So, for five or six years, I had an original Pixel, rooted, and on it, Call Recorder worked flawlessly. I expected the same thing from the 3a, which I just picked up and rooted, but no. Every other call fails to record correctly. I wondered if any of you other 3a owners have managed to get SKVALEX's recorder working and if so, how you did it. Would be happy to flash another rom if that's what it takes. The recorder is the main thing I need out of my phone.
Emmalfal said:
So, for five or six years, I had an original Pixel, rooted, and on it, Call Recorder worked flawlessly. I expected the same thing from the 3a, which I just picked up and rooted, but no. Every other call fails to record correctly. I wondered if any of you other 3a owners have managed to get SKVALEX's recorder working and if so, how you did it. Would be happy to flash another rom if that's what it takes. The recorder is the main thing I need out of my phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Skvalex works fine with all custom ROMs I've tried; the thing is (I think) is to root your phone and use Magisk's Skvalex module (not the Skvalex app installed from app store). So pick any custom ROM ;-)
Tamsta_T said:
Skvalex works fine with all custom ROMs I've tried; the thing is (I think) is to root your phone and use Magisk's Skvalex module (not the Skvalex app installed from app store). So pick any custom ROM ;-)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, that thought finally occurred to me and I replaced my existing Call Record app with the one installed through the Magisk module. That didn't help. But today, I changed my recording setting from ROOT CAF to Voice uplink+downlink and THAT seems to have solved it. Would be curious to know what you're using under "audio source."
Emmalfal said:
Yeah, that thought finally occurred to me and I replaced my existing Call Record app with the one installed through the Magisk module. That didn't help. But today, I changed my recording setting from ROOT CAF to Voice uplink+downlink and THAT seems to have solved it. Would be curious to know what you're using under "audio source."
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use "auto (default)" and it works with stock 3a. V1.7.13 from Magisk module. Updates don't work.
Emmalfal said:
" (…) Would be curious to know what you're using under "audio source."
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Audio source: Voice call uplink + downlink. That's default setting, I've never changed that. App version 3.5.2.
Tamsta_T said:
Audio source: Voice call uplink + downlink. That's default setting, I've never changed that. App version 3.5.2.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, sweet. Maybe that was the issue after all. Mine defaulted to CAF for some reason. Maybe my settings got imported from my old phone initially. So far, changing it to uplink+downlink has it working. If that's all there is to it, I'll be thrilled. Appreciate your checking for me and for your help here.
mulperi said:
I use "auto (default)" and it works with stock 3a. V1.7.13 from Magisk module. Updates don't work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wonder if your default is uplink+downlink. That seems to be the trend on this phone. Good to know.
Emmalfal said:
I wonder if your default is uplink+downlink. That seems to be the trend on this phone. Good to know.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry, I was talking about the Axet's Call Recorder Magisk module, not Skavlex.
mulperi said:
Sorry, I was talking about the Axet's Call Recorder Magisk module, not Skavlex.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Heh. Gotcha. That one is on my list of apps to try in case I can't sort this issue out.
mulperi said:
Sorry, I was talking about the Axet's Call Recorder Magisk module, not Skavlex.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is the Axet recorder still working on your 3a? I'm having zero luck with Skvalex's Call Recorder. Works for a while and then fails when it's most important.
Still no love from the Skvalex recorder on the 3a. I'll think I have it nailed down and then it drops a call. Always seems to know when it's an important call, too. Aggravating. None of the other recording apps work at all for me so there's that..
Emmalfal said:
Still no love from the Skvalex recorder on the 3a. I'll think I have it nailed down and then it drops a call. Always seems to know when it's an important call, too. Aggravating. None of the other recording apps work at all for me so there's that..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Axet's Call Recorder Magisk module v1.0.1 by di72nn works well. In F-Droid it shows as version 1.7.13. I set F-Droid to bypass newer updates due to recording issues.
mulperi said:
Axet's Call Recorder Magisk module v1.0.1 by di72nn works well. In F-Droid it shows as version 1.7.13. I set F-Droid to bypass newer updates due to recording issues.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried Axet and it produced a really low caller volume. Are you using it on a 3a? I'm starting to think this phone simply does not play well with recorders, because I've tried several at this point. Am considering installing a different rom to see if that helps, although I really haven't messed with roms in many years.
Emmalfal said:
I tried Axet and it produced a really low caller volume. Are you using it on a 3a? I'm starting to think this phone simply does not play well with recorders, because I've tried several at this point. Am considering installing a different rom to see if that helps, although I really haven't messed with roms in many years.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, Pixel 3a. Works flawlessly.
mulperi said:
Yes, Pixel 3a. Works flawlessly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you on Android 12, as well? Wish I could figure this thing out. Call recorder worked flawlessly on my regular ol' Pixel.
