Related
I have bought this product due to its oil-resistant feature. But it is not working. Lol. My screen was better without it. It keeps fingerprints and oil very much and as i said before without it the fingerprints and oil surface was not disturbing me. So what do you suggest me for a screen protector? A real one. Thanks.
XO is a very good one and recommended by many.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
I didn't realize this phone had that feature. This explains why my Nexus seems to get so fewer fingerprints than my old Vibrant did, I suppose.
Ngo93 said:
XO is a very good one and recommended by many.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for your answer. Where can i buy it. Can you provide a link? Thanks.
Also which cases do you recommend?
You can buy direct from XO Skins Click me.
They are really great to deal with, and quick to ship.
Cases depend on what you want, lots of protection or light weight and basically just scratch protection for the body.
I like and currently use the Ringke Slim Click me, but it doesn't offer a lot drop protection. but it doesn't add much in bulk or size.
I also have an Otterbox commuter Click me it's a more protective case, and also adds a little more size to the phone as well.
I have the Incipio Ngp Click me which I like a lot as well. It's very similar to the Diztronic cases Click me. Only draw back to the Ngp is just the power and volume buttons lose a lot of there feel, making it a little harder to press.
Hope this helps you out a little.
PacerguyDon said:
You can buy direct from XO Skins Click me.
They are really great to deal with, and quick to ship.
Cases depend on what you want, lots of protection or light weight and basically just scratch protection for the body.
I like and currently use the Ringke Slim Click me, but it doesn't offer a lot drop protection. but it doesn't add much in bulk or size.
I also have an Otterbox commuter Click me it's a more protective case, and also adds a little more size to the phone as well.
I have the Incipio Ngp Click me which I like a lot as well. It's very similar to the Diztronic cases Click me. Only draw back to the Ngp is just the power and volume buttons lose a lot of there feel, making it a little harder to press.
Hope this helps you out a little.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you very much for your detailed answer. It helped me a lot. Final question; What do you think of SGP's Neo Hybrid Case? I like it's design but some people says it deforms in heat.
I haven't tried the SGP's Neo Hybrid Case so I really can't give an answer to this question. They do look nice, and look to offer good protection.
Maybe someone that has one will offer an opinion.
Im pretty interested in the Urban Armor Gear case but some people have problems with the power button.. can someone confirm this is a problem? I heard a fix is to take off the case and press down the cases power button really hard. But other than that case anybody find another great one? Thanks!! Heres the link http://www.urbanarmorgear.com/collections/samsung/products/gs3-white
i use the sgp illuzion but its not for everyone. it is tedious sometiems but im NEVER worried with my phone in that case
i ordered a DBA ultra recently for when im not out and about with the illuzion
SAMSUNG GALAXY S III BALLISTIC HARD CORE SERIES CASE
http://www.goballisticcase.com/products/samsung-galaxy-s-iii-ballistic-hard-core-series-case
http://www.amazon.de/gp/product/B008TN8IS6/
or
http://www.amazon.de/gp/product/B009US0R8S/
each for 3,50 €
in combination with
http://www.amazon.de/Hama-NaviBag-universell-Nylon-schwarz/dp/B000S8BHKQ/
for 1,50€
and your phone is perfect protected for 5 €
Best case
I really like the Otterbox Defender cases... They have protected my phone through mosh pits, Occupy Wall Street, bike polo, street longboarding, and just general junk I've put it though. They also have a lifetime replacement deal although I've never used it. I've used them with my Droid X, Droid X2, and my SGIII. Highly recommended.
I love my UAG it works great to protect my SGS3 and also works good with my ZAGG HD installed.
mcguinness89 said:
Im pretty interested in the Urban Armor Gear case but some people have problems with the power button.. can someone confirm this is a problem? I heard a fix is to take off the case and press down the cases power button really hard. But other than that case anybody find another great one? Thanks!! Heres the link http://www.urbanarmorgear.com/collections/samsung/products/gs3-white
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
- I still plan on getting one of the UAG cases.
- If the problem with the buttons is STIFFNESS...I like that. I hardly ever use the power button and that's less chance of the S3 waking up in my pocket.
