Why international model doesn't have a dedicated XDA page as Note 9 Pro (Indian)?
vote here : https://forum.xda-developers.com/redmi-note-9-pro/help/separate-forums-curtana-joyeuse-please-t4148657
Because India has a population of 1b and the rest (global) is max. 350m.
Sent from my Redmi Note 9 Pro using XDA Labs
Indian people fu of scam.....
Suryadixl92 said:
Indian people fu of scam.....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's not what I meant...
India is being used by everyone as a laboratory (labrats) for (mostly cheap) products.
Sent from my Redmi Note 9 Pro using XDA Labs
Would be a whole lot easier if there was whole dedicated section for global and/or eea development.
whisper1101 said:
Because India has a population of 1b and the rest (global) is max. 350m.
Sent from my Redmi Note 9 Pro using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is not an argument. This way of thinking leads to conflicts. Your approach means that the minority is worse. You and Suryadixl92 in power and we have a war.
---------- Post added at 04:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:23 PM ----------
Suryadixl92 said:
Indian people fu of scam.....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're both wrong (whisper1101, Suryadixl92). Do not insult each other, talk respectfully.
KRisXD said:
That is not an argument. This way of thinking leads to conflicts. Your approach means that the minority is worse. You and Suryadixl92 in power and we have a war.
---------- Post added at 04:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:23 PM ----------
You're both wrong (whisper1101, Suryadixl92). Do not insult each other, talk respectfully.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No. I meant no disrespect. I'm an IT and telecommunications expert, I don't insult. I just tell numerical facts.
Regards.
Sent from my Redmi Note 9 Pro using XDA Labs
Whoever the moderator or administrator of this forum, may we request to create a dedicated forum for REDMI NOTE 9 PRO (GLOBAL VERSION) aka "JOYEUSE" as well as for REDMI NOTE 9 PRO MAX aka "EXCALIBUR". It is very confusing that threads for Joyeuse are inside Curtana's forum. And I also found out that there is already a forum or thread (whatsoever it is called for JOYEUSE https://forum.xda-developers.com/re...o-international-model-general-and-development ) but why it is located inside CURTANA's forum?
---------- Post added at 09:41 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:38 AM ----------
whisper1101 said:
Because India has a population of 1b and the rest (global) is max. 350m.
Sent from my Redmi Note 9 Pro using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wrong. The International Model "REDMI NOTE 9 PRO" with the boardname "JOYEUSE" is not released in INDIA. So INDIA and POPULATION has nothing to do with the question. The suggested forum for Joyeuse is for the users outside of INDIA, not for INDIA.
BenjieLoria said:
Whoever the moderator or administrator of this forum, may we request to create a dedicated forum for REDMI NOTE 9 PRO (GLOBAL VERSION) aka "JOYEUSE" as well as for REDMI NOTE 9 PRO MAX aka "EXCALIBUR". It is very confusing that threads for Joyeuse are inside Curtana's forum. And I also found out that there is already a forum or thread (whatsoever it is called for JOYEUSE https://forum.xda-developers.com/re...o-international-model-general-and-development ) but why it is located inside CURTANA's forum?
---------- Post added at 09:41 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:38 AM ----------
Wrong. The International Model "REDMI NOTE 9 PRO" with the boardname "JOYEUSE" is not released in INDIA. So INDIA and POPULATION has nothing to do with the question. The suggested forum for Joyeuse is for the users outside of INDIA, not for INDIA.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AFAIK, the global 9s is called 9 pro/curtana and the global 9 pro is called 9 pro max/joyeuse in India.
But I could be wrong, not sure...
Sent from my Redmi Note 9 Pro using XDA Labs
whisper1101 said:
AFAIK, the global 9s is called 9 pro/curtana and the global 9 pro is called 9 pro max/joyeuse in India.
But I could be wrong, not sure...
Sent from my Redmi Note 9 Pro using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes you are.
Redmi Note 9 Pro (India) is the Redmi Note 9S Global [CURTANA]
Redmi Note 9 Pro Max is only released in India [EXCALIBUR]
Redmi Note 9 Pro Global is released outside of India and has no Indian counterpart [JOYEUSE]
The point here is that since they are having different boardname and specifications, as well as the region/availability, it should be better if they are in different forums so that users will not be confused for flashing things from Redmi Note 9S/ 9 Pro of India (Curtana) on Redmi Note 9 Pro Global (Joyeuse)
BenjieLoria said:
Yes you are.
