glass, but both these things are very minor to me and wont stop me from continue using it.
If this wet application protector didn't exist, I'd probably go without one as well. I've never done that before but I can't tolerate the insanely poor quality tgsps that work horribly with the curves especially.
rickysidhu_ said:
Ever since curved glass, I started using wet apply screen protectors.
It "molds" to the sides, accommodating the curves and at times it's hard to tell there's something on my phone.
There is a bit of grain when viewing something with a white background, and you don't get the feel of glass, but both these things are very minor to me and wont stop me from continue using it.
If this wet application protector didn't exist, I'd probably go without one as well. I've never done that before but I can't tolerate the insanely poor quality tgsps that work horribly with the curves especially.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good to know. Thanks! Which one do you use in particular, out of curiosity?
v12xke said:
Yeah, old habits die hard. Don't use a screen protector. They interfere with the phone, look like crap, don't fit right (curved glass), cause touch issues and are outrageously expensive. You'll be just fine with a decent case with a good lip unless you intentionally put coins, keys or other hard metallic objects in the same pocket. My .02 cents.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup, those are things I don't do. Very careful. Thanks!
bigblueshock said:
Good to know. Thanks! Which one do you use in particular, out of curiosity?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's from "Sparin". If you search "wet applied" for our device it should come up on Amazon!
rickysidhu_ said:
It's from "Sparin". If you search "wet applied" for our device it should come up on Amazon!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So, this covers the WHOLE screen. I like that. I just wish they made a matte one...
Thanks!
It depends on your phone handling, case & usage! For me, I've not needed one on my devices!
I have not used one since I had a galaxy s2, when Nexus 4 was released never had a scratch on a phone screen since. I did drop a Samsung tablet with a pen under when I was walking at good pace and it landed beneath it and cracked screen. It was between tile floor and the screen.
If you want to protect your screen from cracks you need a case that has a small lip that would prevent glass from hitting ground. The curved glass might be more prone to crack if it lands on a part.
Whitestone dome glass, its been proven to work across several devices with these screen types.
There is another one now with similar tech but I can't remember the name.
sent from my Pixel 2 XL or Note FE
force70 said:
Whitestone dome glass, its been proven to work across several devices with these screen types.
There is another one now with similar tech but I can't remember the name.
sent from my Pixel 2 XL or Note FE
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's the one I was referring to at the $50-60 price point. I'm sure it's as close to perfect as possible, but at $50+ I'd rather pay the $99 deductible to get a full phone replacement considering I have the preferred plan
bigblueshock said:
That's the one I was referring to at the $50-60 price point. I'm sure it's as close to perfect as possible, but at $50+ I'd rather pay the $99 deductible to get a full phone replacement considering I have the preferred plan
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol....yes i get that but how many times can you RMA?
sent from my Pixel 2 XL or Note FE
force70 said:
Lol....yes i get that but how many times can you RMA?
sent from my Pixel 2 XL or Note FE
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If it's only scratches... Once. Right before I re-sell my device because of the current defects I have, lol.
Then again, I wouldn't even have to pay the deductible for defects. Only if i break the screen or drown the phone in water which hopefully neither of those happen.
I got THIS one from Skinomi.
It doesn't interfere with any device functions or the camera, and is really heavy duty, but is not glass.
I've found these are very good for screen protection in rough environments. I test military weaponry and combat vehicles so I am outside, in the desert 80% of the time, so I've used screen protectors for years.
If your lifestyle isn't adverse to display surfaces, you could probably do without.
But on a $900 device, with my lifestyle, and job environment; I'll deal with a slightly ugly looking screen protector which has saved my device many times on random drops
This problem with the Pixel 2 XL is the curved screen. I haven't tried the glass and most have poor reviews and appear difficult to get the edges to adhere.
Even the Skinomi, that are usually great protectors, had a little difficulty sticking to one of the corners of my 2 XL.
tl;dr
If your day to day lifestyle doesn't place your device in danger (drops, contact with hard objects, abusive conditions, etc.), you're probably good without a screen protector. If not, it's cheap insurance for random drops and rough handling.
I bought a Spigen glass.tr nano liquid thingy, which is some sort of SiO2 compound that you have to apply just like you use any glass wipe tissue. I never dared to start smashing it with my keys, but it should be adequate to help the screen intact & scratch-free from the smears & dust in your pockets. I actually applied it to the glass of the back camera as well, and the picture quality didn't decrease. The feel of touching the screen changed though, it feels a bit more rugged and less slippery, compared to a Galaxy S8 without any screen protection.
https://www.amazon.de/Displayschutzfolie-Spigen-Kompatibel-Installation-000GL21813/dp/B0774116F5/
Grab the InvisShield from SGFresh. It's great for the 2 XL. A little tedious to install, but great protection.