- the button(s) will loosen up over time or you can mod it.
- lowest profile sized case for the perceived high degree of protection
themadproducer said:
- I still plan on getting one of the UAG cases.
- If the problem with the buttons is STIFFNESS...I like that. I hardly ever use the power button and that's less chance of the S3 waking up in my pocket.
- the button(s) will loosen up over time or you can mod it.
- lowest profile sized case for the perceived high degree of protection
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What he said^ i love my UAG case
1slow4G said:
What he said^ i love my UAG case
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does it seem like u can cut out that power button and it will still look nice? (just incase its too stiff for me)
mcguinness89 said:
Does it seem like u can cut out that power button and it will still look nice? (just incase its too stiff for me)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
not necessary with the modification that can be done to it. Its not real stiff, you just have to get use to it, after usage it should break in and respond alot better.
You don't actually cut out the lock button on the UAG case. You cut down the long sides of it. It doesn't affect how the button looks, it only makes it easier to press.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
I have the UAG Blue and I don't find the power button stiff at all.
What about these. iOttie Macaron
http://www.ebay.com/itm/iOttie-Maca...063408?pt=PDA_Accessories&hash=item27ccb3da30
CaseMate Tough, buttons are so easy to press!
Case Mate Phantom. Very protective, looks and feels great, not too bulky, and a great built-in screen protector.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app
I bought a two piece gunmetal gray case at the Tmobile store that has been great so far. I bought two other cases but they just aren't as good. Anyone know who makes the case I am talking about ?
Best case for sgs3 I find is the uag. Wouldn't buy anything else now. Just hope when s4 is made they make a case for it
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
Best one for white s3 imo..
http://dx.com/p/protective-tpu-case-for-samsung-galaxy-s3-i9300-grey-white-156859
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda app-developers app
Case-Mate "Signature Flip" <3
http://www.case-mate.com/Samsung-Ga...e-Samsung-Galaxy-S3-Signature-Flip-Cases.asp#
Edit: The case only has on little disadvantage: The HOME-Wake-Function needs to be disabled. Otherwise the cover lid always wakes the phone...
Howto: http://www.s3forums.com/forum/galaxy-s3-hacking-mods/1065-stop-home-key-waking-screen.html
gtda said:
Best case for sgs3 I find is the uag. Wouldn't buy anything else now. Just hope when s4 is made they make a case for it
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
After trying on a couple of cases I have to agree UAG is the best case for the S3. It's a combination of looks and protection without having to make the phone look like an ugly thick brick like the other "protective" cases.
Hello,
With this topic i would like to ask out of these 2 populair cases wich one is best in your honest opinion?
In my opinion i think so far the UAG is alot more nice and maybe a bit less thick,
But maybe the Commutor is alot more Durable and better against drops? But also a bit uglyer than the UAG.
I am still struggling just due i think it has to be good against drops, Due thats whats a case is for obviously.
I hope you can help me out of this and probably other users aswell since i doubt i am the only one ^^
Best regards,
DrLuigi
Or of course if you have another case wich isnt above 35-40 dollar please say so ^^
But i think these two are the best around for this price tag.
I tried out the commuter at a bestbuy and while the case feels nice. the buttons are insanely hard to press. You have to really press it really hard and you don't get feedback so you don't know if you pressed it or not until the screen reacts.
Other members here have said that it eases up over time but not that much.
I personally have the ballistic sg and it seems to be the nicest for me. (not the maxx, just the sg)
mputtr said:
I tried out the commuter at a bestbuy and while the case feels nice. the buttons are insanely hard to press. You have to really press it really hard and you don't get feedback so you don't know if you pressed it or not until the screen reacts.
Other members here have said that it eases up over time but not that much.
I personally have the ballistic sg and it seems to be the nicest for me. (not the maxx, just the sg)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah,
Heard the same thing about buttons, But not becoming lose at all, is what i heard,
Also it just doesnt seem nice anyhow, But its very strong i have heard against drops.
Also i have to say that case seems nice,
But i do think Urban one does look nicer,
But idk about being good against drops or anything.