Redmi Note 9 Pro (India) is the Redmi Note 9S Global [CURTANA]
Redmi Note 9 Pro Max is only released in India [EXCALIBUR]
Redmi Note 9 Pro Global is released outside of India and has no Indian counterpart [JOYEUSE]
The point here is that since they are having different boardname and specifications, as well as the region/availability, it should be better if they are in different forums so that users will not be confused for flashing things from Redmi Note 9S/ 9 Pro of India (Curtana) on Redmi Note 9 Pro Global (Joyeuse)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I totally agree with the different forums. Check.
Sent from my Redmi Note 9 Pro using XDA Labs
But still,
What's the real deifference between indian and global versio? As I saw both are really similar about specs (like SoC)
So why? Imo both are the same (and about roms too)
Dok_T said:
But still,
What's the real deifference between indian and global versio? As I saw both are really similar about specs (like SoC)
So why? Imo both are the same (and about roms too)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Indian model have 48mpx camera and have no NFC.
International have 64mpx camera and have NFC.
Yeah this phone needs its own dedicated page, it would save confusion!
up. this will cause a lot of bootloops for newbie aince not all curtana roms are compatible with joyeuse boards
TECHROY23 said:
up. this will cause a lot of bootloops for newbie aince not all curtana roms are compatible with joyeuse boards
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Seriously this phone needs its own thread/page/sticky or a main page sticky with the different model variants, just so people know
---------- Post added at 02:01 ---------- Previous post was at 01:52 ----------
Anyway I love this phone, not charged it for 3 days, normal use, bar fb and instagram. Massive youtube loads, emails, android pay a few times, the only thing I can say bad about it is it has a glitch coming out of standby where the screen does not load, a press of the home button sorts it, not a massive problem but a bit weird.
Seriously don't understand why they made a POINTLESS subforum... There's still mixed posts in all of them!!
There needs to be a forum for:
Curtana
Joyeuse
Excalibur
Miatoll (all variants)
How hard is it to do this....?
Xda mod, please create separated pages
Related
Hey,
Should I buy this https://www.gearbest.com/cell-phone...af45155&utm_source=admitad&utm_content=191425 . I am not sure if it is whyred or not. They say that it comes with B20 band and it´s a global version. I am developer so want to develop to this phone.Need help pls.
Thank you,
Miguel de Carvalho
No sir. This is Redmi Note 5; Vince if so-called. The image is of Redmi Note 5 Pro and for representational purpose. It is even mentioned down below. Read the name and the questions in latter part of the page.
yes, i made my redmi note 5 pro into fastboot mode. Then i can see my phone was listed in xiaomi assistant software by the name of "whyred", i suppose "whyred" is its code name.
xdatman said:
No sir. This is Redmi Note 5; Vince if so-called. The image is of Redmi Note 5 Pro and for representational purpose. It is even mentioned down below. Read the name and the questions in latter part of the page.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Looking at the specs I really think it's whyred, not vince
I gone to telegram gorup and they said me that it is the whyred man.
MIguelNdeCarvalho said:
I gone to telegram gorup and they said me that it is the whyred man.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's whyred global version. You can safely purchase it. Many have already preorder this device from the same seller.
MIguelNdeCarvalho said:
Hey,
Should I buy this https://www.gearbest.com/cell-phone...af45155&utm_source=admitad&utm_content=191425 . I am not sure if it is whyred or not. They say that it comes with B20 band and it´s a global version. I am developer so want to develop to this phone.Need help pls.
Thank you,
Miguel de Carvalho
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, you must buy that smartphone. It is the one that all people in Europe will buy. The Redmi Note 5 pro is the model suitable exclusively for India. The Redmi Note 5 model from China does not have b20 and is not multilanguage. The link that you have put is the model that we have already bought the most.
When you bought it ... Here is your home .... you can come, we want to create the largest community in the Android world.
https://www.movilesdualsim.com/foros/xiaomi-redmi-note-5.1264/
Hi guys!
I know this will sound like a really stupid question, but which is my phone? GearBest, the place where I ordered it, it's calling it Redmi Note 5 but, according to the hardware, appearently is a Note 5 Pro? I'm really lost here. This is the link (https://pt.gearbest.com/cell-phones/pp_1660528.html?wid=1349303).
Thanks for your help!
Looks like the Global Version Redmi Note 5!
https://www.reddit.com/r/Xiaomi/wiki/specs/redminote5
good to finally see an answer about this confusion, planning to buy this on aliexpress
corkiejp said:
Looks like the Global Version Redmi Note 5!
https://www.reddit.com/r/Xiaomi/wiki/specs/redminote5
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the quick answer! But I'm still confused, should I stick to this forum or move to the Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 forum?
