does a custom kernel make safetynet false? - Samsung Galaxy A3, A5, A7 (2017) Questions & Answe

Hi, I have a Samsung Galaxy A5 2016 (the technical name is SM-A510F) and it's rooted with magisk, has latest TWRP installed and is currently running lineageOS 15.1. I wonder if Installing a custom kernel make safetynet false and if it's even worth it to install a custom kernel, and what does a custom kernel do in the first place?
Please answer ASAP

There's patches you can flash and modules from magisk if you're worried some applications won't work if root is detected.

Filipe Baltazar said:
There's patches you can flash and modules from magisk if you're worried some applications won't work if root is detected.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What can we flash and what modules to install in magisk?

Related

Installation Issues

Can anyone tell me how to install Pixel 2 Experience magisk module on jaguar oreo rom. Im on latest build of rom(8 may release) and module version 4.5 is not installing. Need help!
just install any module there no specific magisk module.. download latest module and flsah via twrp

Edxposed OnePlus 5T

Hi guys,
I have a OnePlus 5T with unlocked bootloader, TWRP and Magisk v20.1, running stock OOS 9.0.9 with Franco Kernel.
Can I safely install Riru-Core and Riru-EdXposed to try some Xposed modules? If yes can I do it via Magisk Manager or is better to flash them in TWRP?
Thank you
Do it via Magisk Manager to be more safe so if anything goes wrong you can easily turn off the module or uninstall it.
g_turc said:
Hi guys,
I have a OnePlus 5T with unlocked bootloader, TWRP and Magisk v20.1, running stock OOS 9.0.9 with Franco Kernel.
Can I safely install Riru-Core and Riru-EdXposed to try some Xposed modules? If yes can I do it via Magisk Manager or is better to flash them in TWRP?
Thank you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes, but use 0.4.5.1 SandHook, not 0.4.6.0.
I'm currently using it now too.
aillez said:
yes, but use 0.4.5.1 SandHook, not 0.4.6.0.
I'm currently using it now too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
0.4.6.0 YAHFA doesn't work with the custom magisk 20.1?
Nolfer said:
0.4.6.0 YAHFA doesn't work with the custom magisk 20.1?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not sure though.
Since I am still using Android 9 and 4.5.1 works fine.
Sent from my beloved Oneplus 5T
I solved the issue. I'm on android 10 0.4.6.0 yahfa magisk 20.1 custom built for android 10 and it works. Had to install riru 19.5 as 19.6 didn't work

Any news about Edxposed Framework on samsung s20+ ?

hi any one know pliz if i can install edxposed framework on samsung galaxy s20+ rooted with lineage recovery ? Thanks
And another question if after rooted with lineage recovery i can update magisk manager and magisk directly with magisk manger ? Thanks
Edxposed works since magisk root... for magisk update you need to flash it with odin.
chieco said:
Edxposed works since magisk root... for magisk update you need to flash it with odin.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks . Have u tested install edxposed on s20 series . There is no bootloop problem ?
the new said:
Thanks . Have u tested install edxposed on s20 series . There is no bootloop problem ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No bootloop
chieco said:
No bootloop
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok thanks will test
I had an issue with random reboots. Once they started it seemed like it would reboot 4 or 5 times and then it would stop. Did it once a day at least. Installed Vanced and removed Edxposed. No issues since. Could've been the app to go along with getting Vanced working but i froze it and it still happened so i dont know. Removing Edxposed completely and the apps to get Vanced working stopped the random reboots though.
@Fuzzy13
you must have done something wrong... everything works flawless with those xposed magisk modules + xposed manager + vanced from magisk repo.
need help installing edxposed s20 ultra snapdragon oneui 2.5 rom
magisk 21.1 stable and manager 8.0.3
i tried sandhook and yahfh both give me bootloop after installing last core
any tips ?
MaZaGnGy said:
need help installing edxposed s20 ultra snapdragon oneui 2.5 rom
magisk 21.1 stable and manager 8.0.3
i tried sandhook and yahfh both give me bootloop after installing last core
any tips ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Install Riru Core v21.3 and YAHFA EdXposed build from > here < (official alpha builds from EdXposed devs).
And ofc latest EdXposed Manager.
serajr said:
Install Riru Core v21.3 and YAHFA EdXposed build from > here < (official alpha builds from EdXposed devs).
And ofc latest EdXposed Manager.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thank you mate for your reply but i also tried this without luck
and i searched about this problem and i found it is because the kernel enforce selinux so i flashed the custom kernel (jimbok) and turned it to permissive and it worked now without any issue .
i need a way to change stock kernel to permissive because the way i use didn't work
i use terminal command ''setenforce 0'' it doesn't change anything in stock kernel but it worked with the custom one
MaZaGnGy said:
thank you mate for your reply but i also tried this without luck
and i searched about this problem and i found it is because the kernel enforce selinux so i flashed the custom kernel (jimbok) and turned it to permissive and it worked now without any issue .
i need a way to change stock kernel to permissive because the way i use didn't work
i use terminal command ''setenforce 0'' it doesn't change anything in stock kernel but it worked with the custom one
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's weird I gotta say.
I have the setup I mentioned and everything works flawlessly (along with latest magisk canary). My SM-G985F with stock firmware is running on enforcing selinux, as it should.
serajr said:
That's weird I gotta say.
I have the setup I mentioned and everything works flawlessly (along with latest magisk canary). My SM-G985F with stock firmware is running on enforcing selinux, as it should.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i think your device not a snapdragon version so you dont have this issue
because i saw in https://github.com/ people like me using snapdragon fold 2 and tab s7+
im not good enough to understanding why but i found this
(The interesting thing about the failure on the Fold2, a Snapdragon device, is that a dependent feature of RKP, namely CONFIG_KDP_CRED, stops 2020 Samsung Snapdragon devices from booting when the EdXposed Magisk module is enabled.
My hope is that fixing this RKP patch in Magisk will have the side-effect of allowing 2020 Samsung Snapdragon devices to boot EdXposed with the device's stock kernel.)
and in the end someone said you must use permissive to fix the boot loop
im waiting a fix for that or someone guide me to make the stock kernel permissive because it is not easy like before
MaZaGnGy said:
i think your device not a snapdragon version so you dont have this issue
because i saw in https://github.com/ people like me using snapdragon fold 2 and tab s7+
im not good enough to understanding why but i found this
(The interesting thing about the failure on the Fold2, a Snapdragon device, is that a dependent feature of RKP, namely CONFIG_KDP_CRED, stops 2020 Samsung Snapdragon devices from booting when the EdXposed Magisk module is enabled.
My hope is that fixing this RKP patch in Magisk will have the side-effect of allowing 2020 Samsung Snapdragon devices to boot EdXposed with the device's stock kernel.)
and in the end someone said you must use permissive to fix the boot loop
im waiting a fix for that or someone guide me to make the stock kernel permissive because it is not easy like before
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep mate, exynos!
I didn't know snapdragon devices were facing such issue. I've searched on this now and found this, but I guess you already saw it.
Hopefully a fix will come out soon!
It totally works!I tried it in July/August

Can't install magisk On LIneageOS 14.1

last week I installed LIneageOS 14.1 on my old tab 3 lite
sm-t113 I already rooted The Phone With TWRP now I need magisk I looked on some videos and articles I found magisk 22.0 and 20.4 both versions got me error: 1 and failed
What version is compatible with LIneageOS 14.1 Android 7.1.2 ?
Rasty#5587 said:
last week I installed LIneageOS 14.1 on my old tab 3 lite
sm-t113 I already rooted The Phone With TWRP now I need magisk I looked on some videos and articles I found magisk 22.0 and 20.4 both versions got me error: 1 and failed
What version is compatible with LIneageOS 14.1 Android 7.1.2 ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know much about tabs but I was facing the same issue when I was flashing some files on my android device. I had to change the file system of my device by booting into recovery mode, I changed my file system to exFAT and then installed the custom ROM again ( not sure if it was necessary to reinstall ), then I installed magisk and everything worked fine for me, not sure if this will help you resolve your problem but you can try.
Just take a backup, just to be on the safer side.
Rasty#5587 said:
last week I installed LIneageOS 14.1 on my old tab 3 lite
sm-t113 I already rooted The Phone With TWRP now I need magisk I looked on some videos and articles I found magisk 22.0 and 20.4 both versions got me error: 1 and failed
What version is compatible with LIneageOS 14.1 Android 7.1.2 ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you only need root, you can flash this instead of magisk
LineageOS Downloads
download.lineageos.org
kurtn said:
If you only need root, you can flash this instead of magisk
LineageOS Downloads
download.lineageos.org
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No bro my problem ain't rooting my phone it's pieces of cake I just want to switch From SuperSU to Magisk because it has so many amazing features
Rasty#5587 said:
No bro my problem ain't rooting my phone it's pieces of cake I just want to switch From SuperSU to Magisk because it has so many amazing features
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In that case I would start with clean flashing. And always use latest magisk. In case you need safetynet - canary version only works at the moment.
Installation method is now download apk from github, rename to zip, flash with twrp.

Question Magisk modules require magisk v24.2

Hey guys, i want to install some modules on me realme C21 which is rooted. However the modules require version 24.2+ of magisk to install. My question is since my device has a MTK chipset and only able to use patched magisk version (which apparently i can't update as it wont support my device), how do i go about it? Or is there a way to update it that i dont know about? Can i install Modules for magisk while bypassing the requirements?
Thanks again for any support i get, i'm new here and happy to be part of XDA!

Categories

Resources