Trident Case has a few rugged options and I heard they are coming out with a charging case too. They range from $35-$50 but they are having a sale, 25% off everything.
I have the commuter. Highly recommend it for protection. It has saved my phone from so many drops.I think some people exaggerate on how hard the buttons are to press. Yes you have to press them a little harder but not much. I just ordered a Uag case since i heard so many great things about them. Either way I don't you can go wrong with either case.
Sent from Flip's S3
elflip88 said:
I have the commuter. Highly recommend it for protection. It has saved my phone from so many drops.I think some people exaggerate on how hard the buttons are to press. Yes you have to press them a little harder but not much. I just ordered a Uag case since i heard so many great things about them. Either way I don't you can go wrong with either case.
Sent from Flip's S3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any idea when it should arrive?
Just so you could tell us maybe how you think it is?
For example so you could tell us wich one you would prefer as first case?
Due the chance is pretty high i get both aswell (Well or something else ofc like a Power Charge case) , but the second will be for over like 3-4 months so ye
Thanks for the help everyone ^^
For Otterbox commuter and Ballistic SG case, please have a look to my thread as I had deeply compare both. For UAG, there is a thread with more 200k view about the case. It's base on your personal preference. If you want your phone to be protected well (with dust cover), then get a Otterbox Commuter(Dont worry about the button, it will getting better after few weeks of use). If you want a unique looking, protective and less bulky case, then get a UAG case. Currently, commuter is much more cheaper than the UAG. I owned 3 of these ultimate protective case, I guarantee that you wont regret if you get either one. But personally, I recommended UAG..^^
lvoonjian8888 said:
For Otterbox commuter and Ballistic SG case, please have a look to my thread as I had deeply compare both. For UAG, there is a thread with more 200k view about the case. It's base on your personal preference. If you want your phone to be protected well (with dust cover), then get a Otterbox Commuter(Dont worry about the button, it will getting better after few weeks of use). If you want a unique looking, protective and less bulky case, then get a UAG case. Currently, commuter is much more cheaper than the UAG. I owned 3 of these ultimate protective case, I guarantee that you wont regret if you get either one. But personally, I recommended UAG..^^
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hai,
Thanks for the explaination,
Did not know there were such topics already there sry ^^
But i also just wanted to know wich one would be better when talking about Quality/Drop/being pretty.
Anyhow ^^
If anyone knows also a pretty cool case please repley ^^
I probably think to buy UAG first, Afterwards perhaps a Otterbox for when i do other stuff that it would be more common it to fall etc etc.
Best regards,
DrLuigi.
Btw how thick is that UAG case?
Since it seems on picture pretty reasonable thin,
But wanted to ask ye first ^^
Also is the back panel plastic smooth or grippy or?
Thanks ^^
I have the aviator UAG. Color isn't great, Gunna get the blue one instead sooner or later. As far as everything goes, great protection, solid feel, all around good quality. Little slippery on the back tho.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda app-developers app
So I just got my UAG case and I love it. It does feel a little slimmer than the commuter. I feel as if it is a bit less protection from the otterbox, but it feels so much better in the hands. I saw a drop test on youtube with this case and seems pretty good.
Sent from Flip's S3
I have both and I always find myself going back to my UAG. It fits better in my opinion and has a much thinner profile. The small raised areas on the back corners help it from sliding around when its on its backside on a flat surface. The otterbox on the other hand is slicker they the naked phone itself. The UAG also comes in and out of pocket easier. Lol my advice is extremely one sided, but its some food for thought.
Sent from inside the RootBox.