TheForgotten said:
Thanks for the quick answer! But I'm still confused, should I stick to this forum or move to the Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 forum?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That forum is for the Indian Redmi Note 5, which is a rebranded redmi 5 plus (china). Codename: - VINCE
^^^ That is why Indian's have a Redmi Note 5 Pro
So if your getting WHYRED, stay in these forums.
corkiejp said:
That forum is for the Indian Redmi Note 5, which is a rebranded redmi 5 plus (china). Codename: - VINCE
^^^ That is why Indian's have a Redmi Note 5 Pro
So if your getting WHYRED, stay in these forums.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for all the help <3
How to see whyred in my device?
beeduq said:
How to see whyred in my device?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dual cam???
TheForgotten said:
Hi guys!
I know this will sound like a really stupid question, but which is my phone? GearBest, the place where I ordered it, it's calling it Redmi Note 5 but, according to the hardware, appearently is a Note 5 Pro? I'm really lost here. This is the link (https://pt.gearbest.com/cell-phones/pp_1660528.html?wid=1349303).
Thanks for your help!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes is it Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 Pro Global Version with SD 636
I figure it out by installing Antutu, but does all Redmi Note 5 with dual camera considered as Pro or Whyred?
Chinese or Indian have same Whyred name?
beeduq said:
I figure it out by installing Antutu, but does all Redmi Note 5 with dual camera considered as Pro or Whyred?
Chinese or Indian have same Whyred name?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 China/global and Pro share one codename which is WHYRED. China and global version are almost the same (global version supports LTE B4 and B20 and China version doesn't ). Pro version has got different front camera sensor
So whenever You see Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 with dual camera and Snapdragon 636 it's code in WHYRED. If frontal camera is 20Mpx - it's Remi Note 5 Pro. If 12Mpx (or 13Mpx I can't remember) it's China or global. LTE B20 and B4 supported ? Then its global
Sent from my whyred using XDA Labs
MikiGry said:
Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 China/global and Pro share one codename which is WHYRED. China and global version are almost the same (global version supports LTE B4 and B20 and China version doesn't ). Pro version has got different front camera sensor
So whenever You see Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 with dual camera and Snapdragon 636 it's code in WHYRED. If frontal camera is 20Mpx - it's Remi Note 5 Pro. If 12Mpx (or 13Mpx I can't remember) it's China or global. LTE B20 and B4 supported ? Then its global
Sent from my whyred using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice info, thanks
MikiGry said:
Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 China/global and Pro share one codename which is WHYRED. China and global version are almost the same (global version supports LTE B4 and B20 and China version doesn't ). Pro version has got different front camera sensor
So whenever You see Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 with dual camera and Snapdragon 636 it's code in WHYRED. If frontal camera is 20Mpx - it's Remi Note 5 Pro. If 12Mpx (or 13Mpx I can't remember) it's China or global. LTE B20 and B4 supported ? Then its global
Sent from my whyred using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So the ROMs discussed in this forum (which is technically for the 20mp front sensor model), will work on the Global version too?
stoatbroker said:
So the ROMs discussed in this forum (which is technically for the 20mp front sensor model), will work on the Global version too?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This entire forum is dedicated to both RN5Pro and Global RN5, both labeled as WHYRED. So most of the things should work on both, unless it's noted otherwise. The builds (both rom and kernel) are unified, as it was done with OP 3/3T.
Hi,.
I own a redmi note 5 and naturally I go to thread redmi note 5 / 5 plus. But I notice the code name doesn't match.
Now I confused, should I go to redmi note 5 pro??
If I'm not mistaken my note 5 is code name are Why red right?
But why two same thread on xda redmi note 5?
And what the sidéré ce between note 5 and 5 pro?!
PLS HELP, THX
EDIT : MY NOTE 5 have 636 snapdragon less ram 4 instead of 6 and have B20 4g
China redmi note 5 = global redmi note 5 ≈ Indian redmi note 5 pro( only camera is different)
Global or China redmi 5 plus = Indian redmi note 5
Indian redmi note 5 (single camera ) is Redmi 5 plus in china.
Indian Redmi note 5 pro (dual camera) is Redmi note 5 in china..
alimsona said:
Global redmi note 5 (single camera ) is Redmi 5 plus in china.
Global Redmi note 5 pro (dual camera) is Redmi note 5 in china..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You could have just refrain from commenting than confusing some one with wrong info.....FYI there is no global redmi note 5 pro.
raad.sobhan said:
You could have just refrain from commenting than confusing some one with wrong info.....FYI there is no global redmi note 5 pro.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are 2 version of Redmi Note 5 pro , 1 for china (redmi note 5) and another for global (redmi note 5 pro).. kindly first search on youtube regarding this..then you will know
alimsona said:
I'm using it...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Apparently you don't know what you are using! Or some third party retailer fooled you...official xiaomi sells pro varient only in India...there is a detail thread in MIUI forum from officials, you can learn more from there.
raad.sobhan said:
Apparently you don't know what you are using! Or some third party retailer fooled you...official xiaomi sells pro varient only in India...there is a detail thread in MIUI forum from officials, you can learn more from there.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh ok then its not global its indian version..now sounds better
the question actually is ....
why xda has sections with names that are only specific for India ?
kodorevi8ulis said:
the question actually is ....
why xda has sections with names that are only specific for India ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes I really don't understand all of this complexe and useless name.
If I not mistake, I own a note 5 pro but in France it's call note 5!.
I have dual camera, B20 bandwidth, snapdragon 636.
I read note 5 have snapdragon 625 and less 4g bandwich. Note 5 is only the Indian version and note 5 pro the global.
INo?! I'm going crazy!!?
kodorevi8ulis said:
the question actually is ....
why xda has sections with names that are only specific for India ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think because ReNo5 Pro (india) was released earlier than ReNo5 (CN/golbal)
Vink67 said:
Yes I really don't understand all of this complexe and useless name.
If I not mistake, I own a note 5 pro but in France it's call note 5!.
I have dual camera, B20 bandwidth, snapdragon 636.
I read note 5 have snapdragon 625 and less 4g bandwich. Note 5 is only the Indian version and note 5 pro the global.
INo?! I'm going crazy!!?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah, just like others said, the naming this time was really confusing.
India : Redmi Note 5 Pro (whyred, SD 636)
CN/Global : Redmi Note 5 (whyred, SD 636)
India : Redmi Note 5 (vince, SD 625)
CN/Global : Redmi 5 Plus (vince, SD 625)
so basically, there just 2 versions of Redmi Note 5, Indian version (RN5Pro) and CN/Global version (RN5)
so yeah, this forum is the correct one for your device
just make sure if u wanted to flash custom roms/mods, use the CN/Global version
kodorevi8ulis said:
the question actually is ....
why xda has sections with names that are only specific for India ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Coz they released whyred in India way earlier than China and Global. So xda made a placeholder with name Redmi Note 5 Pro. But seems like many global and china users want a separate section....they submitted a request to xda to separate RN5 Pro from RN5 China/Global. If you want to support that, then do so
For me, I'm fine with the name Redmi Note 5 Pro.
xtro-xda said:
I think because ReNo5 Pro (india) was released earlier than ReNo5 (CN/golbal)
yeah, just like others said, the naming this time was really confusing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
correct, but this was 2-3 months ago, can't the section renamed ?
@Ghoul159 i don't believe that the problem is to have different sections for rn5 and rn5pro (the rn5 the world has, not the one for india )
but i believe that the section must renamed to something like Redmi Note 5/5 Pro cause the device is the same (cammera's different) and after the latest roms (i think) they have also all camera's drivers included
the confusing section is the other, the Redmi Note 5/5 Plus , this has to be renamed , to something like Redmi 5 Plus/Note 5 India (sorry but 5 plus is the first released device and also the name is for all countries except india)
kodorevi8ulis said:
correct, but this was 2-3 months ago, can't the section renamed ?
@Ghoul159 i don't believe that the problem is to have different sections for rn5 and rn5pro (the rn5 the world has, not the one for india )
but i believe that the section must renamed to something like Redmi Note 5/5 Pro cause the device is the same (cammera's different) and after the latest roms (i think) they have also all camera's drivers included
the confusing section is the other, the Redmi Note 5/5 Plus , this has to be renamed , to something like Redmi 5 Plus/Note 5 India (sorry but 5 plus is the first released device and also the name is for all countries except india)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The other one is already renamed to Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 / 5 Plus. I don't know if they do this for pro too. But it's up to xda. And I just that said many global users are wishing to separate RN5 Pro altogether and create a new section for RN5 global/china users coz of slight hardware diff. This is kinda absurd imo. But I support changing name to Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 / 5 Pro. It's possible only if more users submits a request to xda staff to change the name
xtro-xda said:
I think because ReNo5 Pro (india) was released earlier than ReNo5 (CN/golbal)
/Global : Redmi Note 5 (whyred, SD 636)
India : Redmi Note 5 (vince, SD 625)
CN/Global : Redmi 5 Plus (vince, SD 625)
so basically, there just 2 versions of Redmi Note 5, Indian version (RN5Pro) and CN/Global version (RN5)
so yeah, this forum is the correct one for your device
just make sure if u wanted to flash custom roms/mods, use the CN/Global version
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This confusing and no need complexity made me think of awful and silly name phone...