Emmalfal said:
Are you on Android 12, as well? Wish I could figure this thing out. Call recorder worked flawlessly on my regular ol' Pixel.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, latest (last) stock Android 12 rom. Using v12.9 MVK kernel.
mulperi said:
Yes, latest (last) stock Android 12 rom. Using v12.9 MVK kernel.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, I'm stumped. Sounds like we have the same phone yet call recorders don't work properly on mine. Weirdness.
Emmalfal said:
Well, I'm stumped. Sounds like we have the same phone yet call recorders don't work properly on mine. Weirdness.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A final check:
You tried to install *this* as a Magisk Module? And not upgrade it in F-Droid?
https://github.com/di72nn/callrecorder-axet/releases/download/v1.0.1/callrecorder-axet-v1.0.1.zip
Reboot.
Then you need to give the app all permissions in Android; mic, phone...
App Settings: Recording Source: Auto (default), Sample rate: 16Khz. Encoding: mp3, Disable battery optimizations: Yes, System Mixer Incall Recording: No.
Turn on call recording in app.
mulperi said:
A final check:
You tried to install *this* as a Magisk Module? And not upgrade it in F-Droid?
https://github.com/di72nn/callrecorder-axet/releases/download/v1.0.1/callrecorder-axet-v1.0.1.zip
Reboot.
Then you need to give the app all permissions in Android; mic, phone...
App Settings: Recording Source: Auto (default), Sample rate: 16Khz. Encoding: mp3, Disable battery optimizations: Yes, System Mixer Incall Recording: No.
Turn on call recording in app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did it three different ways that I recall. Installed Call Recorder straight from SKvalex's page, had problems, tried something else. Installed as a Magisk module, had problems, tried something else. After that, I installed it as a straight program again, although I don't remember from where. Still having problems. Doesn't seem to matter
where I install from. And I'm careful every time to make sure it has all the permissions, exclusion from battery optimizations, etc. It's just mystifying.
Emmalfal said:
I did it three different ways that I recall. Installed Call Recorder straight from SKvalex's page, had problems, tried something else. Installed as a Magisk module, had problems, tried something else. After that, I installed it as a straight program again, although I don't remember from where. Still having problems. Doesn't seem to matter
where I install from. And I'm careful every time to make sure it has all the permissions, exclusion from battery optimizations, etc. It's just mystifying.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is *NOT* Skavlex's Call recorder but Axet's.
Related
Hi,
I am in process of transferring from HTC to Xperia Z1 Compact.
One of the most important aps is Call Recorder by Skvalex.
Have tried version 1.52, but recording does not work.
Has anybody had success in using Skvalex Call Recorder, which version and settings.
I am on RomAur v1.2 and it claims call that recording will work, but it doesn't.
Can not use any other recorder, as I like to keep all past recordings.
Thanks!
Would help if you could tell us in detail about the issue. Could you elaborate the issue? Is it crashing? Can't record? Corrupt sound file? No sound? can't install from playstore?
Does it work generelly for people?
Skickat från min C5503 via Tapatalk
I used it wit z1 as model amr but it's a hit or miss. Some times it record some time does not. I've mailed skvalex already. He is a great dev in past replying to mails promptly. So we'll see
Sent from my D5503 using Tapatalk
fixed
Lasantha said:
I used it wit z1 as model amr but it's a hit or miss. Some times it record some time does not. I've mailed skvalex already. He is a great dev in past replying to mails promptly. So we'll see
Sent from my D5503 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
just confirmed with dev.use lg nexus 5 as devise and everything works.loud and clear:good::good::good::good:
Tried it, works very good even without root!
Device = "other", recording method = "Android API", audio source = "voice uplink+voice downlink".
avs333 said:
Tried it, works very good even without root!
Device = "other", recording method = "Android API", audio source = "voice uplink+voice downlink".
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
on romaur call recorder worked without problems with alsa as recording method, but now i´m on cm based kitkat rom and it is not working with any method (no other call recording app i´ve tested is working), i have not tested stock kitkat
funiewski said:
cm based kitkat
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Interesting, thanks for info, will see to it in a couple of days
avs333 said:
Interesting, thanks for info, will see to it in a couple of days
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
got solution from @skvalex, in settings choice nexus5 as device
funiewski said:
got solution from @skvalex, in settings choice nexus5 as device
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
oh nice! that's spares me from installing cyan soon
LG Nexus 5 + standard API method + default audio source (not up/down link) seem to work OK.
Nope, it only catches the other party through the microphone (no sound if mic switched off).
Tried other settings, no luck so far ...