I personally am a otterbox fan I currently have the following otterbox cases for the s3
-gun metal grey / white defender
-orange / black / realtree camo defender
-red / black defender
-white / gunmetal commuter
-purple / pink commuter
I switch these cases out like switchimg out my underwear
YES THE COMMUTER CASE at first is hard to press the buttoms but the more you use it the better and easier it becomes
I also love otterbox customer service always friendly and have no problem exchanging out your case for you or trying to work out something
Ok so I think I got a defective UAG case. The power button on the case gets stuck when I push a little too hard which sends my phone in a bunch of bootloops. Contacted the seller and hopefully I get a replacement
Sent from Flip's S3
elflip88 said:
Ok so I think I got a defective UAG case. The power button on the case gets stuck when I push a little too hard which sends my phone in a bunch of bootloops. Contacted the seller and hopefully I get a replacement
Sent from Flip's S3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
With the case off press the button outward from the inside, slip the phone in and press the power button again, thats to line up where it should be. Thats how i use to do mine then it worked great after
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
1slow4G said:
With the case off press the button outward from the inside, slip the phone in and press the power button again, thats to line up where it should be. Thats how i use to do mine then it worked great after
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks that actually seems to fix it. Also, I thought I had read that this case was really hard to take off. But I take mine off easily. It doesn't feel lose or anything.
Sent from Flip's S3
Great Chooses my friend has the OtterBox Commutor case its a great case havent seen the UAG gear case but my self i own the OtterBox Defender case because i got it free with my phone
elflip88 said:
Thanks that actually seems to fix it. Also, I thought I had read that this case was really hard to take off. But I take mine off easily. It doesn't feel lose or anything.
Sent from Flip's S3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Welcome. Yeah if it feels funny just keep messing with it till it lines up perfectly.
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
After reading reviews and seeing how my wife's iPhone otterbox has held up (she's on her third replacement), I bought an uag yesterday. They look very rugged, kinda like a toolbox.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
Neo Hybrid: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HycezWiWU7A
Slim Armor: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e5WahhWrBvA
I REALLY wanted to love the Slim Armor. It really is a shame that the case has a problem rendering it useless. The case design is great but the fact that it presses the power button all the time is inexcusable. Going to have to use the Neo Hybrid until better options show up!
Let me know if you guys have any questions at all, as I'd be glad to answer them!
Is it really useless or unusable if it only interferes when putting on the case? Are you really changing cases that often?
james11417 said:
Is it really useless or unusable if it only interferes when putting on the case? Are you really changing cases that often?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It permanently pushes the power button down whenever you put the case on. It just sends the phone into a constant power cycle loop.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk 2
I have the case and it works perfectly fine for me, it turns on when I want and off when I want. The case fits great, not sure how well it will protect, and as I'm used to the oterbox as well.
I can put it in and out of my pocket with out it turning on and off.
slowpok22 said:
I have the case and it works perfectly fine for me, it turns on when I want and off when I want. The case fits great, not sure how well it will protect, and as I'm used to the oterbox as well.
I can put it in and out of my pocket with out it turning on and off.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Some units have the manufacturing flaw and others don't. On Amazon about half the reviewed reported this issue with their case.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk 2
ComradeNF said:
Some units have the manufacturing flaw and others don't. On Amazon about half the reviewed reported this issue with their case.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, not my first choice,
I actually ordered this one i-Blason Google Nexus 5, but until someone makes a good quality case hopefully these 2 will keep if from getting banged up and or broken.
Just did some more testing, placing the phone on my desk if i tilt/roll the phone on the edge it will turn the phone on and off again when rolling back and forth, just tried it also with my Gnex in the otterbox and it did the same thing although with a little more pressure.
Spigen has said that they will send you a replacement if you have this issue. Also, not all of the Slim Armor cases have the issue. Lastly, I have the same one you have in the review and mine doesn't do it. It is literally the best case I've used.
you can cut off the button part so it will works well :good:
Is the hybrid thicker then the slim armor? I have the hybrid now and it makes the phone so much wider, is the slim armor identical?
Gja88 said:
Is the hybrid thicker then the slim armor? I have the hybrid now and it makes the phone so much wider, is the slim armor identical?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't have the hybrid but dimension-wise it should be very similar to the slim armor.
Even the Neo Hybrid makes the phone taller and wider though.