Hope this will help
Dear Folks,
can you please correct the subforum name? Redmi Note 5 Pro is only being sold in INDIA with this name. The whole other world calls the whyred "Redmi Note 5".
Thanks
This is correct and wrong... The correct name of forum should be Redmi note 5/pro or Redmi note 5 pro/ai
cRaZy-bisCuiT said:
Dear Folks,
can you please correct the subforum name? Redmi Note 5 Pro is only being sold in INDIA with this name. The whole other world calls the whyred "Redmi Note 5".
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pachenko_Gr said:
This is correct and wrong... The correct name of forum should be Redmi note 5/pro or Redmi note 5 pro/ai
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And your just adding to the confusion!
There is no AI version, even though some sites incorrectly labeling it as such.
There is Redmi Note 5 Global or China version and Pro Indian version all with the codename of WHYRED!
Indian version was release first, and that is when these forums where created and thus adopted the other versions.
Redmi 5 Plus ~~~ Redmi Note 5 [India] ~~~~ vince has it own forum under the RN5 name.
corkiejp said:
And your just adding to the confusion!
There is no AI version, even though some sites incorrectly labeling it as such.
There is Redmi Note 5 Global or China version and Pro Indian version all with the codename of WHYRED!
Indian version was release first, and that is when these forums where created and thus adopted the other versions.
Redmi 5 Plus ~~~ Redmi Note 5 [India] ~~~~ vince has it own forum under the RN5 name.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Still you get the impression India is the middle of the world. Shouldn't a device being called by it's international name when it's a international forum? Really ... that's no good explanation since it was clear from the very beginning that PRO will only be the indian version.
Just avoid any confusion, all the version is the same under codename WHYRED. Just rename it to Redmi Note 5 (WHYRED). DONE.
kuance said:
Just avoid any confusion, all the version is the same under codename WHYRED. Just rename it to Redmi Note 5 (WHYRED). DONE.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Remember that not everyone know its codename. Your suggestion would also confuse the Indian folks, so there is no "one-size-fits-all". I suggest it's left just the way it is right now.
corkiejp said:
And your just adding to the confusion!
There is no AI version, even though some sites incorrectly labeling it as such.
There is Redmi Note 5 Global or China version and Pro Indian version all with the codename of WHYRED!
Indian version was release first, and that is when these forums where created and thus adopted the other versions.
Redmi 5 Plus ~~~ Redmi Note 5 [India] ~~~~ vince has it own forum under the RN5 name.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
they call it AI when it was revealed in china video is in chinesse
raptorddd said:
they call it AI when it was revealed in china video is in chinesse
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Though just so you know, the "AI" bit isn't part of the official name. It's just something resellers have added because AI such a buzz word now.
It is Redmi Note 5 with AI Dual Camera, or in the screenshots the 'with' is dropped.
There is no "AI version". There are three different Redmi Note 5 models, the Indian version (sold by the name Redmi Note 5 Pro), the Chinese version (sold by the name Redmi Note 5) which has a different camera setup and there's also a Global version which is the same as the Chinese version but with additional LTE bands.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Xiaomi/wiki/specs/redminote5
They are all codenamed 'whyred' so their software is fully compatible in theory but some ROMs only support either version because the Indian and Chinese versions have different cameras.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://www.reddit.com/r/Xiaomi/comments/8l1clx/redmi_note_5_ai_and_pro/dzc3ua5
https://www.mi.com/sg/redmi-note-5/
I'm about to buy a phone called Redmi Note 5 Ai but it resembles the Pro one a lot. Are these two phones the same? If I purchase the Ai one, will I have any trouble using roms from this forum? Sorry if this has been asked before, I just got really confused and couldn't find the exact answer on the internet.
Hi
I bought Redmi Note 5 AI and all roms for Redmi note 5 pro do work.
Both Note 5 pro and Note 5 AI have the same codename (whyred), so all whyred roms work on AI and the PRO variants
Okay, thanks for the quick answer! Again, sorry if this is a common question and has been answered before.
cileklim said:
Okay, thanks for the quick answer! Again, sorry if this is a common question and has been answered before.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the pro is for indian region and AI is china and global difference is front camera pro is 20mpx and AI its 13mpx.
they use same firmware.