This is my settings, if you have root there i no better app for call recording than skvalex
hm, can't judge due to lack of signatures, but I suspect those reporting it as working are on 4.4 Kitkat.
Does it work for anybody on stock 4.3? I think I tried every reasonable option and it does not record from the line on my Z1C ...
Will be grateful for a confirmation.
gpietron said:
hm, can't judge due to lack of signatures, but I suspect those reporting it as working are on 4.4 Kitkat.
Does it work for anybody on stock 4.3? I think I tried every reasonable option and it does not record from the line on my Z1C ...
Will be grateful for a confirmation.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It worked from very first sw version to latest.I use caf with nexes 5 4.3 worked fine
I know its been discussed but can't find a solution.
Trying to record both recipient and caller (in other words, both people) on incoming and outgoing calls.
All the ones I have tried only record my phone and not the other person.
To clarify if Person A calls me I want to record them as well as me and if I call person A I want to record person A and me.
I'm thinking this requires a rooted phone?
jbuss2 said:
I'm thinking this requires a rooted phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AFAIK, yes... I use Call recorder by skvalex, also on android 7+ it needs audio patch...
Ja_som said:
AFAIK, yes... I use Call recorder by skvalex, also on android 7+ it needs audio patch...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
is the patch on the play store or something you side load?
tevil said:
is the patch on the play store or something you side load?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When you open the app, you will see warning about it. Or you can find it here on XDA
Ja_som said:
When you open the app, you will see warning about it. Or you can find it here on XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks, wow 10$ tho
Is there a way to enable native call recording in this device? I bought a simcard from thailand but I'm not able to change CSC in my country is legal to record calls.
with root I have enabled call recording.
chieco said:
with root I have enabled call recording.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How did you enabled it?
My device S20 Ultra is rooted too, but i'm not be able to enable call recording and other csc stuff, because cant edit cscsfeature.xml.
Thanks
you need:
working magisk
magisk modules: riru (riru - core), riru - edxposed
the app: edxposed manager
the xposed module: firefds kit (q)
in firefds kit (q) under phone enable call recording
congratulations you now can record the secrets of other on the telephone without them knowing hehehe.....
will i lose my data after rooting ?
rientkill1 said:
will i lose my data after rooting ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
try skyvalex betta 3.3.5 beta01. works for me but dont update cause voice become low volume.
keionp said:
try skyvalex betta 3.3.5 beta01. works for me but dont update cause voice become low volume.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Could you please post the link? I cannot find it
hugoglezp said:
Could you please post the link? I cannot find it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
page 836. sorry dont know how to add link, its on skvalex tread
https://forum.xda-developers.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=4969711&d=1584024461
Got it, thanks but on the other side I still hear voice very low. Have you changed any special settings?
hugoglezp said:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=4969711&d=1584024461
Got it, thanks but on the other side I still hear voice very low. Have you changed any special settings?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
good you found it. no i havent change anything. i tried to change settings cause it fails to record, so i keep it as it is. I also email cube acr which i normally use, and they said they're working on it. Oh yeah also be carefull using cleaners as they will delete recordings. im using built in cleaner and ccleaner and sdmaid, but i dont know which one deletes the recordings.
Hi,
I want to know if it's possible to record phone calls native? I assume this phone is being shipped with Google Dailer.
Is there way to still record phone calls (root or nonroot) that it doesn't notify the other caller just like in the native dailer of Google.
Magisk Module "Call Recorder - SVALEX" is running well here.
By theory if you are able to convert it to international and, also flash nolimits module, you will be able to enable native call record in the dialer settings. This is what I always did. Again, I can't confirm that this works on the 9 because I don't have it but, this has worked on the 6,7,8. Just trying to assist and, I myself refuse to run a phone without native call record.
dlareghoe said:
Magisk Module "Call Recorder - SVALEX" is running well here.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do I need to pay for it to make it work ones trial expired? I just need simple call recording. Nothing fancy.
Thank you for time
netgar said:
Do I need to pay for it to make it work ones trial expired? I just need simple call recording. Nothing fancy.
Thank you for time
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yap, it is 9.99 Euro, and it IS fancy. There are some things an switches to configure. Some important for me (encrypting the records), some don't (filter, who is recorded, who don't).
I use Jone plus tools with EU OTA. Always worked. Just require the Call Recorder Service option to be picked up.
I use axet's call recorder module from magisk. It is free. Only you have to remember to open call recording app once you reboot phone.
I've been using joneplus with oneplus' native call app, but it was not working good for me. If I put the phone to my ear before the call was answered, it did not work at all.
Used svalex version from magisk also and did not see any big difference compared to axet's. Had to open the app every reboot too.
To sum up, I stick to axet's as long as there is better way to record calls.
Steve0007 said:
I use Jone plus tools with EU OTA. Always worked. Just require the Call Recorder Service option to be picked up.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But you need to use the oneplus dialer for that and not the Google dialer that comes as the default dialer?
hallo dare said:
But you need to use the oneplus dialer for that and not the Google dialer that comes as the default dialer?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Install like any normal apk. Then set them as default thru Settings (default for messages, phone). Deactive the Google ones again thru Settings/Applications & notifications/Show all applications and pick up those Google to deactive them
Steve0007 said:
Install like any normal apk. Then set them as default thru Settings (default for messages, phone). Deactive the Google ones again thru Settings/Applications & notifications/Show all applications and pick up those Google to deactive them
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes i have all installed. I just thought from your comment that you'd found a way to have the Google dialer work with the joneplus call recorder.
Steve0007 said:
Install like any normal apk. Then set them as default thru Settings (default for messages, phone). Deactive the Google ones again thru Settings/Applications & notifications/Show all applications and pick up those Google to deactive them
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you have to wait for someone you call to pick up the phone before you put the phone to your ear to call record work? Had this set up and if I forgot about this my call hadn't been recorded.
dlareghoe said:
Magisk Module "Call Recorder - SVALEX" is running well here.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh, serious? And could you post some screenshot how it looks like where the records being stored, and the settings of SKVALEX?
dlareghoe said:
Magisk Module "Call Recorder - SVALEX" is running well here.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do I need to pay for it to make it work ones trial expired? I just need simple call recording. Nothing fancy.
Thank you for
I switched to axet's call recorder since it is free, also like the other Call Recorder - SVALEX requires to be launch after each reboot.
I miss xxx magisk ROM
Steve0007 said:
Install like any normal apk. Then set them as default thru Settings (default for messages, phone). Deactive the Google ones again thru Settings/Applications & notifications/Show all applications and pick up those Google to deactive them
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which version is the native phone dialer you post it?
netgar said:
I switched to axet's call recorder since it is free, also like the other Call Recorder - SVALEX requires to be launch after each reboot.
I miss xxx magisk ROM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you mean with " I miss the xxx magisk Rom?"
Is there no ROM then?
Also how works axet call recorder? How is the sound? Could you send some screenshots of the settings of axet call recording.
GitHub - di72nn/callrecorder-axet: Magisk module for installing axet's Call Recorder app
Magisk module for installing axet's Call Recorder app - GitHub - di72nn/callrecorder-axet: Magisk module for installing axet's Call Recorder app
github.com
aygul12345 said:
What do you mean with " I miss the xxx magisk Rom?"
Is there no ROM then?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I used this ROM on my op7pro
netgar said:
I used this ROM on my op7pro
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you run now these days then?
scorpio76r said:
By theory if you are able to convert it to international and, also flash nolimits module, you will be able to enable native call record in the dialer settings. This is what I always did. Again, I can't confirm that this works on the 9 because I don't have it but, this has worked on the 6,7,8. Just trying to assist and, I myself refuse to run a phone without native call record.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly, I'm in the same boat as you. Always had a phone with native call recorder. Which phone you running these days?
aygul12345 said:
What do you run now these days then?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
9pro... and so far no custom ROM available.
Hi all!
Looking through some threads here and Swedroid, I'd just like to confirm if there's a non-root way of enabling call recording on the 10 III, running stock Android 11. On OnePlus 5 I could just unlock the native recorder over ADB, but the 10 III doesn't have anything to unlock regardless of region, is this correct?
I've found instructions on rooting + Magisk to get call recording to work, but thought I'd doublecheck if that's my only option – call recording is the only feature I'm interested in, so would rather skip the whole process if I can avoid it…
Cheers and merry Christmas all!
/LP
Longpiglet said:
I'd just like to confirm if there's a non-root way of enabling call recording on the 10 III, running stock Android 11.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is correct. I do use True Phone with its Magisk module for call recording.
TrulyPain said:
That is correct. I do use True Phone with its Magisk module for call recording.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the quick reply. Guess I'll look into the root route.
Really annoyed with Sony tossing this function…
I've installed true phone and it records OK. Do I need to install the Magisk Module anyway? What does it improves?
CaptainMaki said:
I've installed true phone and it records OK. Do I need to install the Magisk Module anyway? What does it improves?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm amazed True Phone seems to work without root or Magisk
This was the one reason I've allways rooted, which lately has caused problems in bank apps fpr me.
Now I don't have too root and get sufficient call recording
I'm curious how they do it, thou?......
Edit a little later....
Doesn't work very well....Root seems needed