I meant neo hybrid vs slim armor. Not the ultra hybrid. Is slim armor less wider then neo?
i did run a search and saw one response to this question. before i take that one response as the gospel, i was hoping a few others who have the slim armor could confirm.
is it true that the slim armor does NOT come with a screen protector?
namurt said:
i did run a search and saw one response to this question. before i take that one response as the gospel, i was hoping a few others who have the slim armor could confirm.
is it true that the slim armor does NOT come with a screen protector?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Both the slim armor and neo hybrid do not come with screen protectors
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk 2
ComradeNF said:
I REALLY wanted to love the Slim Armor. It really is a shame that the case has a problem rendering it useless. The case design is great but the fact that it presses the power button all the time is inexcusable. Going to have to use the Neo Hybrid until better options show up!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know exactly what you mean. My Slim Armor has a similar issue with the power button, but Spigen is sending me a free replacement. Hopefully it works better this time around since I really like the case. My Neo Hybrid will be here tomorrow though! Really looking forward to giving that one a try.
i wonder how long we'll have to wait before the next batch of slim armor cases comes out that fixes the power button issue?
reason i'm wondering is because i was late to the party to order my n5. it's not gonna ship until mid december. i want to order a case and screen protector a week or two ahead of time so i have both ready to go when the phone arrives.
namurt said:
i wonder how long we'll have to wait before the next batch of slim armor cases comes out that fixes the power button issue?
reason i'm wondering is because i was late to the party to order my n5. it's not gonna ship until mid december. i want to order a case and screen protector a week or two ahead of time so i have both ready to go when the phone arrives.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From the amazon posting:
Q: If I order this now will the power button issue be resolved with the product i receive?
A:
Spigen SGP says: "Thank you for letting us know! If you are having issues with your power button, we'll send you a replacement part to fix these issues, we'll have them around November 11 for shipping! Just send us your order number and let us know your issue through Amazon messages and we'll be happy to assist you get a fully functioning case. Thank you and hope to hear from you soon!"
Just got my Neo Hybrid case... Man, this thing sucks! Thing is so damn slippery on both the back and the sides. Like holding a bar of wet soap. Sending it back. On a side note, also got their slim case and like that much better.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
aimfire72 said:
Just got my Neo Hybrid case... Man, this thing sucks! Thing is so damn slippery on both the back and the sides. Like holding a bar of wet soap. Sending it back. On a side note, also got their slim case and like that much better.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Slim Armor you mean? If yes, any issues with the headphone jack or USB charging port clearances?
Bio: I was born and I haven't died yet.
Got the Slim Armor case from Amazon and had the same problem with the power button. Returned it, despite the promise from Spigen to send out a fix. I won't support a company that obviously rushed a product to market and puts there customers in a bind like that.
Hey guys,
I know this is totally subjective. However, I have been looking for a case for my nexus 5. I like the Spigen NeoHybrid, and Slimarmor so far, however I have heard bad things about the Neohybrid, and that the Slimarmor is somewhat bulky. Some guidance is needed. Thank you!
Joegrind27 said:
Hey guys,
I know this is totally subjective. However, I have been looking for a case for my nexus 5. I like the Spigen NeoHybrid, and Slimarmor so far, however I have heard bad things about the Neohybrid, and that the Slimarmor is somewhat bulky. Some guidance is needed. Thank you!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Spigen cases are always good to use and I have used slim armour of it...and I just love that case....so my vote will go for Slim Armour.....
---------- Post added at 02:04 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:58 PM ----------
you can also check out the ultra hybrid one too...thats too a really nice case to go for....:good:
sometimes thick cases will mess with the camera by changing the light sensitivity because the lens and/or flash are shrouded. go on amazon and read the reviews... i decided against the slim armor because of potential camera issues and because people complained about the buttons either being hard to press, or no feedback/bad feel from the buttons. but it does look like it would protect the phone well and with tpu instead of cheap silicone like all those old iphone cases i had to deal with years ago i'm sure it's still a pretty good case. but i went with the neo hybrid and it should be here this afternoon so i'll give my opinion then.
I have the slim armour. I was a bit disappointed at how bulky it is when I first put it on my Nexus, however I have grown accustomed to it and it is a good quality case.
The button feedback is actually the best I've ever experienced on a case. Really nice.
I would personally prefer a slimmer case but if you're not worried about bulk, slim armour is a definite one to look at.
I got a Slim Armor and the buttons are no good. Makes them feel spongy. I'm returning it and ordering a Neo Hybrid.
Pretty awesome. Thank you guys!! Anyone encountered fitting problems with the neohybrid, especially the use of the headset jack?
I have the slimarmor. The power button is a bit too snug and i feel alot of dusk seeps into the bottom of the case.
However, I have dropped the phone 2 times on the ground outside (concrete) and there's not one nick on the case itself and the phone is perfectly fine. It does add a bit of bulk, but I got used to it pretty quickly. I can't promise I'll stay with this one for good, but It will definitely be in rotation with other cases
AceKingNYC said:
I have the slimarmor. The power button is a bit too snug and i feel alot of dusk seeps into the bottom of the case.
However, I have dropped the phone 2 times on the ground outside (concrete) and there's not one nick on the case itself and the phone is perfectly fine. It does add a bit of bulk, but I got used to it pretty quickly. I can't promise I'll stay with this one for good, but It will definitely be in rotation with other cases
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A drop test! Thanks for your service:good:
Feeling better about my slim armor now!
I got the neo hybrid. I was unhappy with the size it made the phone and The grippiness. I think it looks nice though.
I returned it. Now have the nilkin v series flip case on order.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
I have both and like the slim armor better. Better protection and list slippery. If you want slimmer I also have the ultra hybrid which I feel is made better than the neo hybrid and is slimmer. That's my 2 cents on the issue.
i have the neo hybrid and think it's fine as a case. the case buttons transfer the tactile feel of the phone's buttons very well.
AceKingNYC said:
I have the slimarmor. The power button is a bit too snug and i feel alot of dusk seeps into the bottom of the case.
However, I have dropped the phone 2 times on the ground outside (concrete) and there's not one nick on the case itself and the phone is perfectly fine. It does add a bit of bulk, but I got used to it pretty quickly. I can't promise I'll stay with this one for good, but It will definitely be in rotation with other cases
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is good to have real life drop test. This is the exact reason why I bought this case (ordered, shipped, but not received yet).
I have the Neo Hybrid on mine and I love it. It makes the phone easier to hold and adds a nice layer of protection. Plus it looks pretty awesome!
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
kevintstephens said:
I have the Neo Hybrid on mine and I love it. It makes the phone easier to hold and adds a nice layer of protection. Plus it looks pretty awesome!
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any issues with camera flash?
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 4
i just got the neo hybrid. it adds more bulk to the phone than i thought... the back is thin but something about squaring off the back makes it feel a lot bigger. also the tpu + bumper adds some width. i was afraid of button access problems through the cutouts with some of the tpu cases out there so i didn't go with a cheap tpu case, maybe i would have been happier with a contoured case rather than this but overall it's a very good case. the power button feedback is a little less, but the button works consistently, my dennon headphones fit, but others might not, the phone stills charges wirelessly without problems.
I picked up the Slim Armor and love it. Great protection around the corners, screen, and camera lens. For a two layer case, it doesn't feel bulky at all. Fits very nice in the hand IMO.
slick_rick said:
Any issues with camera flash?
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
None that I've noticed with my Neo Hybrid. I just wish it wasn't so difficult to remove.
I haven't actually tried either case (because I haven't even gotten my phone yet... backorder ) but I would trade bulkiness for protection by getting the dual layer Slim Armor. I have had a dual layer case on my current phone and I have dropped a couple times over the past two years. In combination with a screen protector, a dual layer case can be the best insurance for your phone without actually paying $100-200 for real insurance.
I was originally planning on the Neo Hybrid just cuz it looks so damn nice but more than 1 person has said its very slippery... and that'd be silly to buy a case only for you to drop it more often.
I ordered the Slim Armor instead, waiting for it to arrive. Amazon's shipping is kind of wonky, they said 2 day delivery but the package has just sat at UPS's facilities for the past 3 days and its scheduled for tomorrow- oh wait, of course UPS changed the date to Thursday.
Hate UPS, but cant wait to get my hands on the case. Hoping it doesn't have the accursed power button issue (though I reckon it won't be too difficult to fix anyway).
I recently got the slim armor. Quality case. Make sure you play around with putting it on. The buttons are very sensitive as you've probably read elsewhere and would turn the phone off. After about 2 tries I got it on and the buttons are working normally.:good: